Unearth The Voyage
New Jersey is famous for its pizza, but some of the best pizza joints in the Garden State are hiding another secret weapon: lasagna that will make you rethink everything you thought you knew about Italian comfort food. These spots serve up bubbling, cheesy, sauce-drenched layers of pasta perfection alongside their famous pies. Whether you’re a lifelong lasagna lover or just looking for your next food obsession, these restaurants prove that you don’t have to choose between pizza and pasta when both are this good.
1. Trattoria La Sorrentina, North Bergen
If there’s such a thing as destination lasagna, you’ll find it at Trattoria La Sorrentina in North Bergen. Multiple food critics and outlets have crowned their Lasagna Napoletana the best in New Jersey and one of the top picks in America. Each bite delivers perfectly layered ricotta, gooey mozzarella, savory meat, and a rich tomato sauce that’s been baked until it collapses into a cheesy, saucy brick of pure comfort.
Despite all the hype and national recognition, this spot still feels like a cozy neighborhood pizza place where locals gather. You can order classic pies right alongside that famous lasagna. It’s the kind of restaurant where you come for the reputation but stay because it genuinely feels like home, with every dish made to satisfy your deepest Italian food cravings.
2. Bella Trattoria e Pizzeria, Guttenberg
At Bella Trattoria e Pizzeria in Guttenberg, the menu lists Nonna’s Lasagna under the pasta section, and it’s every bit as comforting as the name suggests. Baked layers of pasta are stacked with creamy ricotta, seasoned ground beef, tangy tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella that bubbles and browns on top. Each forkful delivers that perfect balance of cheese, meat, and sauce.
This is a true hybrid spot where you can order Grandma-style pies or loaded specialty pizzas, then follow it with a bubbling dish of lasagna. The restaurant proudly advertises homemade pasta and traditional Italian specialties, so you know everything is made with care. It’s the kind of place where you can satisfy every Italian craving in one visit without compromising on quality or authenticity.
3. Brix Restaurant & Pizza Bar, Belleville
Brix Restaurant & Pizza Bar is a lively Italian spot with brick-oven pizzas, craft cocktails, and live entertainment, but don’t sleep on the pasta menu hiding some serious gems. Their Lasagna al Forno shows up on the dinner menu as a seven-layer traditional meat-sauce lasagna that’s rich, hearty, and exactly what you want after a long week. The layers are stacked high and packed with flavor.
Delivery platforms and review sites list Brix as open daily with a full pizza menu and late-night hours, making it an easy go-to spot when you want lasagna with a side of people-watching and a bar vibe. You can enjoy your meal with a drink in hand while soaking up the energy of the room. It’s perfect for date night or a group outing when you want good food and good vibes.
4. Vinni’s Pizzarama, Wayne
Family-owned since 1979, Vinni’s Pizzarama is exactly the kind of old-school Jersey pizza joint you hope still exists when you’re craving authentic Italian food. Walk in and you’ll see the neon sign glowing, the long counter stretching across the room, and fresh slices waiting in the case. Their own website proudly brags that they serve all of your favorite authentic Italian dishes like Nonna made it, including their homemade lasagna.
Grab a classic New York-style pie for the group, then split an order of the house lasagna if you want the full raised-on-red-sauce experience. The lasagna here tastes like it came straight from someone’s grandmother’s kitchen. It’s hearty, traditional, and loaded with flavor that reminds you why simple Italian cooking never goes out of style in New Jersey.
5. Bella Trattoria’s Cousin in Spirit: Mangia Trattoria Pizzeria, Delran
In Delran, Mangia Trattoria Pizzeria bills itself as an Italian kitchen and pizzeria rolled into one delicious package. On its online ordering menu, you’ll find Lasagna al Forno described as classic baked lasagna, sitting right alongside a long list of pizzas and Italian entrees. The lasagna here is traditional, comforting, and made with all the right ingredients to satisfy your cravings.
ToastTab and delivery listings show it as open and taking orders, which makes it a reliable pick when you want a giant tray of lasagna without giving up the option of a classic cheese pie. You don’t have to choose between pasta and pizza here because both are done right. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or just treating yourself, Mangia delivers the kind of Italian comfort food that never disappoints and always hits the spot.
6. Mangia Brick Oven Pizza, Toms River
Mangia Brick Oven Pizza in Toms River is known for its creative pizzas and pasta dishes, but one TripAdvisor reviewer went out of their way to call it the best lasagna on the Jersey Shore. They described a huge tray of lasagna brought buffet-style to the table, piled high and perfect for sharing. When lasagna is served like that, you know it’s serious.
Their current online menu leans hard into pizzas, but the review and local buzz suggest that when lasagna appears here, it’s over-the-top and shareable. It’s definitely the kind of thing you build a group night around. Imagine gathering your friends or family, ordering a few pies, and then dropping a massive tray of lasagna in the center of the table. That’s the Mangia experience, and it’s one that keeps people coming back for more.
7. Dicola’s Pizza, Washington
At first glance, Dicola’s Pizza looks like a classic small-town pizzeria, and it absolutely is, but their website also highlights Baked Homemade Lasagna as one of the house specialties. That tells you everything you need to know about their priorities: they care just as much about their pasta as they do about their pies. The lasagna is homemade, hearty, and full of that comforting red-sauce flavor.
Google and menu aggregators still list Dicola’s as open with current hours, and customers mention hearty Italian dinners alongside the pies. If you’re the kind of person who orders a slice for the table, this is the kind of place where you follow that slice with a bubbling pan of lasagna. It’s unpretentious, delicious, and exactly what you want from a neighborhood Italian spot that’s been feeding the community for years.
8. Soprano’s Pizzeria, Bridgewater
Soprano’s Pizzeria in Bridgewater is your classic strip-mall pizza shop with a surprisingly deep pasta section that’s worth exploring. Their online menu specifically lists Lasagna with Meat, served as a baked pasta dish with sauce and cheese that’s hearty and satisfying. It’s the kind of lasagna that reminds you why Italian-American comfort food is so beloved in New Jersey.
The same menu page shows a full lineup of pies, including cheese, Sicilian, and specialty pizzas, so you can treat it as either your weeknight slice joint or a red-sauce and lasagna sit-down option. The versatility makes it perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on the way home or settling in for a full Italian feast, Soprano’s has you covered with quality food and generous portions that won’t break the bank.
9. Brooklyn’s Pizza, Irvington
Under the Oven Baked Specials section on its online menu, Brooklyn’s Pizza in Irvington calls out Meat Lasagna right next to baked ziti and stuffed shells. The lasagna here is dense, cheesy, and packed with meat, giving you that satisfying slab of comfort food you crave when nothing else will do. It’s classic pizzeria lasagna done right, with generous portions and bold flavors.
This is an order-in favorite if you’re craving that dense, cheesy slab of lasagna but want it from a place that also does classic New York-style pies, wings, and all the usual pizzeria comfort foods. Delivery platforms list it as open and delivering across the area, making it convenient for weeknight dinners or lazy weekend meals. You can build a full Italian feast without leaving your couch, and everything arrives hot and ready to devour.
10. A Legna Wood Fire Pizza, Morristown
A Legna Wood Fire Pizza leans upscale-casual, with wood-fired pies and a polished dining room that feels a step above your typical pizzeria. But it doesn’t stop at pizza. Their online menu includes a Lasagna in the pasta section, served alongside dishes like rigatoni alla vodka and other homestyle pastas. The lasagna here is crafted with the same attention to detail as their wood-fired pies.
If you’re in Morristown and want a place where you can order a Neapolitan-style pie and a serious lasagna in the same sitting, this is the move. The atmosphere is welcoming but refined, making it perfect for a special dinner or a night out when you want quality Italian food in a comfortable setting. Everything is made fresh, and the flavors are bold without being overwhelming, striking that perfect balance.
11. Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza, Northfield
Down the shore, Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza in Northfield is known for its coal-fired pies and Italian comfort food that locals can’t get enough of. Their own menu highlights Housemade Lasagna, emphasizing that it’s prepared in-house rather than a generic add-on. That means every layer is carefully crafted, from the pasta to the sauce to the cheese, and it shows in every bite.
The restaurant’s site and reservation platforms list regular hours and note that it’s a popular local hangout, so it’s a good choice if you’re looking for a lasagna-and-pizza night near Atlantic County. The vibe is casual and friendly, perfect for families or groups of friends. You can enjoy the best of both worlds here: crispy, smoky coal-fired pizza and rich, comforting lasagna that tastes like it was made with love in someone’s home kitchen.
12. Solo Trattoria, Freehold
Solo Trattoria in Freehold is a trattoria first and a pizza spot second, but it absolutely earns a place on any New Jersey lasagna list. The dinner menu lists Lasagna Classica all’Emiliana, described as homemade bechamel lasagna in the Emilian style. This isn’t your typical red-sauce lasagna; it’s creamy, rich, and made with a technique that comes straight from northern Italy, offering a different but equally delicious take on the classic dish.
Food features and local press call out this lasagna as one of the restaurant’s star dishes, and Solo is frequently praised for its house-made pastas and classic Italian comfort food. The attention to detail is obvious in every dish. If you’re looking for something a little more refined but still deeply comforting, this is the spot that delivers elegance and flavor in equal measure.
13. Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza, Elizabeth
Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza is a New Jersey institution, famous worldwide for its old-school brick-oven pies that have been drawing crowds for decades. Hidden among the wild pizza options is their Lasagna Pizza, a pizza built to taste like lasagna, typically topped with ricotta, mozzarella, meat, and sauce. While it’s technically pizza and not a pan of pasta, it hits all the lasagna notes and satisfies that craving in a totally unique way.
This creation comes from a shop that’s been slinging pies for decades, with updated menu pages and ordering info confirming they’re still very much in business. The Lasagna Pizza is a testament to the creativity and tradition that make Santillo’s a legend in the pizza world. It’s the perfect choice when you can’t decide between pizza and lasagna because you get the best of both in one incredible slice.
