Unearth The Voyage
If the scent of warm butter and cinnamon sparks memories of Oma’s kitchen, you are in the right place. These underrated Dutch bakeries across the U.S. and beyond serve pastries that taste like they were pulled from a family recipe tin.
From flaky banket to caramel-laced stroopwafels, every stop offers comfort you can hold. Bring your appetite and a little curiosity, and let’s chase that nostalgic bite.
1. Holland American Bakery – Sussex, NJ
Walk into Holland American Bakery and it feels like stepping into Oma’s pantry. The pastry case brims with almond-filled banket, sugar-dusted boterkoek, and crisp speculaas that snap just right.
You taste butter, spice, and tradition in every bite.
Grab a loaf of hearty Dutch crunch bread and ask for a slice of raisin brodje for the road. The team happily explains the story behind each classic.
Come early, because locals know the good stuff vanishes quickly.
2. Lynden Dutch Bakery – Lynden, WA
Lynden Dutch Bakery hums with small-town warmth and big-time flavor. You will spot towering trays of Dutch letters, their flaky S-shapes packed with fragrant almond paste.
Stroopwafels are pressed to order so the caramel stays velvety and warm.
Pair a slice of appeltaart with coffee and settle by the window to people-watch. Everything here tastes like a memory you did not know you missed.
Take a box home because tomorrow will ask for seconds.
3. Dutch Baby Bakery – New York, NY
In the city that never sleeps, Dutch Baby Bakery delivers comfort fast. Golden Dutch baby cups arrive puffed and tender, ready for lemon, powdered sugar, or cinnamon apples.
Poffertjes sizzle on the griddle, butter melting into every tiny pillow.
Grab a box of kletskoppen for the train and a stroopwafel latte for the walk. The vibe is modern, but flavors stay rooted in tradition.
You will leave with sticky fingers and a happy grin.
4. Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery – Colorado Springs, CO
Boonzaaijer’s is a Colorado Springs treasure where European technique meets Dutch soul. The tompouce slices are neatly layered with custard and pink icing that gleams under the lights.
Almond banket crackles at the first bite, releasing buttery warmth.
Order mocha cake if you love subtle coffee cream and featherlight sponge. Staff guide you through classics with patient pride.
Whether you hike or not, this is the summit you should reach.
5. Wonderen Stroopwafels – New York, NY
Wonderen Stroopwafels turns a simple Dutch classic into a show. You watch the irons press thin waffles, caramel oozing as the halves meet.
Add chocolate, hazelnuts, or crushed cookies, or keep it plain like Oma might have.
Warm, chewy, and fragrant with cinnamon, it is the pick-me-up you can eat while walking. Grab an extra for later because they cure mid-afternoon slumps.
Sweet comfort in a tidy circle.
6. Jaarsma Bakery – Pella, IA
Jaarsma is legendary, and the hype is justified. Their Dutch letters are textbook perfect, flaky pastry wrapped around silky almond paste that perfumes the whole shop.
Almond patties deliver a toasted crunch with creamy centers.
During Tulip Time, lines snake outside, but service moves quickly and kindly. Stock up on windmill cookies and rye bread for home.
You will think about those letters long after they are gone.
7. Steenstra’s Royal Dutch Bakery – Grandville, MI
Steenstra’s is the place for windmill speculaas that snap and spice just right. Aromas of clove, cinnamon, and nutmeg float through the aisles.
You can grab crisp bags for gifting and soft, buttery banket for yourself.
The team crafts with patience, keeping recipes simple and honest. Coffee plus a windmill cookie is a perfect afternoon ritual.
Expect to buy more than planned, and be glad you did.
8. deBoer Bakkerij & Dutch Brothers – Holland, MI
deBoer Bakkerij blends old-country recipes with a sunny cafe vibe. Krentenbollen studded with currants make excellent breakfast sandwiches.
Banket logs are flaky, glossy, and generously almonded, perfect for sharing or not sharing at all.
Stay for brunch if you can and pair pastries with strong coffee. The menu nods to Dutch roots without feeling fussy.
You leave fueled, cheerful, and a bit spoiled by the hospitality.
9. Dutch Bakery And Variety Foods – Ontario, CA
This Ontario spot doubles as bakery and pantry for Dutch cravings. Pick up buttery boterkoek, almond horns, and fruit vlaai by the slice.
Shelves carry drop licorice, hagelslag, and pantry staples that transport you instantly.
Ask for recommendations and you will leave with a curated snack haul. The prices are fair, and portions generous.
It is a one-stop errand for treats, gifts, and weeknight comfort.
10. Hagerstown Dutch Bakery – Hagerstown, MD
Hagerstown Dutch Bakery serves up heartwarming classics with zero pretense. Cinnamon rolls arrive sticky and generous, while apple fritters are packed with real fruit.
You will spot buttery cookies beside loaves of sandwich-ready bread.
It is the kind of place where staff remember regulars and first-timers feel welcome. Grab a box for the office and watch it vanish.
Simple, honest baking that tastes like home.
11. Stoltzfus Pa Dutch Baked Goods – New Castle, DE
At Stoltzfus, Pennsylvania Dutch comfort meets market energy. Shoofly pie offers that molasses crumb you crave, while whoopie pies deliver soft cake and creamy filling.
There are buttery cookies and glazed donuts that sell out first.
Ask what is warm and you will be steered right. Friendly faces, quick lines, and prices that make sharing easy.
Bring containers because you will overbuy and not regret it.
12. Dutch Maid Bakery – Tracy City, TN
Dutch Maid Bakery feels like a time capsule in the best way. Cream horns are filled to order so the shells stay crisp.
Apple turnovers flake beautifully, each layer carrying cinnamon warmth.
You can taste care in the dough and balance in the sweetness. Order an extra box because road trips require pastry insurance.
Friendly chat at the counter makes the stop even sweeter.
13. Holland Farms Bakery & Deli – Yorkville, NY
Holland Farms mixes bakery joy with deli practicality. Start with a filled donut or classic halfmoon cookie, then explore Dutch-style butter cookies and almond treats.
Coffee is strong, seats are plentiful, and service is brisk but kind.
Grab sandwiches for later and a box of pastries for now. This spot fuels busy days while satisfying nostalgia.
You will plan your next visit before leaving the parking lot.
14. Vander Veen’s The Dutch Store – Wyoming, MI
Vander Veen’s is part market, part bakery, and entirely delightful. Stock up on hagelslag, stroop, and cheeses, then grab banket and speculaas from the counter.
The selection reads like a love letter to Dutch pantries.
Staff help you find exactly what Oma would buy. You leave with flavors for breakfast, tea time, and late-night nibbling.
Consider it your Dutch supply run with treats included.
15. Various Bakers in Pennsylvania Dutch Country – PA Region
Pennsylvania Dutch Country is a pastry road trip waiting to happen. Markets brim with sticky buns, fastnachts, and tender whoopie pies that taste like childhood.
Shoofly pie offers caramelized depth and crumbly tops that pair perfectly with coffee.
Chat with vendors about family recipes and seasonal specialties. Bring cash, a cooler, and an open schedule.
You will discover new favorites with every mile and every bite.
