Unearth The Voyage
Indiana is home to a treasure trove of hidden bakery gems that locals cherish. Whether you’re a fan of donuts, pastries, or traditional breads, these 14 bakeries offer something special. Each spot offers its unique flavor, history, and charm. Discover these delightful places and savor what makes Indiana’s baking scene so special.
1. Heyerly’s Bakery (Ossian)
Hidden away in Ossian, Heyerly’s Bakery has been delighting locals since 1931. Known for their irresistible applesauce doughnuts, these treats are soft, perfectly spiced, and sugar-dusted. Morning crowds flock here, seeking these doughnuts that capture a taste of nostalgia.
The family-run atmosphere adds to its charm, with patrons always greeted with a warm smile. It’s a place where tradition meets taste.
A fun fact: they offer free coffee with your purchase, making each visit even more welcoming. A beloved spot, Heyerly’s is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of Indiana’s bakery heritage.
2. Conny’s Little German Breadshop (Peru)
Tucked in the quiet town of Peru, Conny’s Little German Breadshop offers a slice of Bavaria. Famous for gooey cinnamon rolls and pretzel rolls, their German-style breads surprise and delight.
Stepping inside feels like a journey to Germany, with the aromatic scent of freshly baked goods enveloping you. Their dedication to traditional recipes is evident in every bite.
Whether you’re craving a hearty loaf or a pastry, Conny’s has something to satisfy. The charm lies in its authenticity, bringing a taste of Europe to Indiana’s heartland.
3. Rise’n Roll Bakery & Deli (Middlebury)
Situated in Indiana’s Amish country, Rise’n Roll Bakery lures visitors with its renowned cinnamon-caramel donuts, affectionately dubbed “Amish crack.” These delights are a testament to the region’s rich baking tradition.
With a rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere, this bakery offers more than just donuts. Their deli provides a range of homemade products that capture the essence of Amish culinary arts.
The bakery’s humble appearance hides treasures that locals cherish. A visit here is a delightful exploration of taste and heritage.
4. Long’s Bakery (Indianapolis)
In the Haughville neighborhood of Indianapolis, Long’s Bakery has been a staple since 1951. Known for their legendary glazed yeast donuts, this no-frills shop operates on a cash-only basis.
Long lines form early on weekends, proof of their dedicated following. The simplicity of the place belies the quality and flavor of their offerings.
A piece of local history, Long’s is a must-visit for donut lovers. The taste of their donuts captures the essence of old-school baking at its best.
5. Titus Bakery & Deli (Lebanon)
Lebanon is home to Titus Bakery, celebrated for its signature Pershing treat. This family-run spot features a giant donut mural, inviting visitors with its colorful charm.
Inside, you’ll find a variety of pastries, from cinnamon rolls to their beloved maple-iced donuts. Each bite offers a taste of tradition and love.
The bakery’s warm atmosphere makes it a local favorite. With a commitment to quality and taste, Titus Bakery continues to charm its patrons.
6. Square Donuts Inc. (Terre Haute)
Breaking the round-doughnut mold, Square Donuts in Terre Haute offers a quirky twist on a classic treat. Their square-shaped donuts are both a visual and flavorful delight.
The bakery is a place where creativity meets tradition, providing a fun twist on an everyday snack. Each donut is crafted with care and attention to detail.
Known for its welcoming vibe, Square Donuts is a unique experience that delights visitors of all ages. A true Indiana gem.
7. Mary Lou Donuts (Lafayette)
Since 1961, Mary Lou Donuts has been serving up delicious treats in Lafayette. Their apple fritters, packed with fruit and cinnamon, are a local treasure.
The bakery’s retro charm adds to the experience, making it a beloved institution. The tiger-tail twist donuts are another favorite, capturing the essence of classic baking.
With consistent quality and warm service, Mary Lou Donuts remains a staple in the community, offering a comforting taste of nostalgia.
8. Café Babette Bakery (Indianapolis)
On Shelby Street, Café Babette Bakery is a haven for pastry aficionados. Known for their flaky croissants and sourdough, it’s a spot where creativity meets craftsmanship.
The bakery’s artisan style is evident in every bite, with seasonal twists keeping the offerings fresh and exciting. Arriving early is key, as items sell out fast.
A cherished spot in Indianapolis, Café Babette’s commitment to quality shines through, making it a must-visit for those seeking exceptional pastries.
9. Hilligoss Bakery (Brownsburg)
Behind its modest storefront, Hilligoss Bakery in Brownsburg is all about donuts. The lemon-filled and apple fritters with real apple chunks are particularly noteworthy.
The bakery’s dedication to quality shines through in each handmade treat. It’s a place where the simplicity of ingredients meets the artistry of baking.
Loved by locals, Hilligoss offers a warm, inviting atmosphere where every visit feels like coming home. A true hidden gem in Indiana’s baking scene.
10. Taylor’s Bakery (Indianapolis)
Marked by a bright red awning, Taylor’s Bakery has been an Indianapolis institution for decades. Their cream-filled long johns and moist cake donuts are legendary.
The vibrant atmosphere inside invites patrons to indulge in a variety of baked goods that showcase the bakery’s rich history and dedication to quality.
A cherished spot for locals, Taylor’s continues to delight with its timeless offerings and warm, welcoming service. It’s a bakery where tradition and taste go hand in hand.
11. Al’s Donuts (Indianapolis)
Since 1960, Al’s Donuts has been a staple in Indianapolis. Known for their classic glazed donuts made the old-fashioned way, this vintage building holds a piece of the city’s history.
The simplicity of their offerings highlights the quality and skill behind each donut. It’s a place where tradition is celebrated with every bite.
For those seeking a taste of nostalgia, Al’s provides a comforting experience that resonates with locals and newcomers alike.
12. Concannon’s Bakery & Café (Muncie)
In Muncie, Concannon’s Bakery & Café offers a mix of tradition and charm. Their pretzel-shaped glazed donuts are a delightful treat that locals adore.
The stone-cottage-style setting invites patrons to linger and enjoy a range of baked goods that celebrate classic flavors. It’s a spot where the ambiance is as inviting as the offerings.
A pillar in the community since 1959, Concannon’s continues to be a beloved gathering place for those seeking quality and comfort.
13. Hart Bakery & Gift Shop (Indianapolis)
Hart Bakery & Gift Shop in Indianapolis is a family-run establishment known for its breads and rolls. The crown potato bread, in particular, often sells out quickly.
With a rustic charm, the bakery offers a wide range of baked goods that reflect a commitment to tradition and quality. It’s a place where community meets craftsmanship.
Honored in local listings, Hart Bakery continues to delight with its timeless offerings and warm atmosphere, making it a cherished spot for bread enthusiasts.
14. Heidelberg Haus Bakery & Café (Indianapolis)
Blending bakery, café, and general store vibes, Heidelberg Haus brings a taste of Germany to Indianapolis. Known for springerle cookies and other traditional treats, it offers a cozy and hospitable atmosphere.
The charm lies in its authenticity, with each item reflecting the rich flavors of German baking. It’s a place where visitors can feel at home while exploring the culinary traditions of Europe.
A beloved spot, Heidelberg Haus is more than just a bakery; it’s a journey into the heart of German culture and hospitality.
