Unearth The Voyage
Florida is home to a vibrant Amish and Mennonite community, especially around Sarasota’s Pinecraft neighborhood, where traditional cooking meets sunshine-state living. These spots serve up hearty, homemade meals that taste like they came straight from a family farmhouse kitchen.
Whether you’re craving flaky pies, slow-cooked comfort food, or fresh-baked bread, these 13 destinations deliver honest-to-goodness flavor without the fuss.
1. Yoder’s Restaurant (Pinecraft/Sarasota): The “you came for pie, stayed for comfort food” classic
Walk into Yoder’s and you’ll immediately smell what makes this place legendary: buttery pie crusts, sizzling breakfast skillets, and the kind of slow-cooked comfort food that feels like a warm hug. Nestled in Pinecraft, the heart of Florida’s Amish community, this restaurant has been drawing locals and tourists for decades.
People come for the pies and end up ordering meatloaf, fried chicken, and mashed potatoes that taste like Sunday dinner at Grandma’s house.
Breakfast here is no joke. Pancakes are fluffy, eggs are cooked exactly how you ask, and the portions are generous enough to fuel a full day of sightseeing.
If you arrive during lunch or dinner, expect hearty plates of roast beef, turkey with stuffing, and sides that rotate daily.
The dining room has that nostalgic, no-frills vibe where the focus is purely on the food. Service is friendly and efficient, with staff who know the menu by heart.
And yes, you absolutely should save room for pie. The peanut butter cream and strawberry rhubarb are customer favorites, but honestly, you can’t go wrong with any slice they serve.
2. Yoder’s “New Market” Deli & Grab-and-Go (same complex): Sandwiches + take-home goodness
Right next door to the main restaurant, Yoder’s New Market Deli is where you go when you want all the flavor but less sit-down time. This bustling market and deli combo lets you grab a sandwich, stock up on local jams, or pick up ready-made meals to enjoy later.
It’s perfect for beachgoers, road-trippers, or anyone who wants to take a little Amish cooking back to their hotel or vacation rental.
The deli counter serves up thick sandwiches piled high with fresh-sliced meats, crisp veggies, and homemade spreads. You can also find salads, soups, and daily hot specials that change based on what’s fresh.
The market shelves are stocked with locally made goods, from pickles and relishes to baked treats and specialty pantry items you won’t find at a regular grocery store.
There’s also a gift shop attached, making it easy to browse for souvenirs or kitchen goodies while you wait for your order. Locals love stopping by to pick up dinner ingredients or a quick lunch between errands.
It’s casual, convenient, and packed with the same quality you expect from the Yoder’s name.
3. Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co.: Take a whole pie home (or to the beach)
Some people plan their entire Florida vacation around picking up a whole pie from Yoder’s, and honestly, that’s not an exaggeration. Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co. makes it ridiculously easy to order fresh-baked pies for any occasion, whether you’re hosting a family gathering, celebrating a birthday, or just really, really love pie.
These aren’t your average grocery-store desserts. Each one is made from scratch using traditional recipes that have been passed down through generations.
The pie selection changes seasonally, but classics like apple crumb, key lime, and coconut cream are almost always available. If you’re feeling adventurous, try the shoofly pie, a molasses-based Pennsylvania Dutch specialty that’s sweet, gooey, and totally unique.
You can order ahead online or by phone, then swing by to pick it up fresh.
Coffee lovers will appreciate the coffee bar, which serves up hot and iced drinks to pair with a slice. It’s a cozy little spot where you can sit and enjoy a piece before taking the rest to go.
Bringing a Yoder’s pie to the beach or a picnic is a total power move, and your friends will thank you.
4. Der Dutchman Restaurant (Sarasota): Pinecraft homestyle plates
Der Dutchman is the kind of place where you roll in hungry and roll out happy, full, and probably planning your next visit. Located in the same Pinecraft neighborhood as Yoder’s, this restaurant serves up homestyle cooking that hits all the comfort-food notes: tender roast chicken, slow-cooked pot roast, creamy mashed potatoes, and vegetables that actually taste like vegetables.
Everything is made in-house, and the portions are designed to satisfy even the biggest appetites.
The menu rotates daily, so there’s always something new to try alongside the classics. Breakfast is a big deal here, with options like fluffy pancakes, hearty omelets, and biscuits with sausage gravy that could make you weep with joy.
Lunch and dinner lean heavily into traditional Amish and Mennonite dishes, with plenty of casseroles, stuffing, and sides that feel like a trip back in time.
One of the highlights is the in-house bakery, which churns out fresh bread, rolls, pies, and cookies throughout the day. You can smell the baking as soon as you walk in, and it’s nearly impossible to leave without grabbing something sweet.
The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, with big tables that encourage group meals and conversation.
5. Der Dutchman Bakery Counter (same building): Stock up on pies, cookies, breads, and sweets
Even if you’re not in the mood for a full meal, Der Dutchman’s bakery counter is worth a visit all on its own. This is where the magic happens: rows of fresh-baked pies, cookies the size of your hand, soft dinner rolls, and loaves of bread that are still warm from the oven.
It’s a paradise for anyone with a sweet tooth or a love for homemade baked goods.
The bakery case is always packed with seasonal favorites and year-round classics. Fruit pies, cream pies, and custard pies sit alongside cinnamon rolls, brownies, and frosted sugar cookies.
You can buy by the slice or take home a whole pie, and they’ll box everything up carefully so it travels well.
Locals know to stop by early in the day for the best selection, especially on weekends when things sell out fast. The bakers start working before dawn, and everything is made from scratch using traditional recipes.
If you’re planning a potluck, picnic, or family gathering, grabbing a few pies from Der Dutchman is a guaranteed crowd-pleaser. Even if you’re just treating yourself, a fresh cinnamon roll and a cup of coffee is a perfect mid-morning pick-me-up.
6. Detwiler’s Farm Market (Palmer, Sarasota)
Detwiler’s Farm Market in Palmer is part grocery store, part deli, and all about fresh, quality food that tastes like it came straight from the farm. This location is one of several Detwiler’s stores scattered around the Sarasota area, and each one has a loyal following of shoppers who appreciate the Mennonite roots and commitment to wholesome, homemade-style meals.
The deli counter is a major draw, serving up made-to-order subs, sandwiches, and daily hot food specials that change throughout the week.
Walking through the aisles, you’ll find fresh produce, bulk foods, baking supplies, and specialty items you won’t see at a typical supermarket. The store has a farmhouse feel, with wooden shelves, handwritten signs, and a laid-back vibe that makes grocery shopping actually enjoyable.
The deli staff are friendly and fast, and they don’t skimp on the sandwich fillings.
Whether you’re stocking up for the week or just grabbing lunch, the Palmer location offers the same quality and value that Detwiler’s is known for. The bakery section is also worth checking out, with fresh bread, cookies, and pastries baked daily.
It’s a one-stop shop for anyone who values fresh ingredients and homemade flavor.
7. Detwiler’s Farm Market (Venice)
Detwiler’s Farm Market in Venice brings the same farm-fresh philosophy to the southern edge of Sarasota County. This location is popular with locals who want a break from big-box grocery stores and prefer shopping somewhere that feels more personal and community-focused.
The deli is a standout feature, offering hot meals, cold sandwiches, and grab-and-go options that make lunch easy and delicious.
Inside, you’ll find aisles stocked with bulk grains, spices, snacks, and baking essentials, along with a produce section that emphasizes seasonal and local items. The store layout is simple and easy to navigate, and the staff are always happy to help you find what you need or recommend a new product.
The deli menu includes classic subs, wraps, and daily specials that rotate based on what’s available and what the kitchen crew feels inspired to make.
Many shoppers come in just for the deli sandwiches, which are loaded with fresh ingredients and made to order. The bakery section also gets plenty of attention, with pies, cookies, and breads that are baked fresh every day.
It’s a great spot to pick up dinner ingredients, a quick lunch, or a treat for later.
8. Detwiler’s Farm Market (University, Sarasota)
Located near the University Parkway corridor, this Detwiler’s Farm Market is one of the busiest in the Sarasota area. It’s a favorite among families, retirees, and anyone who values fresh food and friendly service.
The deli counter here is always hopping, with a steady stream of customers ordering subs, salads, and hot meals throughout the day. The sandwiches are generous, the ingredients are fresh, and the prices are fair.
Beyond the deli, the store offers a full range of groceries, from pantry staples to specialty items like local honey, homemade jams, and bulk nuts and grains. The produce section is well-stocked with seasonal fruits and vegetables, and the bakery churns out fresh bread, cookies, and pastries daily.
It’s the kind of place where you can do your weekly shopping and grab lunch at the same time.
The University location is known for its clean, organized layout and helpful staff. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, you’ll feel welcome and well taken care of.
Many customers make Detwiler’s their go-to spot for quick, wholesome meals that don’t require cooking or cleanup. It’s convenience and quality rolled into one.
9. Detwiler’s Farm Market (Palmetto)
Just across the bridge from Bradenton, the Palmetto location of Detwiler’s Farm Market serves the northern part of the Sarasota-Bradenton metro area. This store has the same welcoming, farm-market feel as the other Detwiler’s locations, with a strong emphasis on fresh food, homemade-style meals, and friendly service.
The deli is a big reason people keep coming back, offering made-to-order subs, wraps, and daily hot specials that change throughout the week.
The market section is well-stocked with bulk foods, baking supplies, and specialty grocery items that reflect the Mennonite heritage behind the brand. You’ll find everything from stone-ground flours to homemade jellies, along with fresh produce and a bakery section that’s always busy.
The deli staff work quickly and efficiently, even during the lunch rush, and they’re happy to customize your order however you like.
Many locals stop by on their way home from work to pick up dinner, whether that’s a hot meal from the deli or ingredients to cook at home. The Palmetto location is also popular with families, who appreciate the kid-friendly options and reasonable prices.
It’s a solid, dependable spot for fresh, homemade-style food without the fuss.
10. Detwiler’s Farm Market (Clark, Sarasota)
The Clark Road location of Detwiler’s Farm Market is tucked into a busy commercial area, but once you step inside, it feels like a world away from the usual grocery-store chaos. This store has the same farm-fresh philosophy and Mennonite roots as the other Detwiler’s locations, with a focus on quality ingredients, homemade meals, and a welcoming atmosphere.
The deli counter is always a hub of activity, with customers lining up for fresh subs, sandwiches, and daily specials.
Inside, you’ll find aisles stocked with bulk foods, baking supplies, and specialty items that you won’t see at a typical supermarket. The produce section features seasonal fruits and vegetables, and the bakery offers fresh bread, cookies, and pastries baked on-site.
The store layout is simple and easy to navigate, and the staff are always ready to help you find what you need.
The Clark location is popular with locals who want a quick, wholesome lunch without the drive-through experience. The deli sandwiches are generous and made to order, and the hot meals are perfect for grabbing dinner on the go.
It’s a reliable, community-focused spot that delivers on flavor and value every time.
11. Detwiler’s Farm Market (West Bradenton, Bradenton)
Detwiler’s Farm Market in West Bradenton rounds out the chain’s presence in the Sarasota-Bradenton area, offering the same farm-fresh quality and homemade-style meals that have made the brand a local favorite. This location is especially popular with families and retirees who appreciate the clean, organized layout and the friendly, no-pressure shopping experience.
The deli is a major draw, with made-to-order sandwiches, subs, and hot meals that change daily.
The market section is stocked with bulk grains, spices, baking supplies, and specialty items that reflect the Mennonite heritage behind Detwiler’s. You’ll also find fresh produce, homemade jams, local honey, and a bakery section that’s always busy with fresh bread, cookies, and pastries.
The store has a farmhouse feel, with wooden shelves and handwritten signs that add to the charm.
Many shoppers make Detwiler’s their regular grocery stop, not just for the deli but for the overall quality and value. The West Bradenton location is known for its helpful staff and welcoming vibe, making it easy to shop for a week’s worth of groceries or just grab a quick lunch.
It’s a solid, dependable choice for fresh, homemade-style food.
12. Martin’s Country Market (Arcadia): PA Dutch bakery + café sandwiches with Amish/Mennonite roots
Tucked away in Arcadia, Martin’s Country Market is a hidden gem that brings Pennsylvania Dutch traditions to small-town Florida. This family-run market and café has deep Amish and Mennonite roots, and you can taste that heritage in every bite.
The bakery is the star of the show, with fresh bread, cookies, pies, and pastries baked daily using old-fashioned recipes. The smell of cinnamon and yeast fills the air as soon as you walk in.
The café counter serves up simple, satisfying sandwiches made with fresh deli meats, crisp vegetables, and homemade spreads. It’s the kind of place where you can sit down with a hot sandwich and a cold drink, or grab something to go and enjoy it on the road.
The menu is straightforward, but everything is made with care and quality ingredients.
Beyond the food, Martin’s also stocks a variety of Pennsylvania Dutch grocery items, from pickles and relishes to specialty baking supplies and bulk foods. It’s a one-stop shop for anyone who loves traditional, homemade-style cooking.
The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with friendly staff who are happy to chat and share recommendations. If you’re driving through Arcadia, Martin’s is absolutely worth a stop.
13. The Amish Country Store Inc. (Largo): Deli sandwiches + Pennsylvania Dutch grocery treasures
Over on Florida’s west coast in Largo, The Amish Country Store Inc. serves up a taste of Pennsylvania Dutch country in the heart of the Sunshine State. This well-loved spot is known for its deli sandwiches, which are piled high with fresh meats, cheeses, and toppings that make every bite satisfying.
The deli counter is always busy, with locals stopping by for lunch or grabbing sandwiches to take home for dinner.
Beyond the deli, the store is packed with Pennsylvania Dutch grocery items and specialty foods. You’ll find homemade jams, pickles, relishes, bulk snacks, baking supplies, and a variety of Amish-made goods that you won’t see at a regular grocery store.
The shelves are stocked with everything from noodles and soups to candies and sauces, all reflecting the traditional flavors and recipes of Amish and Mennonite cooking.
The atmosphere is friendly and down-to-earth, with staff who know the products well and are happy to make recommendations. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch, stocking up on pantry staples, or hunting for unique food gifts, The Amish Country Store has you covered.
It’s a community favorite that delivers on quality, flavor, and old-fashioned hospitality every single time.
