This Morgantown Steakhouse Has Stone-Fired Pepperoni Rolls Locals Say You Have to Try

Culinary Destinations
By Lena Hartley

Overlooking the Monongahela River in Morgantown, Bourbon Prime pairs premium steaks with locally sourced Appalachian ingredients and polished waterfront dining. The menu features filet mignon, ribeye, New York strip, and a hearty cowboy steak alongside regional favorites with a creative twist.

One standout is the stone-fired pepperoni roll, an elevated take on West Virginia’s iconic snack. With river views, regional ingredients, and serious steakhouse cooking, Bourbon Prime offers a distinctive taste of Morgantown.

A Waterfront Address Worth Knowing

© Bourbon Prime

Bourbon Prime arrived on the Morgantown dining scene in 2017, claiming its home inside the Marriott Morgantown at Waterfront Place Hotel at 2 Waterfront Place, Morgantown, West Virginia 26501. Before the hotel was reflagged as a Marriott, the space was occupied by the Regatta Bar and Grill, and the transformation brought something far more ambitious to the waterfront.

The vision was clear from the start: give Morgantown a restaurant that celebrated Appalachian spirit through exceptional prime cuts and a thoughtfully curated selection of fine aged grain spirits. The location itself does a lot of heavy lifting, placing guests right on the banks of the Monongahela River with views that shift beautifully from afternoon sunlight to evening reflections. You can reach the restaurant directly at 304-284-9850, and the website at bourbonprime.com offers menus and reservation details. That riverside address is not just a backdrop; it is part of the experience.

How Appalachian Roots Shape Every Plate

© Bourbon Prime

The culinary philosophy at Bourbon Prime is grounded in a genuine respect for where the food comes from. The kitchen sources ingredients from six different farms spread across West Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania, with every product chosen from within a 100-mile radius of Morgantown.

Grass-fed beef, fresh local trout, and wild ramps, a springtime delicacy native to the Appalachian mountains, appear on the seasonal menu as proud representatives of the region. The chef’s own words say it best: “All chefs can cook, but the source of our ingredients is what sets us apart.” That philosophy turns each dish into something more than a meal; it becomes a small story about the land surrounding this college town.

This farm-to-table commitment also means the menu shifts with the seasons, so returning guests often find something new worth trying. The connection between kitchen and community here feels deliberate rather than trendy, and that sincerity comes through on the plate.

The Interior Design That Sets the Mood

© Bourbon Prime

The moment you step through the recently renovated entrance, the design at Bourbon Prime signals that this is not a generic hotel restaurant. Deep blue seating gives the space a sense of calm luxury, while modern light fixtures cast a warm, flattering glow across the dining room.

A large chalkboard-inspired art piece shaped like a corkscrew draws the eye and anchors the room with personality. Small details add character throughout, including JQ Dickinson salt and pepper shakers on every table, a quiet nod to one of West Virginia’s most celebrated artisan producers. The open-concept kitchen adds an element of live theater, letting diners watch the culinary team work with focus and precision.

The overall atmosphere manages to feel both polished and relaxed, which is a harder balance to strike than it sounds. Energy moves through the room without ever feeling chaotic, and the design encourages you to settle in, order slowly, and enjoy every course without rushing toward the exit.

Prime Cuts Prepared With Serious Intention

© Bourbon Prime

Every steak served at Bourbon Prime carries a guarantee: the kitchen uses only USDA Choice or higher grade meats, and nothing hits the grill without a careful seasoning of the house JQ Dickinson blend. That small ritual makes a noticeable difference in the final flavor.

The menu features the prime ribeye, filet mignon, New York strip, and a bone-in 20-ounce cowboy steak for those who want something truly substantial. A delicate chive-infused butter often arrives alongside these cuts, adding richness without masking the natural character of the beef. A savory side glaze is also available for those who prefer an extra flourish.

Diners consistently note that steaks arrive cooked to the exact requested temperature, which is the kind of precision that separates a good steakhouse from a great one. The steak frites, in particular, has earned enthusiastic praise from guests who arrived with modest expectations and left genuinely impressed. The kitchen takes the work seriously, and it shows.

Starters and Sides That Steal the Spotlight

© Bourbon Prime

Appetizers at Bourbon Prime arrive with the same level of care as the main courses. The filet poutine is a standout, combining tender filet tips with crispy fresh-cut fries, a rich pan gravy, and white cheddar cheese curds that melt into the whole arrangement beautifully.

The lobster bisque earns consistent praise for its creamy, silky texture and generous portions of actual lobster meat. The signature house salad brings together locally sourced greens, crisp bacon lardon, roasted onion, and tangy blue cheese dressing for something refreshing before a heavier main course. On the side menu, the cornbread infused with green chiles surprises with its unexpected creaminess, while roasted baby carrots and broccolini offer vibrant, lighter options alongside richer choices like creamed spinach and truffle fries.

These supporting players are not afterthoughts; they are crafted with the same attention given to the steaks. Ordering a full spread of starters and sides here is absolutely worth the indulgence, and the table will thank you for it.

The Pepperoni Roll Story Behind the Menu

© Bourbon Prime

West Virginia has a deeply personal relationship with the pepperoni roll, a snack born in the coal mining communities of Fairmont in the early 20th century. At Bourbon Prime, the chef, who grew up in Fairmont, honors that heritage by running the classic through a stone-fired pizza oven and elevating it into something guests have called “the bougiest pepperoni rolls ever.”

That description is meant as a compliment. The familiar comfort food arrives with a beautifully blistered crust, a deeply savory interior, and a presentation that feels both respectful and playful at the same time. It is the kind of dish that makes locals smile and out-of-towners curious about the history behind it.

Ordering the pepperoni rolls as a starter is one of the best decisions you can make at this restaurant, and multiple reviews and repeat visitors point to them as a must-order item. They represent exactly what Bourbon Prime does well: taking something rooted in local tradition and making it sing a little louder.

Stone-Fired Pizzas and Non-Steak Options

© Bourbon Prime

Not every guest at the table wants a steak, and Bourbon Prime handles that reality with genuine creativity. The stone-fired pizza oven that produces those legendary pepperoni rolls also turns out pizzas topped with fresh cherry tomatoes, fragrant basil, creamy mozzarella, and a balsamic drizzle that ties it all together.

For something heartier, the pan-seared salmon arrives with quinoa and roasted vegetables, offering a lighter but satisfying alternative. The Rigatoni Bolognese brings a rich, slow-cooked depth that feels right at home on a cooler West Virginia evening. These options ensure that a group with varied preferences can all find something worth getting excited about.

The Chicken Cordon Bleu has also drawn strong praise, with at least one loyal guest declaring it the best version they have ever tried. Having a stone-fired oven in a steakhouse might seem like an unusual choice, but at Bourbon Prime it expands the menu in ways that genuinely strengthen the overall experience rather than diluting the restaurant’s identity.

Desserts That Earn a Dedicated Finish

© Bourbon Prime

Dessert at Bourbon Prime is not an afterthought tacked onto the end of a meal. The cheesecake has developed a loyal following for its perfectly calibrated sweetness and a crust that guests describe repeatedly as divine, which is a strong word but one that keeps appearing for good reason.

The Filthy Cherry Spoon Bread takes a more adventurous approach, built around almond brittle and finished with a “Country Roads” creme anglaise that adds a regional touch. A scoop of vanilla gelato alongside creates that satisfying push and pull between warm and cold, soft and crisp. The espresso creme brulee delivers deeply caramelized notes with a clean finish, while the blackberry bread pudding offers something comforting and familiar for those who prefer classic endings.

These dessert options prove that the kitchen’s commitment to flavor and presentation does not ease up after the main course. Skipping dessert here would be a genuine mistake, and most guests seem to sense that before the menu even arrives.

The Fine Aged Grain Spirits Collection

© Bourbon Prime

Bourbon Prime holds a distinction that no other restaurant in West Virginia can claim: it was the first establishment in the state to offer its own Private Selection of aged grain spirit, a custom blend crafted at a renowned Kentucky producer. That blend carries the name Country Roads, a tribute to the state it calls home.

The signature offering built around this exclusive blend is the Almost Heaven, served in a smoked decanter with cardamom bitters, simple syrup, and a large slowly melting ice sphere. The theatrical presentation adds a layer of ceremony to the experience that guests find genuinely memorable. For those who want to explore further, flights of small samplings allow a guided journey through the collection.

The overall selection of fine aged grain spirits is widely regarded as one of the most extensive in the state, and the bar also offers thoughtfully crafted mixed concoctions, craft brewed options, and a curated selection of wines. This depth of choice makes the bar program a destination in its own right, not just a complement to dinner.

Service That Guests Remember by Name

© Bourbon Prime

The service at Bourbon Prime has a way of making guests feel like the restaurant was waiting specifically for them. Staff members are frequently praised for being knowledgeable, personable, and genuinely invested in the experience rather than simply going through the motions of a standard dinner shift.

Plates are cleared with quiet efficiency, recommendations are offered with real conviction, and the team’s familiarity with both the menu and the fine spirits collection allows for the kind of guidance that turns a good meal into a great one. Several guests have noted that the service alone made them want to return, independent of the food.

Of course, like any restaurant, consistency can vary depending on the night and the volume of guests. But when the service is firing on all cylinders, it adds a warmth to the meal that is hard to replicate. The kitchen and the front-of-house team both understand that hospitality is the invisible ingredient that holds everything else together.

Riverside Views and Outdoor Dining Options

© Bourbon Prime

The Monongahela River does not just sit in the background at Bourbon Prime; it actively shapes the experience. On a clear day, the outdoor patio becomes one of the most pleasant places to eat in all of Morgantown, with the water catching the light and the surrounding hills providing a classic West Virginia backdrop.

Even from inside, the river views add a layer of atmosphere that no amount of interior design can fully replicate. The waterfront designation is earned, not just a marketing phrase attached to the address. Morning breakfast on the patio has its own quiet appeal, separate from the energy of a dinner service.

Private dining spaces are also available for groups of up to 30 guests, with custom menus and a refined setting that works well for corporate events, birthdays, and celebrations. These dedicated spaces benefit from the same exceptional service and, often, the same river views that make the main dining room so appealing. The setting does a lot of the storytelling here.

Planning Your Visit: Hours, Dress, and Parking

© Bourbon Prime

A visit to Bourbon Prime is straightforward to plan, and the restaurant makes a genuine effort to remove any friction before you even arrive. The dress code is described as comfortable and casual, with the standing invitation to “come as you are,” which removes any anxiety about what to wear to a place that serves $40 steaks.

Complimentary parking is available on-site, a practical detail that matters more than it might seem in a busy college town. Breakfast is served daily starting at 6:30 AM, with brunch available on weekends until noon. Dinner service begins at 4:30 PM and runs until 9:30 PM Sunday through Thursday, extending to 10 PM on Friday and Saturday evenings.

Walk-ins are welcome, but a reservation is always a smart move, especially for weekend dinners or larger groups. The phone number is 304-284-9850, and the full menu is available at bourbonprime.com. Mid-week visits tend to offer a more consistent experience, and the kitchen clearly performs best when it has room to breathe and focus.