Somewhere along the winding roads of Lycoming County, Pennsylvania, there is a restaurant that will make you forget you are nowhere near a beach. Real sand sits beneath your feet, a tiki bar hums with festive energy, and mountain views stretch across the horizon while a creek flows quietly just a few steps away.
The combination sounds almost too good to be true, yet this spot has been pulling in loyal fans and curious first-timers for years with exactly that promise. What started as a local waterfront hangout has grown into one of the most talked-about dining destinations in central Pennsylvania, and the story behind how it got here is just as interesting as the place itself.
Whether you stumbled across it by accident or drove an hour on purpose, one thing is clear: this creekside restaurant delivers an experience that is genuinely hard to find anywhere else in the Keystone State. Keep reading to find out what makes it so special.
A Creekside Address with a Comeback Story Worth Knowing
Few restaurants carry a story quite like this one. Pier 87, at 5647 PA-87 in Williamsport, Pennsylvania, sits along the banks of the Loyalsock Creek in Lycoming County, a setting so naturally beautiful it almost feels unfair to other dining spots in the region.
The restaurant was previously known as New Shore Acres before owners Frank Morrone and Brad Russell took over. After opening in April 2011, severe flooding from the Loyalsock Creek caused devastating damage to the property just months later, impacting the restaurant and many homes throughout the valley.
Rather than walking away, Morrone and Russell chose to rebuild. The doors reopened in February 2013 after a long and difficult restoration process.
That resilience transformed Pier 87 into something more than a bar and grill. It became a symbol of community determination, and regulars who remember those early days carry that history with them every time they return.
Real Sand Underfoot and the Beach Feeling You Did Not Expect
Most restaurants offer a patio. Pier 87 offers a sandy beach.
That distinction matters more than it sounds, because the moment your shoes come off and you feel actual sand between your toes, something shifts in your brain and the day suddenly feels like a vacation.
The outdoor sand area features Adirondack chairs positioned to face the Loyalsock Creek, creating a relaxed, unhurried atmosphere that is genuinely hard to manufacture. Families with children especially appreciate this feature, since kids can play in the sand while adults settle in and enjoy the view.
The sandy strip also provides a natural gathering space where conversations start easily and lingering feels encouraged rather than awkward. It fills up quickly on warm weekends, so arriving a bit early is a smart move if claiming a prime spot matters to you.
Once you are settled there with the creek in front of you and the hills beyond, leaving feels like an unnecessary inconvenience.
The Tiki Bar That Brings Island Energy to Pennsylvania
A tiki bar in central Pennsylvania sounds like a punchline, but Pier 87 plays it completely straight and the result is genuinely fun. The outdoor tiki setup draws comparisons to Key West from people who have actually been there, which is a compliment that does not come easily.
The bar area hums with cheerful energy, particularly during warmer months when the surrounding sand pit and creek views add to the tropical mood. Colorful, creatively crafted drinks arrive in festive glassware, and the atmosphere encourages you to slow down and actually enjoy where you are.
Non-alcoholic options like virgin strawberry daiquiri pina coladas are just as popular as anything else on the menu.
The tiki bar extends its hours on weekends and opens earlier after Memorial Day, giving visitors plenty of opportunity to experience the full outdoor setup. It operates as a side bar adjacent to the main dining area, so you can move freely between the two without losing your spot in the overall vibe of the place.
Mountain Views That Turn Every Meal Into a Moment
There is a particular kind of satisfaction that comes from eating a good meal while staring at a genuinely beautiful view, and Pier 87 delivers that without asking you to hike for it. The mountain scenery that surrounds the Loyalsock Valley stretches across the horizon in every direction from the outdoor seating areas.
The screened porch offers one of the best vantage points, giving diners a front-row seat to the creek and the rolling hills beyond without exposure to bugs or unpredictable weather. The owners specifically highlight a scenic mountain view at sunset on the restaurant’s website, and that promise is not an overstatement.
As the seasons change, so does the backdrop. Summer brings deep greens and shimmering water reflections.
Autumn transforms the hillsides into a layered display of red, orange, and gold that makes the already-scenic setting feel almost theatrical. Even a gray winter afternoon carries its own quiet charm when viewed from a warm seat beside the creek-facing windows.
The Menu’s Star Power, from Haddock to the Beast
Pier 87’s menu has built a loyal following through sheer consistency and creative variety. The haddock has achieved near-legendary status in the region, arriving golden-brown on the outside and perfectly flaky within.
Locals plan visits around it, and many drive significant distances just for a plate.
The New England Clam Chowder is another standout that regulars treat as a must-order, with many ranking it among the best in the state. Beyond the seafood highlights, the menu covers serious ground.
Bacon-wrapped pierogies drizzled with BBQ sauce offer a playful take on a Pennsylvania classic, while the soft pretzel served with nacho cheese and country mustard is a crowd-pleasing starter.
For heartier appetites, the roast beef sandwich known as “The Beast” has developed its own fan base, and the crab cake sandwich earns consistent praise for its generous portions and clean flavor. Prime rib specials on Saturdays, perfectly cooked sirloin, and rotating homemade desserts round out a menu that gives every visitor something worth returning for.
Inside the Rustic Lodge That Somehow Also Has a Tiki Bar
The interior of Pier 87 presents a fascinating identity that takes a moment to fully absorb. Warm wooden paneling, exposed beams, and soaring ceilings create the unmistakable feel of a well-loved Pennsylvania hunting cabin, yet just outside sits a tropical-themed tiki bar.
The contrast works better than logic suggests it should.
Walls decorated with mounted deer heads, local fish specimens, and outdoor memorabilia tell a story of genuine connection to the region’s culture rather than curated decoration. Nothing about it feels forced or assembled from a catalog.
It feels like the place has been lived in, celebrated in, and returned to across many seasons.
The dining room carries a comfortable energy that makes strangers feel like neighbors. Whether you arrive in hiking boots after a trail run or dressed up for a birthday dinner, the atmosphere accommodates both without skipping a beat.
That flexibility is rarer than it sounds, and it contributes significantly to why so many people consider Pier 87 their favorite spot in the Williamsport area.
Live Music, Fire Pits, and the Outdoor Experience After Dark
As the sun drops behind the mountains and the creek takes on that soft golden tone, Pier 87 shifts gears into something that feels distinctly different from a typical dinner out. The outdoor area, already lively by day, takes on a warmer and more festive character once the fire pits are lit and the evening settles in.
Live music is a regular feature, with a rotating lineup of bands that keeps the entertainment calendar fresh and gives regulars a reason to come back on different nights. The schedule is posted at the restaurant, and the variety ensures there is usually something that appeals to a broad range of tastes.
Fire pits scattered through the outdoor area provide gathering points where conversations stretch naturally into the evening. The combination of crackling fire, creek sounds, and mountain air creates an atmosphere that is genuinely hard to replicate.
It is the kind of outdoor setup that makes you wonder why more restaurants have not figured out this formula, and why you waited so long to discover it yourself.
Water Activities and the Outdoor Adventure Connection
The Loyalsock Creek is not just a scenic backdrop at Pier 87. It is an active part of the experience for many visitors who arrive by water rather than by road.
Kayakers, tubers, and boaters regularly use the restaurant as a planned stop along their creek journeys, pulling up to refuel with food before continuing downstream.
The surrounding area deepens the outdoor appeal considerably. World’s End State Park and Loyalsock State Park are both within reasonable distance, offering hiking and biking trails that work perfectly as a pre-meal activity.
Rider Park, also nearby, provides trails with panoramic views that make the drive to this part of Pennsylvania feel especially worthwhile.
Bald eagles have been spotted nesting in the area, adding an unexpected wildlife element to the already scenic surroundings. Pier 87 serves as a natural anchor point for a full day outdoors, the kind of place where you plan lunch as the reward for the morning’s adventure.
That integration of activity and appetite is part of what keeps visitors coming back season after season.
Practical Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Visit
A visit to Pier 87 goes more smoothly with a bit of advance planning, especially during peak summer weekends when the outdoor areas fill quickly. The restaurant is open Tuesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 9 PM and is closed on Mondays.
Arriving closer to opening time gives you the best chance at a window table with a prime creek view.
Reservations are accepted for parties of six or more, which is worth knowing if you are organizing a group outing. The outdoor patio is dog-friendly, so well-behaved pets are welcome to join the experience.
Parking is free and generally plentiful, with both a dedicated lot and street parking available nearby.
Takeout is also an option for those who want to enjoy the food elsewhere, though eating on-site with the creek and mountains in front of you is hard to replicate at home. The phone number is 570-435-0290, and the website at thepier87.com has current hours and menu information.
Going in prepared means more time enjoying and less time figuring out logistics.
Why This Spot Keeps Drawing People Back Year After Year
With a 4.6-star rating across nearly two thousand reviews on Google, Pier 87 has clearly figured something out that most restaurants spend years chasing. The combination of a genuinely beautiful setting, a menu that covers serious ground, and a staff that makes people feel at home creates a loop that is hard to break once you are in it.
The sandy beach area keeps families coming back with children who loved playing by the water. The tiki bar and live music schedule pull in a crowd looking for a livelier evening.
The screened porch and mountain views attract those who simply want a quiet, beautiful meal. Pier 87 manages to serve all of these groups without feeling scattered or unfocused.
The story of rebuilding after the 2011 flood still resonates in the community, adding a layer of meaning to every plate served and every evening spent on that sandy strip by the creek. Pier 87 is the rare kind of place that earns its reputation honestly, one memorable visit at a time.
Share this story
