Some of the best meals you will ever eat come from places that look like nothing from the outside. Illinois has a long tradition of no-frills spots that quietly serve food so good it stops you mid-bite.
Italian beef sandwiches are a point of serious local pride here, and a handful of shops have built loyal followings one dripping sandwich at a time. These five places are worth every mile of the drive.
1. Mr. Beef, Chicago, IL
Few addresses in Chicago carry as much sandwich weight as 666 N Orleans St. Mr. Beef has been feeding the city with no-nonsense Italian beef long enough to become a genuine institution, and its reputation is as well-seasoned as the meat itself. The thinly sliced beef is tender, deeply flavorful, and stacked onto a soft French bread roll that soaks up every drop of the sweet and hot dipping sauce.
The shop famously served as a setting for the hit TV show The Bear, bringing national attention to what locals already knew. Signed photos line the walls, the banter among the staff is part of the experience, and the menu keeps things refreshingly simple.
Fresh-cut fries and onion rings round out the order.
Hours run Monday through Saturday, 10 AM to 4 PM, making this a perfect weekday or Saturday lunch stop in the heart of Chicago.
2. Johnnie’s Beef, Elmwood Park, IL
Cash only, carry-out style, and absolutely no pretense – Johnnie’s Beef in Elmwood Park operates exactly the way a legendary sandwich stand should. Tucked along West North Avenue, this tiny counter-service spot draws a devoted crowd that stretches into the evening hours on weekends, and for very good reason.
The Italian beef here is the kind that makes people rethink every sandwich they have eaten before it.
Wonderful dipped beef comes topped with your choice of sweet or hot peppers, and the flavors hit with a confidence that only comes from years of doing one thing exceptionally well. Italian ice and shakes offer a cool contrast after the heat of the peppers.
Open until midnight most nights of the week, Johnnie’s is a suburban gem that earns its place alongside the best Chicagoland has to offer. Bring cash and arrive hungry.
3. Novi’s Beef, Berwyn, IL
Berwyn sits along the historic Route 66 corridor, and Novi’s Beef fits right into that legacy of no-fuss, full-flavor roadside eating. A longtime beef sandwich specialist, the shop has built its reputation on portions that are genuinely generous and seasoning that earns its praise without any marketing help.
Perfectly thinly sliced beef arrives piled high on a soft Italian roll, soaked through with savory au jus and finished with sweet and tangy peppers.
Beyond the signature Italian beef, the menu stretches to gyros, Chicago hot dogs, tacos, and pizza puffs, making it a reliable stop for groups with different cravings. The atmosphere is casual and quiet, the service is fast, and the spot is good for families and solo diners alike.
With drive-through and delivery options available, Novi’s makes it easy to get your fix. Open seven days a week from 10 AM to 9 PM.
4. Baldarotta’s Porketta & Sicilian Sausage, Urbana, IL
Central Illinois does not always get credit for serious Italian food, but Baldarotta’s in Urbana is quietly changing that conversation. Operating as an Italian sandwich shop, deli, and gelateria on West Griggs Street, the spot brings a level of care and flavor that feels more like a family kitchen than a quick-service counter.
The meats are tender, moist, and seasoned with real intention.
The Italian beef here comes with a full wide container of au jus for dipping, which is the kind of detail that separates a good sandwich from an unforgettable one. The menu also includes porketta, Sicilian sausage, muffalettas, and porketta fries, giving every visit plenty of reason to try something new.
Gelato and dessert options round out the experience beautifully.
Baldarotta’s draws college students, families, and tourists alike, with a cozy and trendy atmosphere that makes lingering feel natural. Closed Mondays.
5. Frank’s, Peoria Heights, IL
Frank’s in Peoria Heights runs on reputation, and that reputation has been built one packed sandwich at a time. Serving Frank Abdnour’s famous Italian beef alongside hot dogs, authentic Italian subs, and fresh salads, the shop operates carry-out only – a format that keeps the focus exactly where it belongs: on the food.
The Italian beef is super tender, loaded with flavor, and filled to the absolute brim of the roll.
Locals have been making Frank’s a regular stop for years, and visitors who get the recommendation quickly understand why. The Chicago Dog is another menu highlight worth ordering alongside the beef.
Prices stay approachable, and the portions justify every penny.
Open Tuesday through Saturday with evening hours on Fridays and Saturdays, Frank’s is a worthy detour on any central Illinois road trip. Free parking makes the stop even easier to justify.
Share this story
