Some of the best food stops in Illinois hide behind plain little storefronts you could drive past a hundred times. I almost did, until the smell of warm sugar pulled me back.
Inside, the trays were full, the prices felt like a typo, and the donuts tasted like a childhood I forgot I missed. Bring cash, bring an appetite, and get ready to make this your new reason for a road trip.
A Hometown Bakery on Hanover Street
Tucked at 115 W Hanover St in New Baden, Berkemann’s Baker’s Dozen is the kind of spot that looks modest from the curb and turns into a habit once you step inside. It sits in a small Clinton County town east of St. Louis, a short hop off I-64.
Locals call it their hometown bakery, and visitors often describe it as an old fashioned bakery in the best sense. Shelves hold donuts, cookies, breads, pies, turnovers, and cream-filled pastries, with cakes made to order for birthdays, events, and weddings.
One fan put it simply by calling it a hole in the wall worth loving. There is no fancy decor or big branding here.
What you get instead is fresh baking, small-town friendliness, and prices that make you want to buy a second box. For Illinois road trippers, that combination is pure gold.
Memories Baked Into the Same Old Corner
Ask around and you will hear the word memories more than once. Several regulars say stepping inside takes them straight back to being a kid, when nearly every small town had a bakery like it.
One longtime visitor mentioned it may even be the same location as an earlier bakery they visited growing up, just under a different name. That sense of continuity matters to people here.
A bakery on Main Street-style blocks like this one becomes part of how a town remembers itself.
Travelers passing through feel it too. A couple heading home from St. Louis called the shop a treasure and said it is a must for bringing kids or grandkids.
It is not about trendy flavors. It is about tradition, sugar, and the quiet comfort of a place that feels like it has always been there, waiting with a fresh tray.
Donuts Worth Setting an Alarm For
Doors open at 4:30 a.m., which tells you everything about the priorities here. Donuts are the star, and they come up in conversation far more than anything else on the menu.
Visitors rave about how fluffy and light they are. Many point out they are not overly sweet, which lets the dough itself shine.
Popular picks include original glazed donuts, glazed twists, sugar and cinnamon twists, and cinnamon sugar donuts. Cake donuts, like blueberry, show up too, along with apple-filled options.
One guest said a bite reminded them of their childhood donut shop, and that feeling seems common. An office crew even claimed these as their favorites.
A quick tip: selection can vary, and one visitor once found no glazed left, so earlier really is better. Arrive with the sunrise and you may catch the glaze still setting on the rack.
Cream Horns and Cream Puffs
Melt in your mouth. That is how one visitor described the cream horns, adding they were the best they had ever eaten, hands down.
Strong words, but plenty of regulars back them up.
The flaky pastry tubes are piped full of sweet cream and have earned a loyal following of their own. A fan who swears by the donuts and sugar cookies still warns newcomers not to skip the cream horns.
Cream puffs get similar love. One couple happened to arrive just as a freshly made tray was being carried out, and the puff disappeared quickly.
It was called wonderful, which sounds about right for anything that fresh. If you only grab one non-donut treat, many would steer you toward these two.
Order an extra for the car ride, because sharing is harder than it sounds.
Turnovers, Elephant Ears, and Flaky Things
Flaky layers have their own fan club here. Turnovers come up often, with cherry and apple both getting mentions from happy customers.
One visitor described the apple turnover as flaky and not too sweet, a balance that seems to run through much of the baking. Fruit fillings stay bright without drowning in sugar, so you can actually taste the apple.
Then there is the Elephant’s Ear. A traveler tried one and called it light and crunchy, with pecans worked in for extra texture.
It is the kind of pastry that shatters a little with each bite, so maybe eat it over the box.
The case also changes from visit to visit, and regulars say there is always something different to try. That variety keeps people coming back to see what is new on the trays, and it makes every stop a small adventure.
Paul’s Delight, a Summer-Only Legend
Here is a fun bit of insider knowledge. The treat locals call Paul’s Delight only shows up between Memorial Day and Labor Day.
Picture a hand-held chocolate cake topped with a star-piped dollop of marshmallow cream, then covered in chocolate. One fan described it in all caps as delicious, and it is easy to see why.
It is part snack cake, part nostalgia trip, and entirely the kind of thing you plan a summer drive around.
A longtime customer listed Paul’s Delights right alongside cinnamon sugar donuts and pizza dough as personal favorites. Seasonal specialties like this give regulars something to look forward to every year.
If you are planning a warm-weather trip across Illinois, timing your visit for this little chocolate gem may be the smartest move you make all season.
Bread, Bagels, and the Famous Pizza Dough
Not everyone comes for sugar. A surprising number of regulars walk out with bread, bagels, and a bag of pizza dough tucked under one arm.
The pizza dough has quite the reputation, earning repeat mentions from people who make it part of their weekly routine. Homemade pizza night gets a serious upgrade when the base comes from a local bakery that opens before sunrise.
Bread gets praise too. One visitor called it perfect for sandwiches, and a family from O’Fallon said they drive over specifically for bread and bagels.
Another traveler makes a habit of grabbing a loaf every time they pass through New Baden. There are even some frozen, pre-made items available for stocking up.
Think of this as the practical side of the bakery, the stuff that turns a sweet detour into a grocery run worth bragging about.
Cookies That Change With the Seasons
Walk in during fall and you might spot bat-shaped cookies. Stop by in another month and the decorations will likely look completely different.
Visitors love that the cookies keep changing with each season or simply for fun. Sugar cookies are a dependable favorite, and pumpkin cookies have been called soft, sweet, and amazing.
Oatmeal cookies sit in the case too for anyone who likes something more classic.
To be fair, one customer noted a decorated cookie came out on the firmer side, so texture can vary by style. Still, the creativity is half the charm.
Kids especially seem to enjoy picking out whatever shape or color catches their eye.
Lemon bars and pies round out the sweets beyond donuts. Cherry pie in particular has picked up compliments, making it a solid choice for anyone heading to a family dinner afterward.
Celebration Cakes and Wedding Pies
Five bakeries said no. Berkemann’s said yes instantly. That is how one customer described ordering an event cake with less than three days of notice, and the result earned them a big thank-you.
Custom cakes are a major part of the business. Families mention beautiful birthday cakes with great flavor, and one group praised the team for adapting to a design change, then delivering on time and coordinating with a building manager.
Guests reportedly piled on the compliments.
Weddings get the treatment too. Wedding cakes come up in conversation, and one couple skipped cake entirely in favor of individual pies in lots of flavors.
They restocked the dessert table all night, and the pies were a huge hit. A cinnamon roll cake is another option, perfect for a Saturday breakfast with the whole crew around the table.
Prices That Feel Like a Throwback
Confusingly cheap. That phrase from one happy visitor sums up how many people feel at the register.
Most items fall in the $1 to $10 range.
Several customers call it the best price they have paid for donuts anywhere. The cash-only setup is often mentioned as part of the reason prices stay so friendly.
And the name says it all, since a classic baker’s dozen gives you thirteen instead of twelve.
Not every opinion lines up, of course. One visitor paid $8 for a half dozen assorted and felt some donuts ran small.
Another was not impressed with the gooey butter cake. Tastes differ, and that is fine.
For most folks, though, the value is part of the fun. Leaving with a full box and change in your pocket feels like a small victory, especially in a world of fancy pastry shops.
Small Rooms, Friendly Faces, Busy Mornings
Friendly comes up again and again. Staff are described as outgoing, helpful, and happy to guide first-timers toward something good.
One traveler appreciated how quickly the team packed up birthday goodies for their celebration.
The space itself is cozy. There is one little table near the door, so most people grab their treats and go.
Weekends can get lively, with one guest saying the place was popping on a Saturday.
Service can slow down on busy days, and a couple of visitors mentioned waiting a few minutes. It is a small-town operation, and patience pays off here.
A sweet touch worth knowing: on Veterans Day, the bakery has offered military guests a free donut or two.
The vibe suits families, road trippers, office donut runners, and anyone who misses the bakery on their old block back home.
Hours, Cash, and Getting There
Planning ahead helps. Berkemann’s opens Tuesday through Saturday from 4:30 a.m. to 7 p.m. and closes on Sundays and Mondays.
Cash is king here. Cards are not accepted, though checks are, and there is an ATM inside if your wallet comes up empty.
Bring a little extra anyway, because you will probably see something you did not plan on buying.
Finding it is easy. The shop sits at 115 W Hanover St in New Baden, only a short distance from I-64, making it a natural stop between St. Louis and points east.
Parking is limited, but a small lot right next door usually has room. Regulars from Belleville, O’Fallon, and beyond make the trip.
Locals also love pairing a visit with lunch at Good Ol’ Days nearby. For questions or cake orders, call 618-588-4233.
Why the Drive Pays Off
Some places are built for photos. Others are built for Tuesday mornings, birthday parties, and the drive home when the box is already half empty.
Berkemann’s Baker’s Dozen is firmly the second kind.
You will not find polish or fuss. You will find light donuts, legendary cream horns, a summer-only chocolate treat, dependable bread, and cakes that rescue last-minute celebrations.
Throw in small-town kindness and old-school prices, and it becomes clear why people go 25 minutes in the wrong direction just to stop in.
Not every pastry will win everyone over, and that is part of honest small-town baking. Still, for Illinois day trippers who love claiming a hidden gem, this one is easy to defend.
Set the alarm, grab some cash, and head to New Baden. That early glaze will not wait forever, and neither should you.
Share this story
