Some of the best meals start with a hungry stomach and a building you almost drove past. That is exactly the kind of surprise waiting at a pirate-themed buffet on the South Carolina coast.
Behind the playful decor sits a mountain of snow crab legs, stuffed crab, prime rib, and desserts that keep you going back for one more plate. If you love seafood and a little adventure with your dinner, this spot deserves a place on your treasure map.
A Pirate Ship of a Buffet on North Kings Highway
Ahoy, hungry travelers. Crabby George’s Calabash Seafood Buffet sits at 7904 N Kings Hwy in Myrtle Beach, right along the main stretch that beach visitors cruise every day.
Spotting it is easy, and stopping is even easier once you know what waits inside.
At heart, the place is a seafood restaurant built around an all-you-can-eat buffet. Guests can load up on snow crab legs, stuffed crab, shrimp, and plenty more, then circle back as often as they like.
For those who prefer ordering off a menu, a la carte steak and seafood options are available too.
The word Calabash in the name nods to a classic Carolina style of seafood dining, and the buffet leans into that coastal spirit. Add a full pirate theme and you get a dinner that feels part feast, part family outing.
Few places along the Grand Strand pack this much food into one stop.
Treasure Chests, Metal Sculptures, and a Little Shop
Walking in feels a bit like stepping onto a ship that sailed through a junkyard art gallery, in the best way. Pirate decor fills the dining rooms, and visitors point out a fun twist of steampunk style mixed in.
Look closely and you will see sculptures crafted from repurposed metal scattered around the space. Kids love hunting for details, and adults usually end up snapping a few photos too.
Guests describe the overall feel as comfortable, warm, and inviting rather than over the top.
Booths line the dining area, which one family said was the main reason they chose the spot, since their little one stays seated best in a closed-off booth. There is also a small store area to browse after your meal.
A photographer often roams the building, and guests mention that the pictures cost extra, so decide ahead whether you want a keepsake from your voyage.
Snow Crab Legs, the Star of the Show
Crab legs are, by far, what people talk about most here. Diners mention them thousands of times, and it is easy to see why once you crack the first shell.
Many guests call the snow crab fresh and say they ate more than they planned. One happy visitor admitted to losing count of how many legs ended up on the table.
Because the buffet is unlimited, you can pace yourself or go all in, no judgment either way.
A few honest notes help set expectations. Some diners felt the legs were thin during their visit, and one guest was disappointed after expecting king crab instead of snow crab.
Others mention a King Snow Crab option offered for an upcharge, which they felt was worth it. Ask your server what is available that day so you know exactly what is heading to your plate.
Stuffed Crab and a Parade of Shrimp
Here is a tip from people who have done the rounds: save room beyond the crab legs. The stuffed crab earns special praise, with one diner calling it especially enjoyable.
Shrimp shows up in many forms, from grilled to fried and beyond. One guest proudly tried every version and said they were the best they had found in South Carolina.
Others highlight the salmon, scallops, crawfish, fried oysters, and catfish as worthy picks.
A cold and raw bar adds oysters and chilled options, while crab salad and chicken salad give the plate a cooler side. Frog legs are on the line too, a fun dare for adventurous eaters, though one visitor found them a little rubbery.
Not every dish wins every guest, and some found the crab imperial bland. Still, with this much variety, building a favorite plate is half the fun.
Prime Rib and Land-Lover Favorites
Not everyone at the table dreams of shellfish, and that is perfectly fine. Prime rib ranks as the second most talked-about item, right behind crab legs.
Plenty of diners describe it as tender and say it was a highlight of their trip. One guest felt it was dry on their visit, so timing may matter.
Sirloin steak also appears on the buffet, though one weekday guest waited a while for it to be refilled.
Families with picky eaters will find BBQ ribs, wings that one parent called surprisingly good, roast, pizza, and a salad bar. Asparagus even got a shout-out as the best one diner ever had.
Prefer ordering? The a la carte side of the menu covers steak and seafood, and a guest who ordered lobster tails said they were great.
In short, the non-seafood crowd will not leave hungry.
Baklava, Flan, and Giant Chocolate Strawberries
Buffet desserts often feel like an afterthought. At Crabby George’s, they might be the sneaky reason people come back.
Baklava gets frequent praise, with one couple calling it a must-try. Large chocolate-covered strawberries and ice cream stand out for others.
One guest raved about a chocolate cupcake topped with silky chocolate mousse, calling it rich and moist.
The spread is wide: cookies, pies, puddings, cakes, cheesecakes, brownies, custard or flan, and fresh fruit. A longtime buffet fan said the dessert selection surprised them in quality and variety.
Not every visit hits perfectly, as one diner found some cakes dry, but most guests leave happily sugared up. Celebrating a birthday?
One group shared that the staff gave them a lively celebration and free cake, a sweet ending to any family trip.
Friendly Crews, Live Tunes, and Cotton Candy
Ask regulars what makes a visit memorable, and many skip the food entirely to talk about their server. Kind staff get mentioned hundreds of times, with guests praising quick drink refills, clean tables, and helpful tips on where to find everything.
One parent shared how patient and respectful their waiter was with their autistic son, something they rarely find when dining out. Another family loved how sweet their server was to a toddler.
Service is not flawless every time, and a couple of guests wished for more frequent check-ins or a warmer front desk greeting.
Entertainment adds extra sparkle. Visitors mention live music, including a saxophone player, a clown making balloon animals, and someone handing out fresh cotton candy to kids.
With that kind of lineup, it is a solid pick for families, birthday groups, and anyone who enjoys a lively dinner.
Hours, Prices, and Money-Saving Tricks
Planning ahead pays off here. Doors open at 2 PM Monday through Thursday and close at 9:30 PM.
Friday runs noon to 10 PM, Saturday noon to 10:30 PM, and Sunday noon to 9:30 PM.
Expect to spend around $50 to $60 per person. One guest noted an adult price of $55.99, plus a 3.99% surcharge on top of taxes.
Drinks are not included, and several diners said soft drinks felt pricey, so ordering water can save a few dollars each.
Coupons are the local secret. Guests mention finding a $6 off per adult deal for dining before 5 PM in coupon books around town.
Early visits also bring fresher, hotter food and lighter crowds, according to regulars. Reservations help too, as one diner was seated right away.
Call 843-839-4044 or visit crabbygeorges.com for current details.
Worth Setting Sail For
So, should you drop anchor at Crabby George’s? For most crab lovers, the answer leans toward a cheerful yes.
Unlimited snow crab, tasty stuffed crab, tender prime rib on a good day, and a dessert bar that outshines typical buffets make a strong case. The pirate setting, booths, and kid-friendly extras turn dinner into an event rather than just a meal.
Friendly servers often seal the deal.
Go in with clear expectations, though. It is a splurge, especially once drinks and fees are added, and a few dishes can be hit or miss.
Those expecting king crab at the regular price may want to ask first. Arrive early, grab a coupon, and bring a big appetite.
Many first-timers leave already planning their next beach trip around a return visit, and that might be the clearest sign of all.
Share this story
