Some of the best finds in Oklahoma hide behind plain glass doors in ordinary strip plazas. I walked into one expecting a quick browse and walked out an hour later, hungry for more and already planning my next trip.
Inside were shelves of old cartridges, classic consoles, and card games that took me straight back to childhood. If you have ever wondered where Oklahoma collectors go treasure hunting, this little shop is worth knowing about.
A Strip Plaza Secret on NW 23rd Street
Blink while driving down NW 23rd Street in Oklahoma City and you might miss it completely. Video Games Plus sits in Suite B at 4557 NW 23rd St, tucked into a plaza that looks like countless others across the state.
From the parking lot, nothing screams treasure. There is no giant arcade sign or flashing marquee, just a storefront that blends right in with its neighbors.
That ordinary look is part of the fun, because what waits inside feels like a different world.
Officially, the place is a video game store. In practice, it works more like a museum where everything is for sale.
Retro cartridges, classic consoles, collectible guides, figurines, and trading cards fill the space, and visitors often say they never leave empty-handed.
Regulars describe it as their first stop whenever they want older games. Some say it is the best shop of its kind within a hundred miles, and others make the drive from nearby towns like Moore just to spend time here.
For Oklahomans who grew up blowing dust out of cartridges, finding a spot like this so close to home feels like striking gold in your own backyard. It is a local find with real pull.
From a Smaller Space Down the Plaza to Today
Long before the current layout, the shop started out in a smaller spot farther down the same plaza. Longtime fans love bringing this up, almost like a badge of honor showing they were there early.
Several regulars say they have followed the store since those first days. One describes visiting since the original location and calls it their number one video game store, period.
That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident.
The move brought a big change in feel. Shoppers who knew both spaces say the newer, more open floor plan is far easier to navigate than the old one, which makes browsing less of a squeeze and more of a stroll.
Growing within the same plaza also says something about the community behind it. Instead of leaving the neighborhood, the business simply expanded where its customers already knew to look.
For visitors today, that history adds a layer of charm. You are not walking into a chain store dropped from above.
You are stepping into a place that grew up alongside its customers, one cartridge, one card night, and one repair at a time. That steady, homegrown story is part of why people trust it.
Retro Carts for Days
Picture shelf after shelf of the games you begged for as a kid. That is the main attraction here, and retro titles are easily what visitors talk about most.
The selection mixes common favorites with harder-to-find pieces. One shopper joked that you can bet they have Sonic the Hedgehog 2, while another spotted a sealed South Park game for the Nintendo 64.
Japanese editions show up on the shelves too.
Collectors also point to the loose games section. People describe it as very extensive and affordable, which makes it a great place to rebuild a childhood library without emptying your wallet.
Displays get praise for keeping items in good condition as well.
Rarities draw serious hunters. One visitor said they had never seen the GameCube version of Ocarina of Time before finding it here.
Another eyed a copy of Tails Concerto priced around 399 dollars and almost bought it.
Newer generations are covered too, so younger gamers will not feel left out. Still, the heart of the store beats in 8-bit and 16-bit.
One self-described retro collector called the shop a paradise, and after a lap around the shelves, it is hard to argue with that.
Consoles, Guides, and Curious Collectibles
Games are only half the treasure hunt. Classic consoles line the space too, and some come ready to play on retro setups set up right in the store.
One customer picked up an NES top loader planning to give it an RGB mod. They reported it arrived clean and worked as advertised, both before and after the upgrade.
That kind of reliability matters when you are buying hardware older than some shoppers.
Beyond the systems, the shelves hold a fun mix of memorabilia. Visitors mention old game guides, figurines, accessories, and even Beyblade toys.
It is the kind of place where you go in looking for one thing and leave thinking about five others.
A frequent observation is how different this feels from other game shops. One first-time visitor noted that many stores end up packed with the same cheap merchandise, and this is not one of those places.
Even the shelf behind the counter gets attention. A collector said one look at it shows how much passion for gaming lives here.
Whether you need a replacement controller or a piece of nostalgia for your bookshelf, the browsing here rewards curiosity in a big way.
Card Tables and Commander Nights
Tuesday evenings bring a different kind of energy. According to visitors, the store hosts a free Magic: The Gathering Commander night every Tuesday starting at 7 pm, running as late as midnight.
Card players are some of the shop’s biggest fans. One avid Magic player said the card selection far surpassed expectations and added that the trip is worth it even if you live outside the area.
Pokemon cards are plentiful too.
Events go beyond Magic. Shoppers mention trading card game tournaments and other community gatherings, and one person said they had been attending local events for about five months and felt genuinely well treated as a player.
Tabletop fans will find something as well. Dungeons and Dragons accessories and board games are part of the mix, and several people describe the shop as a good place to hang out and play with friends.
Staff on duty during these nights earn praise for setting a relaxed, welcoming mood. Even a visitor who does not play card games said they loved seeing a business host events for the local community.
If you want to meet fellow Oklahoma gamers face to face, a Tuesday here is a solid place to start.
Repairs That Bring Old Hardware Back
Got a console that refuses to boot? Repairs are a big part of what this shop does, and it comes up again and again when people talk about it.
Services reportedly cover classic systems as well as newer machines like the PS5. One customer said their repairs have been fast, reliable, and more affordable than anywhere else they had tried.
Another said the team took on a job outside their usual work and still exceeded expectations.
Small fixes count too. Scratched discs can be cleaned for around 2 dollars, which is a cheap way to rescue a favorite game.
A visitor also mentioned a diagnostic fee of about 30 dollars for console work.
Generosity shows up in surprising ways. One shopper brought in a corroded VR controller, and a staff member worked to fix it and then declined payment once it worked again.
Not every repair story is smooth, to be fair. One visitor shared a frustrating experience over a PlayStation 2 job and communication, so it helps to ask questions upfront and get details in writing.
Overall, though, many locals clearly trust the shop with their beloved hardware.
Selling Your Collection and Talking Prices
Money talk is where opinions split the most. Some shoppers call the prices fair and transparent, while others feel rare retro titles sit above online market values.
Fans often point to the wider collecting market. One regular said prices are what they are, but given current conditions, they come across as very fair.
Another described a rare game as a good deal, even after failing to haggle it lower.
Critics have a different take. A few visitors said certain Game Boy and Pokemon titles cost more than they could find online, so price-checking before buying a pricey rare piece is a smart move.
Selling is also an option here. One customer traded in part of their collection and felt the offer was reasonable, especially since it saved the hassle and risk of listing items themselves.
Customer service on returns gets praise too. A shopper whose controller had faulty buttons came back, and the staff replaced it with a pricier model at no extra cost, testing it on the spot.
The takeaway is simple: know what you want, compare if you like, and enjoy the convenience of holding the game in your hands first.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
Ask regulars what keeps them coming back, and the staff tops the list. Friendliness is by far the most praised trait in what people share about this store.
Names pop up often. Visitors mention employees who greeted them warmly on the way in and out, one who was knowledgeable and easy to talk to, and another who set a chill mood during card nights.
Shoppers describe the team as helpful and passionate about the hobby.
The overall vibe feels personal rather than corporate. People describe it as a spot where you could hang out, chat about old consoles, and maybe get pulled into a game.
Honesty matters too, and not every visit has been perfect. One family felt staff conversation at the front got too loud and inappropriate for kids, and the owners responded that the issue was handled internally.
Another visitor wished for background music to make browsing feel less quiet.
Still, the bigger picture is clear. For hobby lovers, the people working here are a major reason the store feels like a clubhouse.
The welcome is often as memorable as the merchandise, and that is rare in any shop.
Hours, Contact, and Planning a Visit
Good news for weekend road-trippers: the doors are open seven days a week. Monday through Saturday, hours run from 11 am to 7 pm.
Sundays are a little shorter, from noon to 6 pm. If you are planning a Tuesday visit, consider staying late for Commander night, which starts at 7 pm according to visitors.
Finding the shop is easy once you know where to look. Head to 4557 NW 23rd St, Suite B, Oklahoma City, OK 73127, and keep an eye out for the plaza storefront.
It is simple to miss if you are driving fast.
Questions about stock or repairs can go to the phone line at 405-252-0747. The store also shares updates through its Facebook page under vgpokc, which is a handy place to check before making a long drive.
A few tips help too. Bring a list if you are hunting specific titles, set a budget before browsing rare cases, and leave extra time because the loose game bins have a way of eating an afternoon.
Packing some old games to trade can also stretch your spending. Combine it with other Oklahoma City stops, and you have a fun day out.
Worth the Detour for Pixel Lovers
So, is it worth the drive? For anyone with a soft spot for classic games, the answer leans strongly toward yes.
Video Games Plus packs a lot into a modest Oklahoma City storefront. You get a deep retro library, rare finds, playable setups, card game nights, tabletop gear, and repair help, all under one roof.
Few places in the state combine that much under such a quiet exterior.
Like any collector shop, it is not perfect for everyone. Bargain hunters chasing the lowest possible price on rare titles may want to compare first, and families might check the mood before settling in.
Those notes are worth keeping in mind.
Yet the loyalty speaks loudly. People drive in from neighboring towns, follow the shop through moves, and call it their go-to stop.
One visitor summed it up by saying that if you are not in the area, it is still worth the trip.
That captures the appeal nicely. In a state full of hidden gems along its highways and back roads, this one hides in plain sight.
Grab some friends, bring your wish list, and see what childhood memories you can carry home.
Share this story
