Your pizza order does not come with a buzzer or a shout from the counter. Instead, a number shows up on a mirror, and that is your signal to go grab your food.
It sounds like a party trick, but it is how one Colorado pizzeria has run for years. The room around those mirrors is full of stained glass, a player piano, and Old West style decor.
Keep reading to see how the system works and what else makes this place so different.
The Mirrors That Call Your Number
Forget buzzers and loud name calls. Here, your order number glows right on a mirror hanging in the dining room, and that is how you know the food is done.
The mirrors are placed around the building, so you can sit far from the counter and still keep an eye on your number. That matters in a space this big.
Once you spot your digits, you walk up to the pickup area and carry your pizza back to your table. There is no waiter stopping by, so the mirrors do the job of getting your attention.
It takes a minute to get the hang of it. Watch the glass, stay close enough to see it, and do not wander off too far.
The system is a big part of why people talk about this place long after they leave, and it is the detail that makes first-timers grin.
Meet Fargo’s Pizza Co.
So where do you find these mirrors? The answer is Fargo’s Pizza Co., at 2910 E Platte Ave in Colorado Springs, Colorado, United States.
It is a big pizzeria with a Victorian-style look, and it has seating for 500 people. That is a lot of chairs for one pizza spot.
The size shapes everything about the visit. Rooms flow into other rooms, and each corner has its own feel.
Plan to take a minute just to look around before you pick a table. The place is built for large groups, family dinners, and birthday gatherings, though a small party fits in just fine too.
Hours run from 11 am most days, with later closing times on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, so you have a nice window to stop by.
An Old West Saloon Feel Without the Dust
The decor leans hard into a Wild West theme, and it works. Dark wood, vintage touches, and playful details make the rooms feel like a movie set.
Some people say the vibe mixes a classic saloon with a family fun center. That is a fair way to describe the mood.
The costumes add to it, as the people working the counter dress in outfits that match the theme.
Take your time wandering. Every wall seems to hold something different, from old signs to odd collectibles, and you will likely spot new things on a second visit.
The goal here is to feel like you stepped into another era while you wait on a hot pizza.
Stained Glass and Grand Dining Rooms
Look up and around, because the windows deserve attention. Stained glass is scattered through the building, and it throws color across the tables when the light hits.
The dining rooms feel grand in a Victorian way, with ornate touches that make an ordinary pizza night feel like a special outing.
Families often pick a room and settle in for a while. Some spaces are cozy, while others are wide open and made for crowds.
There is also an upstairs seating area, so you have choices depending on how lively you want your meal to be. A fireplace adds another warm detail for those who like a calm corner.
Bring a camera, since the glasswork and furnishings make for great photos.
A Quarter for the Player Piano
Here is a small thrill: drop a quarter into the player piano and the keys start moving by themselves. Music fills the room, and nobody is sitting at the bench.
It is one of the details people mention again and again. The tune adds a honky-tonk feel that suits the Old West look.
Long tables sit near the piano, making it a popular spot for bigger parties. Kids love watching the keys dance.
Since there is no change machine, bring some coins ahead of time. A few quarters in your pocket will cover the piano and any arcade fun later.
It is a cheap bit of entertainment while you wait for your number to light up.
The Self-Serve Salad Bar
The salad bar is one of the most talked-about parts of the menu. It stands out as a signature feature, with a wide spread of fresh vegetables and toppings.
You grab a bowl and build your own plate. Plan your approach, because the bowl size shapes how much you can fit.
Pudding and dessert items sometimes show up here too, and a foam cup is handy for sweets.
Many families start with a trip to the bar while the pizza bakes. It keeps hungry kids busy and gives adults something fresh before the cheesy main event.
Ask at the register how the pricing and bowls work, so there are no surprises when it is time to fill up.
Handmade Pizza and Crust Choices
The pizza is made by hand, and the crust gets most of the attention. Many diners say the base is the part they remember best.
There is a gluten-free option, available on the smaller nine inch size. That is helpful to know before you order.
Sizes include small and giant, so think about your group before you commit. A giant pie goes a long way with a crowd.
Toppings can be dialed up or down, and the Super Combination comes loaded with tomatoes. If you want fewer, just ask at the counter.
Longtime fans note the recipe has shifted over the years, so try a pie with fresh eyes and decide for yourself.
Baked Spaghetti, Ravioli, and Sweet Treats
Pizza is not the only thing coming out of the kitchen. Pasta fans can try baked spaghetti or cheese ravioli with marinara or meat sauce.
There is also a chicken alfredo pizza for those who prefer a creamy pie over a red sauce one.
Save room for dessert if you can. Carrot cake gets a lot of love from regulars.
Garlic bread and garlic knots round out the sides, so a table can mix and match to suit different tastes. Ordering a few dishes to share is a smart way to sample more of the menu without overdoing it.
Everything is picked up at the counter once your number appears on the mirror.
Arcade Games and a Magician
Waiting for a pizza is easy when there is an arcade down the hall. The game room has classics like Pac-Man, Galaga, and Skee-Ball.
Some visitors mention that a few machines may be out of order, so keep your expectations flexible. New games have been added over time.
A magician also performs at times, and kids enjoy watching the tricks up close.
That mix of games and magic is why the place works so well for birthday parties and family nights. Bring coins or cash, because there is no change machine on site.
Give yourself time to play a round or two before your number glows on the mirror.
Tips for Your First Visit
A little planning makes the first visit smoother. You order at the counter, take your number, and then watch the mirrors for it.
Choose a table where you can see a mirror easily, since food sits and cools if you miss your number.
Ask the person at the register to explain the system if it is your first time. They can also help you pick a pizza size.
Bring cash or coins for the piano and arcade, and expect a bigger crowd on weekends. The restaurant opens at 11 am daily, closing at 8 pm early in the week and 9 pm Friday through Sunday.
Check the website for current updates before you go.
Why Families Keep Coming Back
Ask around Colorado Springs and you will hear stories. Some families have been coming for decades, and several generations have celebrated birthdays here.
That history gives the building a warm, familiar feel. Grandparents bring grandkids to the same rooms they once visited with their own children.
Visitors from out of town often get brought along too, because the place is simply different from a typical pizza chain.
If you enjoy quirky spots, consider pairing a meal here with other local stops around Colorado Springs, like parks or museums. The magic mirrors, the piano, and the stained glass make this a memorable pizza night.
Go with curious kids, hungry friends, and a pocketful of quarters.
Share this story
