Pennsylvania’s shoofly pie is an old-fashioned dessert built around molasses, a crumb topping, and a recipe that has been part of Pennsylvania Dutch baking for generations. Some bakeries have made it their signature treat, while others sell it alongside sticky buns, whoopie pies, apple dumplings, and homemade breads.
There are two main styles worth knowing. Wet-bottom shoofly pie has a soft, gooey molasses layer beneath the crumbs, while dry-bottom versions have a firmer, more cake-like filling.
Both have loyal fans, and plenty of people have strong opinions about which one belongs on the dessert table.
From Lancaster County bake shops to Reading Terminal Market, these ten Pennsylvania bakeries offer plenty of reasons to bring home a pie. Some stick closely to traditional recipes, while others have additional treats that make the stop worthwhile.
And if you’ve never tried shoofly pie before, this is a good place to start.
1. Bird-in-Hand Bakery & Cafe
Ever ordered shoofly pie and an apple fritter sundae in the same visit? At this two-level bakery and cafe, nobody will judge you.
Shoofly pie sits alongside whoopie pies and apple fritters in the cases. Fresh local ice cream adds another sweet option.
Custom cakes can be ordered for birthdays and other big moments.
Hungry for real food first? The menu covers breakfast sandwiches with egg and cheese, a chef salad, and chicken salad sandwiches.
A half sandwich with a cup of soup works well for a lighter lunch.
Seating is spread across more than one area, including an upstairs space. Kids may enjoy the petting zoo on the property.
Free Wi-Fi and a free parking lot make a longer stop easy.
Doors open at 6 AM Monday through Saturday, which is great for early risers. The cafe stays closed on Sundays.
Midweek mornings are usually quieter than Mondays.
Address: 2715 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird in Hand, PA 17505
2. Bird in Hand Bakeshop
Shoofly with molasses icing appears on the menu here, and yes, that means shoofly flavor shows up in more than one form. Oatmeal whoopie pies come in a shoofly version too.
This family-run shop sits on a country road away from the busiest highway traffic. Traditional shoofly pie shares shelf space with schnitz pie, a dried apple classic of Pennsylvania Dutch baking.
Bread lovers have plenty to grab. Cinnamon raisin bread, pecan sticky buns, and white iced cinnamon rolls come in take-home packs.
Hand-rolled soft pretzels are another reason to linger at the counter.
Amish jams, bulk goods, and craft items round out the shop. Prices stay reasonable, which makes stocking up tempting.
Snickerdoodle and assorted cookies are sold by the dozen.
There’s no seating, so think of it as a grab-and-go stop. Saturdays are the busy day, and the shop closes on Sundays.
Weekday visits usually feel more relaxed.
Address: 542 Gibbons Rd, Bird in Hand, PA 17505
3. Locally Made Food Shop
Baked goods here come straight from the kitchen on-site. That includes fresh shoofly pies, which share counter space with fudge and artistic pretzels.
The shop feels polished and tidy, with a slightly upscale look for an Amish country stop. Staff offer samples, so trying something new feels low-risk.
Whoopie pies are also part of the lineup.
Jars fill a good chunk of the space. You’ll see homemade jams, jellies, sauces, and oils from the area.
Homemade root beer is another local pick worth grabbing.
Souvenir hunters have options as well. Americana Amish dolls and Intercourse PA clothing are sold here, so gifts and dessert can happen in one stop.
Late hours set this shop apart from many nearby bakeries. It stays open until 8:30 PM on Fridays and Saturdays and opens on Sundays too.
A free parking lot makes it an easy evening detour.
Address: 2811 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572
4. Shady Maple Farm Market
Groceries and shoofly pie in one cart? That’s the appeal of this expansive farm market in East Earl.
The bakery section is a big draw. Shoofly pies sit near whoopie pies and donuts, so dessert decisions can take a while.
It’s an easy spot to grab a pie for a family dinner.
Fresh local produce is one of the market’s strengths. Prepared foods and a salad bar make it simple to put together a quick meal.
Flowers and even a pharmacy are under the same roof.
That mix makes this stop practical for road trippers. You can refill snacks, pick up fruit, and get your pie without driving to three different places.
Free parking is available on-site.
The market opens early at 7 AM and stays open until 8 PM Monday through Saturday. Sundays are closed.
Saturdays get busy, so a weekday trip is calmer.
Address: 1324 Main St, East Earl, PA 17519
5. Beiler’s Bakery
Not every great shoofly pie requires a country drive. This Amish bakery sells it right inside Reading Terminal Market in downtown Philadelphia.
Pennsylvania Dutch classics fill the cases. Shoofly pie appears with whoopie pies and cinnamon apple loaf.
Sticky buns and pumpkin pie add even more traditional choices.
Donuts are the other big story. They’re made on-site, with flavors like key lime pie, Boston creme, apple fritter, and blueberry fritter.
Lines can form, but they tend to move quickly.
The menu stretches further than you might guess. Rainbow bagels and Asiago cheese bagels sit alongside carrot cake and cookies by the dozen.
Prices are friendly, making it easy to try a few things.
Parking nearby is paid, so many people pair a visit with other market errands. The bakery opens at 8 AM Monday through Saturday and closes on Sundays.
It’s a handy shoofly stop for city travelers.
Address: 51 N 12th St, Philadelphia, PA 19107
6. Zig’s Bakery & Cafe
A restored barn houses this Lititz bakery, and its wet bottom shoofly pie is the house specialty. That gooey molasses layer is exactly what wet bottom fans want.
Pies are a big focus. Pecan pie gets plenty of attention, and grape pie offers something less common.
Homemade quiche and bread fill out the bakery shelves.
Lunch is a serious option here too. The deli-style menu includes a turkey pesto sandwich, plus homemade pastries for after.
Coffee drinks like an iced caramel macchiato pair nicely with dessert.
Nice weather? Grab a seat on the patio.
Dine-in and takeout are both available, so you can eat now or save your slice for later.
Weekday hours run until 7 PM, which helps if you’re driving after work. Saturday closes at 3 PM, and Sundays are off.
Saturday mornings are busiest, so weekdays work well.
Address: 800 E Newport Rd, Lititz, PA 17543
7. Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery
Since 1946, this Lincoln Highway stop has made shoofly pie its main claim to fame. The name on the sign leaves no doubt about what to order.
Each pie follows the classic Pennsylvania Dutch formula. You get a molasses-based filling under a crumb topping.
Staff hand out free samples, so you can taste before you commit to a whole pie.
Pecan pie and other desserts are also on hand. Homemade root beer is part of the sampling lineup too, which is a fun pairing with something so sweet.
The shop doubles as a gift store with a playful, old-school personality. Shelves hold Amish souvenirs, local goods, Pennsylvania Dutch spices, and pickled items.
There’s no dine-in seating, so plan to take your treats to go.
Hours run most days, but Wednesday is a day off. Sundays and Saturday afternoons get busy, while Mondays tend to be calmer.
Plan your stop with that in mind.
Address: 2857 Lincoln Hwy A, Ronks, PA 17572
8. Yoder’s Country Market
Shoofly pie tastes even better when it comes from a bakery that knows its Pennsylvania Dutch traditions. Yoder’s Country Market in New Holland is a great place to find the classic wet-bottom version.
The gooey molasses filling sits beneath a sweet crumb topping, giving each slice a mix of soft and crunchy textures.
The bakery also makes whoopie pies, sticky buns, fruit crumb pies, and other homemade treats.
Need groceries while you’re there? This family-friendly market has plenty beyond the bakery counter.
Fresh produce, meats, deli items, and pantry staples fill the aisles. It’s easy to turn a quick dessert stop into a full shopping trip.
The market has a welcoming country-store atmosphere without feeling too small or crowded.
You can pick up a whole shoofly pie to share at home or grab a few extra sweets for the road.
Free parking makes stopping convenient, especially if you’re traveling through Lancaster County.
Address: 14 S Tower Rd, New Holland, PA 17557
9. The Bake Shop at Kitchen Kettle Village
A visit to Kitchen Kettle Village in Intercourse can easily turn into an afternoon of shopping and snacking. The Bake Shop is one of the sweetest reasons to stop.
Traditional shoofly pie is part of the bakery’s Pennsylvania Dutch lineup. Its rich molasses flavor makes it a natural choice for anyone exploring local desserts.
Whoopie pies, cookies, and other freshly baked treats offer plenty of alternatives.
The village setting adds to the experience. Instead of walking into a standalone bakery, you’ll find yourself surrounded by specialty food shops, handmade crafts, and local gifts.
Jams, jellies, and other Pennsylvania Dutch favorites are easy to find nearby.
It’s a fun place to visit with family or friends because everyone can explore something different.
You can pick up a pie, browse the shops, and enjoy the atmosphere without rushing to the next stop.
Parking is available at the village, making it convenient for travelers exploring Amish Country.
Address: 3529 Old Philadelphia Pike, Intercourse, PA 17534
10. Arianna’s Bakery
Wet-bottom shoofly pie fans have another reason to look toward New Holland. Arianna’s Bakery specializes in traditional baked goods, including the gooey molasses dessert.
The wet-bottom style is especially appealing if you prefer a softer, richer filling beneath the crumb topping.
Shoofly pie isn’t the only sweet worth knowing about here. Apple dumplings and cream-filled cake rolls are also among the bakery’s specialties.
Those options make it an interesting name for anyone who enjoys old-fashioned Pennsylvania baking.
Unlike a typical roadside bakery with a large storefront, Arianna’s primarily operates as a wholesale bakery.
That means it’s important to check whether direct purchases or pickup arrangements are available before making the drive.
For readers who love discovering smaller local producers, it’s a bakery worth keeping on the radar.
You won’t find the same busy shopping atmosphere that comes with a large farm market or tourist bakery. The appeal here is the focus on familiar, homemade-style desserts that have been part of Pennsylvania Dutch kitchens for generations.
Apple dumplings are especially tempting if you enjoy fruit-filled pastries with a comforting, old-fashioned flavor.
If you’re already exploring New Holland, it’s worth checking where Arianna’s baked goods are available locally. That way, you can enjoy a traditional treat without making an unnecessary detour.
Address: 158 E Jackson St, New Holland, PA 17557
Share this story
