Some of the best meals in New York hide inside plain-looking buildings next to grocery stores and parking lots. You walk in expecting an ordinary buffet, and suddenly you are staring at piles of snow crab legs, a sushi bar, and a whole lobster that costs less than a sandwich.
It feels like finding a secret that the rest of the city somehow missed. If you love seafood and a good bargain, this is one stop worth planning your appetite around.
A Seafood Haven on Nostrand Avenue
Tucked along the southern end of Brooklyn, Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet sits at 3839 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235. From the street, it might look like just another large restaurant near a shopping strip.
Step inside, though, and the scale of the food spread tells a different story.
The restaurant is an all-you-can-eat Asian and Japanese buffet. Its menu mixes Chinese, Japanese, and American classics in one big room, so nobody at the table has to compromise.
Sushi, seafood, hot pot, ramen, grilled meats, and desserts all share the same roof.
Locals know it as a spot to show up hungry. Visitors often mention the location near familiar neighborhood landmarks like Fun Land and Aldi, which makes it easy to find.
For anyone in Brooklyn craving crab legs without a fancy dinner bill, the address is worth saving on your phone.
From Party Store to Premium Buffet
Fun bit of local trivia: some diners had no idea the building once housed a Party City. Today, the space has been transformed into a sprawling buffet that feels far more polished than its past life would suggest.
Regulars who have lived nearby for years say the place keeps getting better. One longtime neighbor noticed that every return visit brought some new improvement, from fresh dishes to upgraded decor.
After a renovation, the dining room gained a more luxurious look with traditional design touches.
Not everyone loved every change. A few returning guests felt the flavors shifted after the remodel and missed the old recipes.
That mix of opinions is normal for a place that has grown so much. What stands out is the effort to live up to the word premium in its name, turning a former retail shop into a destination where Brooklyn families gather for big, relaxed meals.
Unlimited Snow Crab Legs
Crack, pull, dip, repeat. That rhythm is exactly why so many people drive to this corner of Brooklyn.
Snow crab legs are one of the headline attractions, and since the buffet is all-you-can-eat, the only limit is how much patience you have for shells.
Diners who love crab describe the seafood as feeling fresh, and the crab legs come up again and again when people talk about their visits. Some call them the high point of a seafood journey that begins with oysters and clams and ends with a plate full of legs.
A simple tip helps here. Grab a small portion first, then head back once you know how quickly you eat them.
Staff keep sections replenished, so there is no need to pile up a mountain on your first trip. Bring napkins, roll up your sleeves, and enjoy the delicious mess that comes with real crab.
The $6 Whole Lobster Upgrade
Six dollars. In New York, that barely covers a fancy coffee, yet here it can add a whole lobster to your buffet meal.
Visitors rave about this upgrade, and lobster is the most talked-about dish tied to the restaurant.
One excited diner pointed out that you can upgrade with a whole lobster for just $6 on top of the regular buffet price. The restaurant itself has mentioned grilled lobster among the favorites guests enjoy.
For lobster fans, that deal alone can make the trip feel like a win.
Here is the part to understand before you sit down. Some guests found signs about lobster, such as a half lobster tail per customer, a bit confusing and assumed it was included.
It actually costs extra. Ask your server politely how the lobster option works on the day you visit, and you will avoid any surprises when the check arrives.
Sushi, Sashimi, and a Touch of Caviar
Sushi lovers, your section has arrived. Sushi is the single most discussed item among visitors, and the bar is big enough to keep you busy through several trips.
What sets the spread apart from a typical Chinese buffet is a full sushi bar that includes sashimi and even caviar. One lunch guest singled this out as the real difference maker.
A young regular says she always heads straight to the sushi station because she simply loves it.
Opinions on quality do vary. A few diners felt the rice was too firm or thick on some pieces, and others wished the flavors were bolder.
Still, many describe the fish as fresh and the variety as impressive. A smart move is to sample a few different rolls and sashimi slices first, then return for the ones that hit the spot.
Picking favorites is half the fun.
Raw Bar Treasures: Oysters and Clams
Picture a bed of crushed ice glittering under the lights, topped with oysters and clams waiting to be picked up. The raw bar gives seafood fans a starting point that feels a little more special than the average buffet line.
One guest described the ideal order of attack: begin with oysters, move through the clams, and finish with crab legs. It works like a tasting tour, building from light and briny bites to richer ones.
Clams in particular pop up often when people describe what they filled their plates with.
Seafood taste is personal, of course. A few diners found the ocean flavor stronger than they liked, while others praised the freshness.
If raw shellfish is new to you, try one or two pieces before loading up. Plenty of cooked options are close by, so you can easily switch lanes if the raw bar turns out not to be your thing.
Hot Pot, Hibachi, and Made-to-Order Ramen
Cold seafood is great, but sometimes you want something steaming. Hot pot, hibachi, and ramen give the buffet a cozy, interactive side that many guests enjoy.
Hot pot is served in individual bowls heated at the table. One happy diner loves ordering it spicy, adding a whole bunch of vegetables, and says the heat was just right, never overpowering.
Another guest noted that the burner setup can leave a smoky smell around the table, so keep that in mind if you are sensitive to it.
Ramen is made to order, which feels like a nice upgrade from noodles sitting under a heat lamp. Hibachi is another popular topic among visitors, adding a grilled element to the mix.
Together, these stations let you build a meal that changes from bite to bite. Build a spicy broth, slurp some noodles, then return to the crab.
Options Beyond the Ocean
Not everyone in the family loves seafood, and that is perfectly okay. The buffet also offers chicken, beef, and pork dishes, plus all the classic Chinese buffet favorites you might expect.
One visitor was surprised by how tasty the meat dishes turned out, even calling them a highlight. Another guest recommended the grilled meats as part of a well-rounded plate.
That makes the place a reasonable pick for groups with mixed tastes.
Honesty matters, though. A diner who is not a fan of seafood felt the non-seafood choices made up only a smaller share of the menu.
So if your group has picky eaters who avoid fish entirely, set expectations before you go. For most mixed tables, there is still enough variety that everyone should leave full.
A grilled skewer on one plate and crab on another keeps the peace at family dinners nicely.
Sweet Endings at the Dessert and Drink Station
Save room. Seriously.
After all that crab, a dessert and drink station waits with sweets, fruit, ice cream, and bubble tea.
Families with young kids like that the ice cream keeps little ones happy, and one regular listed fruits and yummy desserts among her favorite parts. Drinks are included with the buffet, and at least one guest adored a refreshing drink that paired nicely with spicy hot pot.
Tastes differ at this station more than anywhere else. One visitor warned that the boba drinks were too sugary for them, and another fan of the old setup asked for an ice cream machine like the one at a different buffet.
The best plan is to grab small samples. A scoop of ice cream, a slice of fruit, and a tiny cake will tell you what is worth a second trip.
Finishing on something sweet makes the long feast feel complete.
Atmosphere, Service, and Who Will Love It
Walking in feels like a bit of an event. Several guests describe a beautiful space with traditional design elements, and one young diner even noticed the decorative tree near the entrance before stepping inside.
Service stories range widely. Many visitors praise attentive staff who keep tables clean and friendly workers who remember regular families by name.
Others had less pleasant moments with servers who seemed rushed or short with them. Your experience may depend on the day and how busy the room is.
So who fits best here? Seafood fans, big eaters, and families who like trying lots of dishes at once will feel right at home.
Groups celebrating something casual also enjoy the variety. If you prefer a quiet, carefully plated meal with slow service, this probably is not your ideal spot.
Come with an appetite and an open mind, and the lively setting tends to work in your favor.
Hours, Prices, and Smart Visiting Tips
Planning helps you get the most for your money. The buffet opens daily at 11:30 AM, closing at 10 PM Sunday through Thursday and at 10:30 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Prices typically fall in the $40 to $50 range per person for dinner. Guests have reported lunch starting around $23.99 and dinner around $39.99, though holiday pricing can run higher.
Some diners mention an automatic service charge on the bill, and one noticed a $1.50 discount per adult when booking online, while another mentioned a 5% deal. Ask about current offers when you arrive.
There is also a two hour time limit, so pace yourself. Free parking is available outside, though the lot can get crowded given nearby stores like Aldi and Fun Land.
Call +1 718-648-6888 or visit umibuffet.com before heading over to confirm prices and details.
The Final Word on a Brooklyn Crab Feast
Is it perfect? No buffet ever is.
Some diners leave wishing for bolder flavors or friendlier service, and those notes are fair to keep in mind.
Still, the big picture is hard to ignore. Endless snow crab legs, a full sushi bar with sashimi and caviar, a raw bar, bubbling hot pot, fresh ramen, and a lobster upgrade for about the price of a snack make a strong case.
Plenty of families return again and again, and some regulars consider it their go-to meal out.
Think of it as a fun, hearty adventure rather than a fine dining evening. Arrive hungry, check the current pricing, ask about the lobster, and watch the clock so you can enjoy every trip to the buffet line.
For seafood lovers in New York hunting for value, this Brooklyn spot deserves at least one delicious try.
Share this story
