Some of the best stops in Ohio look like nothing from the road. I pulled off a quiet highway, tucked into a little valley, and found a place where the smell of cheese hit me before I reached the door.
Staff in old world clothing, a waterfall, and a counter full of samples made me forget my plans for the afternoon. Hungry and curious, I wanted to see what else was hiding inside.
A Cheese House Tucked Into a Quiet Valley
Tucked just off the main highway in Ohio’s Amish country, Broad Run Cheese sits in a small valley that is easy to miss. Visitors say the signage is good and parking is plentiful, though a few mention using GPS on a first trip.
The listing calls it a cheese shop, and that is the heart of it. Locally made cheeses fill the cases, along with deli meats, charcuterie, and a surprising amount of other treasures.
Holmes County travelers often tuck it into a day of sightseeing, and locals say they return whenever company comes to town. It feels like a small-town store from an earlier era, only with a lot more to explore than you would guess from the parking lot.
Old World Costumes and Small-Town Charm
Step through the door and the first thing you notice may be the clothing. Staff dress in old world attire, and visitors say it adds real personality to the whole stop.
Friendly staff is the most mentioned topic among guests, with 17 mentions in the data. People describe helpful, knowledgeable workers who happily answer questions and share local tips.
One longtime fan called it what cozy town shops used to feel like, and that comment fits. A family owned feel runs through the place, from the greetings to the way samples are handed over.
The Cheese Case and Its Local Stars
Cheese is the headliner, and the case proves it. Local cheeses are a common talking point, and one visitor planned a return just for the smoked cheddar.
Guests describe the cheese as out of this world, and the selection pairs naturally with deli items, charcuterie, and meats. Homemade crackers earn their own praise from regulars.
Tastings are a big draw here, with 11 mentions in the data. Sampling before buying is the easiest way to find your favorite, so come hungry and ask questions.
If you came expecting only Swiss, leave room to explore the whole case.
Tasting Trays and Sangria Recipe Cards
Forget one-at-a-time sampling. Visitors love that tastings arrive on a tray holding everything they chose, so the group can compare at their own pace.
Fruit-forward flavors come up often, including peach, blueberry, strawberry, and cranberry. Sangria mixes are popular, and guests mention extra recipe cards to take home.
One reviewer noted that samples were charged for, without a posted sign, so it is smart to ask about pricing before you begin. Even so, most comments about tastings are warm, and many say the staff made the experience fun.
Gifts, Laces, and Plenty More to Browse
Allow extra time, because the shelves keep going. Gift items drew 11 mentions, and shoppers describe a cute shop packed with finds.
Beyond cheese, visitors have spotted decor, clothing, pet supplies, and a large, beautiful selection of laces. Road trippers say it is easy to pick up snacks and presents in a single visit.
Another plus is elbow room. A regular noted it is never too crowded compared with other shops around Amish country, which makes wandering the aisles relaxing.
Patio Seating and a Waterfall Soundtrack
Out back, the setting steps up. The outdoor area earned 8 mentions, and guests rave about the large patio and the sound of a waterfall.
Stairs lead up a hill to more seating, including a private covered space. A gas fireplace can be seen from inside or out, and live edge tables are finished to a silky sheen.
One fall visitor loved lunch outside as the colors peaked, which hints at autumn being a lovely time to go. Relaxed and pretty, the patio is where many people linger longest.
Lunch on the Hill
Hungry after browsing? Reviewers mention a restaurant on the hill called Han’s Place, which they say is not to be missed.
One guest enjoyed fries and a tinfoil wrapped lunch of sausage or chicken with roasted potatoes, sweet cabbage, and peppers. Another ate a cheese plate on the patio and called it a highlight.
Menus and hours can change, so check ahead before building a day around it. Pairing a meal with a cheese shop visit makes for an easy, satisfying stop between Amish country sights.
Who Will Enjoy a Stop Here
Cheese lovers are the obvious fit, but the appeal stretches wider. Couples, friends, and traveling families all turn up in the comments.
Road trippers like the snacks and gifts, while locals return with out-of-town guests. Fans of fruit wine and sangria find plenty to sample, and anyone who enjoys quiet outdoor seating will feel at home.
Calm pacing helps, too. Visitors describe fast service and staff who are available to answer questions, so you can move quickly or settle in for a long afternoon.
Hours, Prices, and Getting There
Planning is simple. The shop is open 9 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and closed Sundays.
One visitor wished for later hours, so weekday after-work trips may be tight.
The address is 6011 Old Rte 39 NW, Dover, OH 44622, and the phone number is 330-343-4108. Parking is plentiful and signage is good, though GPS helps on a first visit.
Prices strike most guests as decent, with some items very affordable. A recent visitor found it a little pricey, so set a budget before gift shopping.
A Soft Verdict for Day Trippers
Here is the takeaway. Broad Run Cheese does not shout from the road, yet it rewards anyone who turns in.
With a 4.7 star average across 190 reviews, it clearly leaves a good impression. Friendly staff, a deep cheese selection, a charming patio, and a gift shop worth exploring all make the case.
If you are heading through Amish country, give it an hour or two. Grab a cheese plate, sample a few flavors, and bring home something local.
Ohioans looking for a nearby surprise will find one here.
Share this story
