A restaurant in Ohio serves meatballs that people mention more than almost anything else on the menu. The pasta is made in house, and the menu changes with the seasons.
I like a kitchen that keeps things focused. A fairly small menu gives the cooks room to get each dish right.
That’s a lot of promise for a dinner spot that only opens in the evenings. It closes two days a week, too.
So what keeps pulling people back to this Italian kitchen in a small Ohio town? I think the answer starts with a bowl of pasta.
A Small-Town Ohio Kitchen With Big Italian Ambitions

Novella Osteria is an Italian restaurant in Powell, Ohio, a suburb north of Columbus. It sits at 170 W Olentangy St, close to the center of town.
The name points to the osteria style, a casual, neighborly kind of Italian eatery. Dinner is the only meal on offer, and the doors open at 5 pm on the days it serves.
Plenty of Ohioans drive past towns like Powell without a second thought. This is the kind of stop that can change that habit.
The restaurant is listed as an Italian restaurant, and the menu leans into handmade pasta, shareable starters, and hearty plates. Those basics drive everything else in this article.
Think of it as a weeknight neighborhood place with a polished, special-occasion streak. That mix is rare, and it explains why so many people bring it up when talking about Italian food around central Ohio.
If you live anywhere near Columbus, this one is an easy day trip or dinner run by car.
Handmade Pasta Is The Whole Point Here

Everything starts with pasta made in house. Visitors point to this again and again, and the menu backs it up with a lineup of shapes and sauces.
Rigatoni is the dish mentioned most often, with cacio e pepe and squid ink pasta close behind. Lamb ravioli and street corn gnocchi also come up.
Fresh pasta changes the whole experience. The noodles carry flavor on their own, so the sauce has a partner instead of a stage.
That is the plate worth ordering if you want to understand the buzz around this kitchen. A bowl of rigatoni tells you plenty about the cooks.
Menus here shift with the seasons, so a favorite might rotate out. That gives regulars a reason to return and newcomers a reason to ask what is current.
Servers know the menu well, which helps when the choices are all tempting. Ask for a recommendation and let the kitchen steer.
Those Meatballs Get Mentioned Constantly

Meatballs lead the popular topics by a wide margin, with 18 mentions. That is far more than any pasta on the list.
They show up as a starter, and visitors describe a portion big enough for two. Soft and tender is how people tend to describe them.
Skip the temptation to order them as an afterthought. Ordering them first sets the tone for the whole meal.
Other antipasti draw attention too. Crispy pork belly and a mushroom ricotta crostini have both been enjoyed, and a hazelnut and ricotta crostini gets a nod as well.
Calamari fritti is another starter that has earned praise, and it suits a group of two or more.
With so many hearty openers, pacing matters. Sharing a couple of starters and saving room for pasta is a sensible plan.
Plenty of diners say the starters alone could make an evening. Even so, the pasta deserves its turn.
Free Bread Sets The Tone Before The Menu Even Starts

Complimentary bread arrives early, and diners talk about it with real affection. One describes it as dense and buttery with a little salt on top.
Olive oil comes alongside for dipping. It is a small gesture that makes the table feel welcome.
Bread like this can steal the show if you let it. Pace yourself, because the entrees are generous.
The kitchen also makes focaccia, which some regulars have noted over the years. Tastes vary on how much salt feels right, so it is worth trying and deciding for yourself.
Starting with something simple tells you a lot about a kitchen. When the basics are done with care, the rest of the meal usually follows.
Use it to scoop up leftover sauce, too. Nobody here is going to judge a clean plate.
Pork Belly And Polenta For Anyone Who Wants Something Richer

Pork belly turns up repeatedly in the popular topics. It appears as a crispy starter and in weekly specials.
One Friday special has been a pork belly rotolo over mashed potatoes. Diners describe it as tender with crispy skin.
Pork shank with polenta is another rich option, and polenta with small pieces of apple has been mentioned as a treat. Those little touches show the kitchen paying attention.
Rich dishes like these call for balance. Pairing a fatty main with a lighter starter can keep the meal from feeling heavy.
Tastes differ, of course. Some diners have found the pork belly fattier than they like, so know your preferences before ordering.
Specials change, so ask your server what is on that night. A Saturday special has included eggplant Parmesan.
That kind of rotation keeps the menu from getting stale.
For Seafood Fans, The Squid Ink Pasta Is Calling

Squid ink pasta brings a dramatic look to the table. It comes with shrimp and mussels, a combination that seafood lovers have enjoyed.
Frutti di mare also appears among the popular topics, so seafood has a loyal following here. A seafood fettuccine has earned praise too.
Dark noodles against bright shellfish make for a photo-worthy plate. The flavor is the real reason to order it, though.
Not everyone wants a creamy sauce, and this dish gives another direction. The carbonara covers the heavier, creamier side for those who want it.
With a short menu, each option has a clear purpose. That makes deciding easier than at a place with endless pages.
If you are dining with a group, order a few different pastas and pass the bowls around. You will learn the range of the kitchen fast.
Lamb, Short Rib, And Other Heartier Pasta Choices

Hearty sauces have their place on this menu. A lamb Bolognese with Grana Padano has been enjoyed, and so has a short rib ragu with rigatoni.
Lamb ravioli appears among the popular topics as well. Cold evenings seem made for these plates.
Portions run generous. One diner expected small plates and was surprised by hearty servings, including lasagna with two pieces.
Such sauces can lean rich, and a diner or two has noted the heaviness. If you like bold, rustic cooking, that is a plus.
Gnocchi is another standout, with the street corn version drawing a couple of mentions. It is a lighter-feeling pillow compared with the ragu dishes.
Ask your server which sauce is the best fit for your appetite. They are well versed in the menu.
Leftovers are a real possibility, which is not a bad problem to have.
Salads, Sweets, And The Little Extras

Salads get more attention than you might expect. A beet salad that actually contains plenty of beets won a fan.
A Caesar salad has been made well, and diners have called the salads unique. Vegetables get real effort here.
Sweet endings include tiramisu, lemon cookies, and chocolate zeppole. Each has had its supporters.
Fried brussels sprouts with pomegranate have appeared as a side. They are a fun addition if you want something crisp next to pasta.
Menus rotate by season, so a favorite side may change. That keeps the kitchen interesting from visit to visit.
Save a little room for dessert if you can. Lemon cookies at the end are a light way to close out a rich meal.
A Warm, Modern Room That Works For Date Night

The dining room feels warm, modern, and welcoming. Diners have called it beautiful and romantic, even when packed on a Saturday night.
A bar offers another place to eat if you have not reserved a table. It is a handy backup plan.
Patio seating is available in warmer weather. One diner noted adequate shading and a comfortable level of noise.
The space suits date nights and small groups. Cloth napkins add a touch of polish.
Winter brings a tradeoff, since the bar sits close to the entrance. A curtain helps block the draft, though some find it a bit close.
Overall the mood is relaxed but a little dressy. You can wear nice jeans and fit right in.
Service is often called attentive and kind. That friendly rhythm shapes the whole evening.
Service That Makes Mistakes Feel Small

Service earns steady praise. Servers are described as knowledgeable and warm, with frequent but not annoying check-ins.
One group of eight wanted a table at a place with a standard maximum of six. The manager helped make space even after a date mix-up.
That kind of flexibility stands out. Hospitality can matter as much as the pasta.
Pacing can vary on a busy night. A diner suggested ordering appetizer and entree together to keep things moving.
Experiences differ, and no restaurant is perfect every night. Still, kindness comes up more than anything else.
If you need a bigger table, call ahead and ask. It is always smarter than hoping for the best.
Who Will Love It Most

Couples fit well here, thanks to the romantic lighting and shareable starters. Small groups do too.
Birthday dinners and friend gatherings are common occasions. A larger party needs planning ahead.
Pasta lovers are the natural audience. If you do not care for Italian food, the menu may feel limited.
Someone in the party may want a non-pasta option. Meat and fish dishes are available, and daily specials add more choices.
Diners who like bold, rustic flavors will be happiest. Those who prefer lighter plates can pick carefully.
Special events like tasting menus have been mentioned. Watch for those if you enjoy a multi-course night.
Hours Worth Writing Down Before You Go

Planning matters here. Novella Osteria is closed Monday and Sunday.
Tuesday through Thursday it serves from 5 to 8 pm. Friday and Saturday stretch to 9 pm.
Weekend evenings can be busy, so reservations are a smart idea. Walk-ins may find a seat at the bar.
The restaurant sits at 170 W Olentangy St in Powell. It is a short drive from Columbus.
Hours can change, so check with the restaurant before you head out. That keeps your evening from hitting a locked door.
Arrive a bit early if you want a relaxed start. The kitchen closes earlier than many dinner spots.
What To Know About Cost

Prices run on the higher side for some diners. One guest felt a dinner for two came out a bit pricey.
Portions are hearty, though, which helps. Sharing a starter keeps things reasonable.
Handmade pasta costs more to produce than the boxed kind. That is part of what you pay for.
Large parties may face a booking policy. Ask about it when you reserve.
Treat it as a nice night out rather than a quick bite. That mindset makes the value clearer.
Check the current menu before you go. Seasonal changes affect what is offered.
The Verdict On A Small-Town Ohio Italian Favorite

So does one plate of pasta explain the praise? Pretty much, yes.
Handmade rigatoni and its peers carry the story.
Add meatballs, free bread, and a warm room, and the picture fills in. Kind service ties it together.
Not every dish suits every taste. A few diners found sauces heavy or portions rich.
Overall, Novella Osteria earns a spot on any Ohio food list. It proves that a great Italian dinner can be found in a small town.
Call ahead, plan around the hours, and bring an appetite. Then order the rigatoni.
It may be the best reason to take a drive in Ohio this season.
Share this story

