You pull into a busy parking lot in South Carolina expecting just another beach buffet, the kind you forget by morning. Then you step inside and find sharks hanging overhead, servers in crisp uniforms, and steaming piles of crab legs as far as you can see.
Your stomach growls, your eyes go wide, and suddenly dinner feels like an adventure. Here is why this seafood spot sticks in people’s memories long after the plates are cleared.
A Seafood Giant on North Kings Highway

Picture a stretch of road packed with seafood buffets, each one shouting for attention. Among them sits The Original Benjamin’s Calabash Seafood at 9593 N Kings Hwy in Myrtle Beach, and it tends to be the one with the line out front.
At its heart, the place is a vast, nautical-themed, all-you-can-eat seafood buffet. Diners grab a plate and wander from station to station, choosing whatever looks good, with mounted sharks watching from above.
It is less of a quick bite and more of a full evening out.
Visitors often describe it as one of the largest buffets they have seen on the coast, both in food choices and in seating. One guest even noticed that, while checking several seafood spots around opening time, this was the only one with a full lot and people waiting.
That kind of crowd tells you something before you even taste a single hush puppy.
Calabash Roots and Family Traditions

Calabash is more than a word on the sign. It points to a style of Carolina seafood cooking that diners here mention again and again, and many come specifically to enjoy those coastal favorites alongside the crab.
What really stands out, though, is how many families treat this buffet like a tradition. One visitor shared that their parents brought them here on vacation as a kid, and now they bring their own children.
That same family loved it so much they came back twice in a single week.
Others return from nearby states several times a year, making the drive a regular part of their beach plans. A meal that gets passed down through generations says plenty about the place.
Fun thought: some kids eating hush puppies here today may be the parents leading the way to the same tables twenty years from now. Few restaurants can claim that kind of loyalty.
Sharks Overhead and Ships Everywhere

Look up. That is the first piece of advice for anyone walking in, because mounted sharks hover above the buffet stations like silent guards of the crab legs.
Then look around. Model ships, maritime decorations, and ocean treasures fill room after room.
Guests often say the whole building feels like a museum where you happen to eat dinner, and some compare it to walking onto a cruise ship or even the Titanic.
One diner especially enjoyed the dry aquarium idea, a clever display that brings sea life indoors without any water. Others spent as much time wandering and learning about ships and uniforms as they did eating.
Families with kids who get restless at the table will find this a real bonus. There is always something new to point at, ask about, or gaze at between plates.
Few buffets give you a history lesson with your fried shrimp.
The Main Event: Endless Crab Legs

Crab legs are the star here, no contest. They come up in conversation about this restaurant far more than anything else, and the all-you-can-eat setup is exactly why so many people walk through the door.
Fans describe the legs as always steaming with excellent taste. Plenty of diners load up plate after plate, cracking shells until their fingers ache.
Not every trip lands perfectly, though. A few guests said the meat was stubborn to pull out on certain batches, and one noticed the second round tasted better than the first.
Another group admitted they eventually gave up wrestling with shells and happily turned to the rest of the buffet instead.
So here is a fair tip: if your first batch is tricky, try again later when a fresh round comes out. And keep plenty of napkins nearby, because this is gloriously messy eating at its best.
Beyond the Shell: Oysters, Shrimp and Southern Sides

Hungry for something besides crab? You are in luck, because the spread here is so wide that one regular doubted anyone could try everything in a single visit.
Fried oysters and hush puppies earn tons of love, and the hush puppies are said to be especially tasty fresh and hot. Bang shrimp became a favorite for one guest, while others praised the broiled shrimp, broiled scallops, crab cakes, salmon patties, and trout.
Crawfish show up too.
Comfort sides hold their own. Real mashed potatoes with gravy get compliments, and a vegetable beef soup surprised at least one diner.
Honest feedback exists as well. Some found certain fried items greasy and a few pans not warm enough.
One clever tip: grab grits and shrimp separately and build your own bowl rather than taking the premade combo. Small choices like that help you shape the perfect plate.
Prime Rib and Picks for Non-Seafood Fans

Not everyone in your group loves fish, and that is fine. Visitors point out there are plenty of choices for people who would rather skip seafood altogether.
Prime rib gets a lot of attention, and one guest called the steak tenderloin almost melt-in-your-mouth, though slightly salty. Ribs, pasta, and different kinds of wings also appear on the line, along with a salad bar that one diner described as great.
Opinions on beef do vary. One visitor felt the roast beef missed the mark, reasoning that most people come for seafood anyway.
Parents should know one thing ahead of time. A guest noted there was no separate kids’ buffet with items like chicken nuggets or corn dogs, so picky young eaters may need to hunt a little.
Still, with this many stations, most folks find something that makes them smile.
Soft Serve, Cobblers and the Sweet Finish

Save room. Seriously, the dessert bar deserves a little planning.
Soft serve ice cream seems to be a hit with nearly everyone, and it pairs perfectly with warm cobbler. Desserts come portioned in small cups or squares, so you can sample several without committing to a giant slice.
One diner felt overwhelmed by the options in the best way, and another fondly mentioned Ranger cookies.
Brownies got a thumbs-up even from a guest who was less impressed by the rest of the sweets.
To be fair, dessert is where opinions split most. A few people found some treats tasted artificial, while others called the bar amazing.
Our advice? Start with ice cream and cobbler, the crowd favorites, then explore from there.
Worst case, you get a second scoop, and nobody ever complained about that.
Uniformed Servers and a Guided Welcome

Most buffets hand you a plate and point. Here, the welcome feels almost formal.
Staff members dressed in full professional uniforms wait near the door, which made one guest feel like they were entering somewhere fancy. Your server then walks you to the table and explains how everything works, often giving a little guided tour of the stations.
Service gets glowing words again and again. Diners mention drinks always refilled, dirty plates cleared fast, and servers sharing stories about the restaurant and the Myrtle Beach area.
One server happily handled a party of about 29 people.
Several guests said they rarely see this level of care at a buffet. One heads-up: the dining rooms can get loud, so catching every word of the tour might take some leaning in.
Even so, many visitors left saying their server made the whole night.
Downstairs Surprises Worth Seeking Out

Here is a secret some guests almost missed: head downstairs.
Below the main dining area, families discovered a small play area for kids and a sail maker’s office display that one visitor called the coolest part of the trip. Another group admitted they never would have known about the lower level if their server had not mentioned it.
There is also a gift shop, praised for beautiful items, including some made by local artists. It makes a nice stop for a souvenir that is not a plastic keychain.
Why does this matter? Because a long buffet dinner with little ones can test anyone’s patience.
Having a spot to wander, explore, and stretch legs turns the meal into an outing. So before you leave, ask your server to point you toward the stairs.
A few extra minutes might become your favorite memory of the evening.
Hours, Prices and Beating the Line

Timing is everything at a place this popular. Doors open at 3:30 PM and close at 9 PM, seven days a week.
Expect a crowd. Guests say a line forms even before opening, especially on weekends, though one family arriving at 3:25 PM was seated in about five minutes.
Seating is often quick once the doors swing open.
Now, the money talk. Recent visitors reported the adult buffet at $52.99, with an earlier price of $49.99 mentioned too.
Add tax, tip, and a drink, and one diner landed around $65 per person. A party of four adults and four kids topped $500.
Some felt every penny was worth it, while others wished a drink beyond water was included. Coupons were hard to find for one family.
Call 843-449-0821 or visit originalbenjamins.com before heading over to check current details.
Our Take Before You Grab a Plate

So, is it worth the trip? For most people, the answer seems to be a happy yes.
You come for crab legs and leave remembering the sharks, the ships, the uniformed welcome, and the server who knew everything about Myrtle Beach. The food is not flawless every single night, and the price is real.
Still, the sheer variety, the friendly staff, and that museum-like setting make it feel like an event rather than just dinner.
Big appetites will get the most value, especially crab lovers ready for several rounds. Families looking for a memorable vacation night will enjoy the exploring as much as the eating.
One guest summed up the feeling nicely by urging others not to be fooled by similar names nearby. Arrive early, bring patience for the crowd, and leave room for soft serve.
Your beach trip just found its tastiest chapter.
Share this story

