Unearth The Voyage
Ohio boasts a vibrant ice cream scene with locally-owned shops offering unique flavors that often surpasses national chains. From Cincinnati to Cleveland, these parlors are celebrated for their artisanal creations, nostalgic settings, and community ties. Each shop has its own unique charm, drawing locals who appreciate quality, tradition, and creativity. Here are nine standout ice cream shops in Ohio that have won the hearts of their communities.
1. Aglamesis Bros.
Aglamesis Bros. has been a Cincinnati treasure since 1908. Founded by Greek immigrant brothers, this charming parlor is celebrated for its made-from-scratch ice cream and hand-dipped chocolates, reminiscent of a bygone era. Stepping inside feels like traveling back in time, with its vintage decor and old-world charm. Many Cincinnati locals argue that this artisanal delight surpasses even the most popular national chains. Despite the popularity of local competitor Graeter’s, Aglamesis holds a special place in the hearts of those who cherish tradition and quality over modern convenience. The nostalgic atmosphere and dedication to craftsmanship make it a beloved spot in the community.
2. Graeter’s Ice Cream
Graeter’s Ice Cream is a Cincinnati institution, dating back to 1870. Known for its dense, French-pot style ice cream, it has been praised for iconic flavors like Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. Oprah Winfrey once declared it ‘the best ice cream [she] ever tasted.’ This family-owned business has expanded beyond Cincinnati into cities like Columbus and Cleveland, yet it retains its traditional charm. Locals appreciate the quality and heritage that Graeter’s embodies, making it a staple in Ohio’s ice cream culture. Despite its growth, the brand remains deeply rooted in its commitment to crafting perfect scoops. Each visit promises a delightful journey through flavor and tradition.
3. Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams
Founded in 2002, Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams has quickly become a beloved Ohio brand. With its artisanal, inventive flavors like Goat Cheese & Cognac Fig, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, Jeni’s has redefined what ice cream can be. Their commitment to using meticulously sourced ingredients from local farms sets them apart. The sleek, modern shops offer a fresh twist on traditional ice cream parlors. Locals often regard Jeni’s as a cut above both regional and national brands due to its craftsmanship and flavor complexity. This creative approach to ice cream has fostered a devoted following that appreciates both innovation and quality.
4. Toft Dairy & Ice Cream Parlor
Toft Dairy & Ice Cream Parlor stands as a testament to Ohio’s rich dairy heritage. As the oldest dairy in Ohio, family-run since the early 1900s, it offers an impressive array of over 50 flavors. The massive portions and fresh local milk draw generations of families to its doors. Sandusky locals often speak of Toft’s with pride, citing its nostalgic quality and capacity to surpass generic chain offerings. The parlor’s commitment to tradition and quality resonates with those who grew up savoring its creamy delights. It’s more than just ice cream; it’s a cherished part of local history and a beacon of community pride.
5. Velvet Ice Cream (Ye Olde Mill)
Nestled in Utica, Ohio, Velvet Ice Cream at Ye Olde Mill is a destination that offers more than just sweet treats. Founded in 1914, this fourth-generation family business welcomes visitors with a picturesque setting and a historic visitors’ center. Velvet’s classic flavors, like Banana Cream Pie and seasonal specialties, delight the taste buds. Locals cherish the charm and rich flavors that make this place a local icon. The scenic grounds invite visitors to enjoy ice cream in a way that transcends the average parlor experience. Velvet Ice Cream remains a beloved escape that captivates both the palate and the heart with its timeless appeal.
6. Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream
In the Cleveland area, Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream is renowned for its small-batch, handcrafted approach. By using local and organic ingredients, Mitchell’s offers fresh and transparent flavor experiences. The open kitchen design allows customers to see the magic happen, further instilling trust and admiration. Locals adore the genuine ‘homemade’ charm and the care put into each scoop. The diverse flavors and commitment to quality have built a loyal following, making Mitchell’s a cornerstone of Cleveland’s ice cream scene. Each bite is a celebration of local ingredients and artisanal craftsmanship, setting it apart from both regional and national chains.
7. Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream
Since 1945, Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream has been a Youngstown staple, delighting visitors with over 100 flavorful options. USA Today once called it “the busiest ice cream stand in America.” Founded by Alice Handel from home-grown recipes, this shop offers thick milkshakes and a vibrant atmosphere that captures the essence of summer. The Hometown feel and flavor variety appeal to those seeking something more personal than predictable big-brand scoops. Handel’s continues to charm both locals and visitors with its commitment to quality and tradition. It’s a place where ice cream is not just a treat but an experience to be savored.
8. Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl
Established in 1948, Tom’s Ice Cream Bowl is a beloved icon in Zanesville, celebrated for its enormous sundaes. “Put mine in a soup bowl!” is a famous request here, highlighting the generous servings and fun-loving atmosphere. The American diner-style setting adds to its charm, drawing visitors into a time-honored tradition. Locals appreciate the cultural significance and the sense of community found within its walls. Tom’s offers more than just ice cream; it offers a slice of history and a chance to be part of something special. The enduring appeal of Tom’s lies in its ability to create fond memories with every scoop.
9. Rosati’s Frozen Custard
In Northeast Ohio, Rosati’s Frozen Custard offers a rich, creamy escape with its rotating daily and seasonal flavors. From Wedding Cake to Rainbow Marshmallow, this custard shop delights the senses. The nostalgic, no-frills vibe adds to its charm, inviting visitors to indulge in a sweet retreat. Locals often praise the dense custard and the innovative flavor schedule that sets it apart from national chain soft-serves. Rosati’s is more than just dessert; it’s a beloved local haunt where creativity meets tradition. Each visit promises a new adventure in taste, making it a treasured destination for custard enthusiasts.
