9 Hidden Great Lakes Islands Where Lighthouses Steal the Show

Road Trips
By Ella Brown

The Great Lakes are home to numerous hidden islands, each boasting its own unique lighthouse. These lighthouses, steeped in history and surrounded by natural beauty, offer a glimpse into the past while providing breathtaking views and experiences for visitors. From remote national parks to cozy island communities, each lighthouse tells a story of maritime resilience and serves as a beacon for both ships and tourists alike.

1. Rock Island, Wisconsin (Lake Michigan) — Pottawatomie Lighthouse

© Travel Wisconsin

Perched on a scenic bluff, the Pottawatomie Lighthouse is Wisconsin’s oldest light, dating back to 1836. This charming car-free island offers trails and beaches, inviting visitors to explore its natural beauty. Reachable only by the passenger-only Karfi from Washington Island, Rock Island is a tranquil escape. The lighthouse, maintained by rangers and volunteers, is open seasonally. It is a quiet haven with a beautifully restored light station and a unique stone boathouse. Biking and driving are off-limits, accentuating its peaceful atmosphere.

2. South Manitou Island, Michigan (Lake Michigan) — South Manitou Lighthouse

© Flickr

Standing tall at 104 feet, the South Manitou Lighthouse was once a vital guide for ships navigating the stormy Manitou Passage. Now part of Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, it offers seasonal tours that showcase its preserved grounds and historic charm. Visitors can enjoy expansive beach views and delve into the island’s shipwreck history. The lighthouse climb rewards with sweeping vistas of Lake Michigan, while surrounding cedar forests provide a serene backdrop.

3. Raspberry Island, Wisconsin (Lake Superior) — Raspberry Island Light (Apostle Islands)

© National Park Service

Dubbed the ‘Showplace of the Apostle Islands,’ Raspberry Island Light stands out with its manicured grounds amidst a wild archipelago. Built in 1859, it opens for ranger-led tours in summer, offering both historical insights and stunning views of Lake Superior. Visitors can book dedicated lighthouse trips to this secluded spot, feeling far from the mainland. The island’s unique blend of wilderness and cultivated beauty makes it a must-see, where Superior’s endless stretch meets the horizon.

4. Grand Island, Michigan (Lake Superior) — East Channel Lighthouse

© Munising Visitor’s Bureau

The East Channel Lighthouse, established in 1868, is a beloved fixture on Grand Island’s southeast shore. Its iconic wooden structure once guided sailors into safe harbor and remains a cherished subject for photographers and paddlers alike. A short boat ride from Munising brings you to this quiet island, where the lighthouse stands against the backdrop of Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore. The island’s tranquil vibe and picturesque scenery make it an enchanting destination for history buffs and nature lovers.

5. Isle Royale, Michigan (Lake Superior) — Rock Harbor, Passage Island & Rock of Ages Lights

© National Park Service

A true wilderness escape, Isle Royale National Park houses multiple historic lighthouses. From Rock Harbor to Passage Island, these lights have witnessed the ebb and flow of Lake Superior’s maritime history. The offshore Rock of Ages Light, an engineering marvel, rises from a shoal and remains a striking sight. Accessible only by ferry or seaplane, Isle Royale offers solitude, shipwreck lore, and the timeless allure of classic lighthouse stations amid pristine wilderness.

6. Flowerpot Island, Ontario (Lake Huron) — Flowerpot Island Lightstation (Fathom Five)

© Historic Places Days

Flowerpot Island, part of Fathom Five National Marine Park, is famous for its sea-stack formations resembling flowerpots. Accessible by boat from Tobermory, this small island features a historic lightstation and offers trails, caves, and limited camping. The turquoise-clear waters and karst shoreline create a stunning backdrop for exploration. The lightstation compound, meticulously maintained, provides sweeping views of Georgian Bay, inviting visitors to immerse themselves in its natural and historical wonders.

7. Beaver Island, Michigan (Lake Michigan) — Whiskey Point (St. James/Harbor) Light

© Beaver Island Historical Society

Nicknamed Whiskey Point Light, this 41-foot cylindrical tower overlooks St. James Harbor on Beaver Island. Established in 1870, it continues to serve as an active aid next to a U.S. Coast Guard station. The island’s laid-back atmosphere and rich Great Lakes history make it a fascinating place to visit. Beyond the lighthouse, the island offers a wealth of maritime heritage and scenic views, promising a fulfilling journey for those with a penchant for exploration.

8. South Bass Island, Ohio (Lake Erie) — South Bass Island Lighthouse (Put-in-Bay)

© Toledo Blade

Located at the southwestern tip of South Bass Island, the late-19th-century South Bass Island Lighthouse is a beacon of history. Owned by Ohio State University, it offers seasonal tower climbs and year-round access to its grounds. Its strategic position provides panoramic views of Lake Erie, complementing the vibrant attractions of Put-in-Bay. The lighthouse is a testament to maritime heritage, offering a peaceful retreat amid bustling island life, where visitors can reflect on the enduring legacy of Great Lakes navigation.

9. Manitoulin Island, Ontario (Lake Huron) — Mississagi Strait Lighthouse (Meldrum Bay)

© Wikimedia Commons

At the far west end of Manitoulin Island, the Mississagi Strait Lighthouse stands as a small heritage museum. Built in 1873, it offers visitors a glimpse into the life of a lighthouse keeper. The scenic park surrounding the lighthouse features rugged rock shorelines and expansive water views. Seasonal access allows guests to enjoy the tranquil beauty of the North Channel and stunning sunsets. This end-of-the-road location promises peace and reflection, away from the world’s hustle and bustle.