Unearth The Voyage
When it comes to pizza in Maryland, most people think of the big names – but locals know the real magic happens off the beaten path. Tucked inside strip malls, basements, and quiet neighborhood corners are hidden pizzerias serving slices so good, you’ll never go back to the chains. From Baltimore’s old-school favorites to small-town brick ovens turning out crispy perfection, these are the spots Marylanders keep to themselves – until now. So grab a napkin and get ready to explore Maryland’s 10 secret pizza spots only true locals know about.
1. Matthew’s Pizzeria
Since 1943, Matthew’s Pizzeria in Baltimore has been a beloved neighborhood institution. Known for its iconic crab pizza, this spot combines sweet backfin crab meat with the unmistakable zest of Old Bay seasoning. The thick-crust, square-cut pies evoke nostalgia for many locals who grew up savoring its flavors.
Matthew’s offers a unique take on deep-dish pizza, creating a culinary experience that is both comforting and innovative. Each bite is a testament to tradition, drawing pizza lovers back time and again. Whether it’s the signature crab topping or a classic cheese, Matthew’s continues to weave itself into the fabric of Baltimore’s culinary history.
2. Zella’s Pizzeria
Tucked away in Baltimore’s Hollins Market area, Zella’s Pizzeria serves up hand-tossed, artisanal pies that surprise and delight. The secret to their success lies in their sourdough crust, fermented for days to achieve perfect texture.
Beyond traditional toppings, Zella’s offers creative specialty pies such as prosciutto and fig, enticing adventurous eaters. This family-run spot, with its modest charm, has cultivated a loyal following among those who appreciate quality and creativity. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita or something more daring, Zella’s satisfies every craving with skill and passion.
3. Underground Pizza
Beneath the streets of Baltimore’s Federal Hill, Underground Pizza exudes a secretive charm. This basement location, reminiscent of a speakeasy, specializes in large New York-style slices.
Their dough undergoes a 48-hour fermentation process, resulting in a slice that perfectly balances crispness and chew. Locals adore this hidden gem for its commitment to quality and the lively energy that permeates the space. Whether enjoyed at a cozy table or taken on the go, Underground Pizza delivers an experience as unique as its setting.
4. Isabella’s Brick Oven
Isabella’s Brick Oven, a relatively new addition to Baltimore’s pizza scene, brings a touch of Italy to the neighborhood. Utilizing a 900°F wood-fired oven imported from Naples, they craft pizzas with authenticity and passion.
San Marzano tomatoes and a multi-generation sourdough starter ensure each pie stands out with rich flavors. The high-temperature baking technique results in a perfectly blistered crust, capturing the essence of Neapolitan pizza. Isabella’s commitment to traditional methods makes it a treasured spot for pizza enthusiasts seeking genuine taste.
5. OBO Pizza (One Better Option)
In Southern Maryland, OBO Pizza is making waves with its fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Known for their bold crab pizzas, loaded generously with lump meat, OBO offers a taste of the Chesapeake Bay.
Their “Chesapeake” pie, adorned with Old Bay-seasoned seafood and white sauce, showcases their inventive flair. The commitment to freshness and quality has earned them a dedicated fanbase in Waldorf and beyond. Each slice is a culinary adventure, celebrating local flavors with creativity and care.
6. Frankly…Pizza!
Frankly…Pizza! began as a food truck, evolving into a beloved wood-fired destination in Kensington. Known for fermenting dough over three days, they craft pizzas with a depth of flavor that captivates.
The small space and high-quality ingredients create an intimate dining experience that feels both personal and special. Frankly’s commitment to excellence, from crust to topping, resonates with pizza lovers who appreciate authenticity. This spot stands out for its unique blend of tradition and innovation, offering a memorable slice every time.
7. Grotto Pizza
In Columbia, Grotto Pizza has established itself as a cherished local haunt. Part of a regional chain originating from Delaware, this location is distinguished by its signature swirl of sauce.
The swirl creates a distinctive visual and flavor profile, beloved by those in the know. Grotto maintains consistent quality, ensuring each pie delivers the satisfaction expected by its fans. The lively atmosphere and iconic presentation have made it a staple for pizza aficionados seeking something unique yet familiar.
8. Laurienzo Brick Oven Cafe
Laurienzo Brick Oven Cafe in Clarksburg is a suburban treasure nestled quietly in a strip mall. Known for its brick oven and focused menu, this spot excels in crafting simple yet exquisite pizzas.
High-temperature baking techniques deliver a perfectly crisp crust, while their choice of quality ingredients ensures each pizza sings with flavor. With fewer options but impeccable execution, Laurienzo’s offers a dining experience that is both refined and comforting.
9. Gentleman Jim’s Restaurant
For decades, Gentleman Jim’s Restaurant in Gaithersburg has been a beloved local favorite. Known for its thin, crackly crusts, this spot offers a lighter take on classic pizza comfort.
The hometown vibe and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect gathering place for families and friends. Gentleman Jim’s blends tradition with quality, serving up pizzas that satisfy cravings while creating lasting memories. This timeless appeal keeps locals returning, generation after generation.
10. Fortunato Brothers Pizza
Tucked away in Bel Air, Fortunato Brothers Pizza offers a slice of New York with its foldable yet crisp pizzas. Despite flying under the radar, this spot has captivated locals with its fresh sauce and high standards.
The welcoming, unpretentious environment invites patrons to enjoy classic and specialty pies alike. Fortunato Brothers’ commitment to quality and flavor ensures each visit is satisfying and delightful, making it a hidden gem worth discovering.
