Unearth The Voyage
Chicago’s deep-dish pizza scene offers a myriad of options, each providing an authentic and delightful experience. While some spots are famous tourist attractions, others remain hidden gems cherished by locals. Here are 14 lesser-known deep-dish pizzerias that offer quality and taste without the hype.
1. Pequod’s Pizza
Pequod’s Pizza stands out with its signature caramelized cheese crust. This local favorite, located in Lincoln Park and Morton Grove, offers a unique deep-dish experience that captures the heart of many locals. The cheese crust, which crisps up against the pan, provides a delightful twist on the traditional deep-dish.
Its casual atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for both locals and visitors looking to avoid the typical tourist hustle. Pequod’s is a place where you can enjoy a relaxed dining experience without sacrificing quality. Many patrons visit for the crust alone, which has become a legend in its own right.
Whether you’re a seasoned deep-dish enthusiast or a newcomer, Pequod’s offers something special.
2. The Art of Pizza
In the heart of Lakeview, The Art of Pizza is known for delivering consistently delicious deep-dish pies. Its unpretentious setting allows patrons to focus purely on the flavors and textures of their meal. Established as a reliable favorite, it manages to keep a low profile while serving some of the best pizzas in town.
Their deep-dish is characterized by a rich, savory sauce and a perfect balance of cheese and toppings. The Art of Pizza doesn’t just stop at deep-dish; they also offer a variety of other styles, ensuring a comprehensive pizza experience.
Locals appreciate the casual vibe, making it a convenient choice for take-out or a laid-back dining experience.
3. Bartoli’s Pizzeria
Bartoli’s Pizzeria in Roscoe Village is a testament to family tradition and culinary passion. Since opening in 2013, it has quickly become a beloved neighborhood spot. It’s praised for its robust flavors and hearty portions that don’t fall into the trap of being a commercialized brand.
Their “Bartoli’s Special” is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Each bite offers a delightful mixture of flavors and textures, making every meal memorable.
With a welcoming and cozy atmosphere, Bartoli’s provides a genuine, family-oriented dining experience, drawing regulars who appreciate both quality and community spirit.
4. Labriola Chicago
Labriola Chicago brings an elevated touch to the world of deep-dish pizza. Located near the bustling Magnificent Mile, it offers a sophisticated dining experience with a focus on gourmet toppings and a focaccia-style crust. The upscale setting sets it apart from the typical pizza joint.
Labriola’s pizzas are known for their firm, golden crust that holds a delightful array of fresh ingredients. This spot is perfect for those looking to enjoy deep-dish without compromising on elegance and refinement.
Whether you’re shopping nearby or exploring downtown, Labriola offers a stylish yet satisfying stop for pizza lovers craving something a bit more refined.
5. Pizano’s Pizza & Pasta
Pizano’s Pizza & Pasta is steeped in the rich history of Chicago’s deep-dish scene. With connections to the legendary Malnati family, it offers a classic style pizza in a setting less frenetic than the more tourist-heavy spots.
Known for both its deep-dish and thin-crust options, Pizano’s caters to a variety of tastes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The intimate, welcoming atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals seeking a genuine dining experience.
The quality and consistency of Pizano’s pizzas continue to stand out, offering a delicious slice of Chicago history with every bite.
6. Connie’s Pizza
Connie’s Pizza has been a cherished Chicago institution since 1963. Located on the South Side, it provides a more tranquil alternative to the renowned downtown pizzerias. Its deep-dish roots are evident in every slice, harkening back to the authentic flavors of decades past.
With a strong focus on maintaining tradition and quality, Connie’s delivers pizzas that are both hearty and flavorful. The ambiance is inviting and unpretentious, providing a perfect escape from the bustling downtown crowds.
For those venturing to the South Side, Connie’s is a must-visit, offering a slice of history with every delicious bite.
7. Williams Inn Pizza & Sports Bar
Williams Inn Pizza & Sports Bar offers a cozy, welcoming environment for both pizza lovers and sports enthusiasts. Situated away from the mainstream radar, this family-run establishment provides a unique mix of deep-dish and pub fare.
The atmosphere is casual and friendly, making it an ideal spot for enjoying a game with friends while savoring a hearty meal. Their deep-dish pizzas are crafted with a focus on quality and tradition, ensuring each bite is as satisfying as the last.
For those seeking a true local experience with great food and a relaxed vibe, Williams Inn delivers on all fronts.
8. George’s Deep Dish Pizza
George’s Deep Dish Pizza has garnered praise for its innovative take on the classic deep-dish. Known for its sourdough crust, this pizzeria offers a fresh twist that sets it apart from traditional counterparts. The crispy edges add a delightful contrast to the soft, flavorful interior.
Located in a vibrant neighborhood, George’s provides a trendy yet welcoming atmosphere. The modern take on deep-dish appeals to both long-time fans and newcomers looking for something different.
For those interested in exploring new flavors and textures within the deep-dish realm, George’s is a must-try destination.
9. Gino’s East
While Gino’s East may be well-known, it still holds its own as a reliable choice for authentic deep-dish pizza. Its downtown location combines authentic techniques with a lively atmosphere that appeals to both locals and visitors.
The thick, flaky crust sets the stage for a generous helping of cheese and fresh toppings, cooked to perfection in a cast iron pan. Despite its popularity, Gino’s manages to maintain its charm without falling into the typical tourist trap category.
For those navigating the bustling downtown area, Gino’s East offers a taste of tradition with genuine Chicago flair.
10. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is synonymous with Chicago’s deep-dish heritage. With ties to the origin of deep-dish pizza, it continues to uphold a legacy of quality and flavor. Each pizza is a labor of love, crafted with a buttery crust and a rich, savory sauce.
Despite being a known chain, Lou Malnati’s remains a favorite due to its historical significance and consistent excellence. The warm, family-friendly atmosphere attracts both loyal fans and curious newcomers.
For those seeking a piece of Chicago’s culinary history, Lou Malnati’s offers an experience that’s both delicious and memorable.
11. Milly’s Pizza in the Pan
Milly’s Pizza in the Pan has quickly become a local sensation since its inception in 2020. Originally a ghost kitchen, it has found a permanent home in Noble Square, captivating the hearts of deep-dish enthusiasts.
Known for its precise crust and premium toppings, Milly’s offers a modern take on the traditional style, with each pizza boasting caramelized edges that add a delightful crunch.
Whether you’re a seasoned local or a curious visitor, Milly’s presents a fresh perspective on deep-dish, making it a go-to spot for those exploring contemporary Chicago pizza.
12. My Pi Pizza
My Pi Pizza in Bucktown offers a refreshing take on the deep-dish tradition with its distinctive sourdough crust. The inclusion of fresh, robust tomato chunks elevates each slice, providing a vibrant and modern twist on a classic.
The Bucktown location is trendy yet relaxed, attracting a diverse crowd eager to explore new flavors within the deep-dish realm. My Pi’s dedication to quality ingredients and innovative techniques ensures a satisfying experience for all.
For those seeking a departure from conventional deep-dish, My Pi Pizza offers a taste that’s as dynamic as its surroundings.
13. Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Company
Situated in Lincoln Park, the Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Company offers a unique twist with their ‘Pizza Pot Pie.’ This inverted pizza baked in a bowl features a buttery crust and a delightful mix of ingredients.
The charming, unassuming setting enhances the dining experience, making it a beloved spot among locals who appreciate culinary creativity. The Pizza Pot Pie has become a standout item, drawing patrons eager to try something different.
For those in search of a dining adventure that deviates from the norm, this establishment provides a memorable and delicious journey.
14. Nella Pizza e Pasta
Nella Pizza e Pasta in Hyde Park combines traditional Italian influences with Chicago’s deep-dish style. The result is a delightful Margherita deep-dish that captures the essence of both culinary worlds.
Located in a vibrant neighborhood, Nella provides a chic yet welcoming environment that appeals to a diverse clientele. The focus on quality ingredients and artisanal techniques ensures each pizza is a masterpiece.
For those interested in exploring the fusion of Italian tradition and Chicago innovation, Nella Pizza e Pasta offers a deliciously unique opportunity.
