After Visiting 23 Tropical Islands, These 5 Still Top My List

Destinations
By Arthur Caldwell

Over the years, I’ve been lucky enough to explore 23 different tropical islands, each with its own special charm and beauty. Some were crowded with tourists, others felt untouched and wild, and a few surprised me in ways I never expected. But after all that traveling, only five islands truly stood out as unforgettable experiences that I’d return to in a heartbeat. Here are the tropical destinations that earned their spot at the very top of my list.

Bora Bora (French Polynesia)

© GoodFon

With its absolutely iconic lagoon and crystal-clear waters, Bora Bora still captivates travelers from around the world. The dramatic backdrop of Mount Otemanu adds a stunning visual element that makes every photo look like a professional postcard. According to many travel experts, the island is surrounded by a barrier reef and has become a major luxury-resort destination over the years.

What truly makes it top my list is the rare combination of natural beauty and modern comfort. You can stay in over-water bungalows, enjoy easy access to incredible snorkeling, and relax in calm, protected waters. It’s not just a postcard—it’s one you can actually live inside for a week.

The trade-off is that Bora Bora isn’t budget-friendly, and some areas feel heavily dominated by resorts. But for a dream island experience that delivers on every promise, it remains incredibly hard to beat.

La Digue (Seychelles)

Image Credit: © Pexels / Pexels

La Digue stands out because of its breathtaking beach scenery, especially the famous Anse Source d’Argent. Huge granite boulders frame turquoise water and powdery white sand in a way that many travel websites call among the world’s most beautiful. The island feels like nature designed it specifically for photographers and daydreamers.

Why does it remain on my top five? It offers something both exotic and genuinely relaxed, with far less mega-resort energy than many tropical destinations. You can rent a bike and explore the island at your own pace, discover quieter hidden coves, and still soak in that perfect “tropical paradise” feeling without the crowds.

The nuance here is that getting to La Digue may cost more time and money, and some amenities are more limited compared to bigger islands. But honestly, that’s part of the authentic appeal that keeps drawing me back.

Palawan (Philippines)

Image Credit: © Pexels / Pexels

Palawan is consistently mentioned among the world’s most beautiful islands, and once you see it in person, you’ll understand why. The mix of dramatic limestone cliffs, hidden lagoons, and world-class snorkeling and diving creates an almost surreal landscape. Every turn reveals another stunning view that feels like it belongs in a fantasy movie.

What makes Palawan special for me is how it balances remote-island magic with affordability and local culture. Unlike ultra-luxury destinations, you can experience authentic Filipino hospitality, try amazing street food, and explore diverse activities without breaking the bank. It keeps that sense of adventure alive while offering plenty of variety beyond just beach lounging.

Trade-offs do exist—some areas require effort and patience to reach, and tourist infrastructure is still growing in certain spots. But that rougher edge is exactly what makes Palawan feel more genuine and exciting than polished resort islands.

Mauritius

Image Credit: © Pexels / Pexels

Mauritius deserves a spot on this list because it blends beach luxury, vibrant marine life, and inland nature adventures in one compact package. In multiple travel roundups, it’s been cited for its multifaceted appeal that goes way beyond typical sun-and-sand vacations. The island truly offers something for everyone in your travel group.

For me, that variety means you’re never stuck doing just one thing. You can hike through waterfalls and forests in the morning, explore colorful local markets at lunch, go diving in the afternoon, and still have time to relax at a spa. The infrastructure is strong, making travel around the island smooth and stress-free.

The flip side is that Mauritius is getting busier each year, and some of the pristine, untouched feel is fading in the most popular tourist zones. Still, if you venture slightly off the beaten path, you’ll find plenty of authentic charm and natural beauty remaining.

Raja Ampat (Indonesia)

Image Credit: I Made Adi Dharmawam, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Raja Ampat makes this list because it hits the absolute high-end of remote tropical island magic. It’s home to one of the world’s richest marine ecosystems, with stunning above-water scenery and fewer crowds in many parts. A recent travel piece called it “magical” while noting it’s definitely not for the high-maintenance traveler.

Why do I love it so much? This kind of destination feels genuinely unique and deeply immersive in ways that polished resorts simply can’t match. Snorkeling and diving here reveal underwater worlds bursting with color and life. Every island seems untouched, and the sense of discovery is powerful and real.

The trade-off is significant—accessibility, cost, and comfort all require more effort and flexibility than the other four islands. It’s not the easiest or most luxurious choice on my list, but the experience is absolutely unforgettable and worth every challenge.