Unearth The Voyage
Brooklyn is renowned for its exceptional pizzerias, many of which locals prefer over Manhattan’s offerings. Here are ten standout spots that highlight the rich and diverse pizza culture Brooklyn has to offer, each providing a unique experience that many locals cherish.
1. Di Fara Pizza (Midwood)
In the heart of Midwood, Di Fara Pizza stands as a testament to decades of pizza mastery. Founded by Domenico De Marco in 1965, it quickly became a benchmark for quality. The secret? Each pizza is meticulously crafted by hand, offering a perfect blend of crust, olive oil, and sauce. The atmosphere is as rich as the flavors, with a nostalgic Italian-American charm that enchants every visitor. What to order? The classic slices, of course, which are revered for their crispy texture and flavor depth. Locals and travelers alike often find themselves returning, craving a taste of authentic craftsmanship that defies the hustle of Manhattan.
2. Lucali (Carroll Gardens)
Nestled in Carroll Gardens, Lucali offers a romantic escape with its candlelit ambiance and no-menu policy. Established by Mark Iacono, it’s a haven for pizza purists who appreciate the art of building their pie with ultra-fresh ingredients. Lines often stretch around the block, as both locals and celebrities seek a taste of this beloved spot. The atmosphere inside is intimate, almost like dining in a friend’s home, with the warmth of a brick oven at its heart. Patrons adore the thin-crust pizzas adorned with fresh basil, a simple yet irresistible combination that captures the essence of Brooklyn’s charm.
3. Juliana’s (DUMBO / Brooklyn Heights)
Opened by pizza legend Patsy Grimaldi, Juliana’s in DUMBO offers an inviting slice of Brooklyn’s rich pizza legacy. After selling the original Grimaldi’s, Patsy returned to the culinary scene, delighting fans with coal-oven fired pies that boast a purer, more authentic taste. It’s a place where simplicity reigns, and every Margherita pizza becomes a canvas for quality ingredients to shine. The location, with its iconic views of the Brooklyn Bridge, adds to the allure. Frequented by both locals and tourists, Juliana’s captures the spirit of Brooklyn, mixing tradition with a passion for perfection in every bite.
4. Roberta’s (Bushwick)
In the vibrant arts district of Bushwick, Roberta’s offers a unique twist on traditional pizza. Known for its rustic, garden-edged setting, this eatery attracts an eclectic crowd eager to try innovative pies like the “Bee Sting.” The combination of sweet and spicy flavors reflects the experimental spirit of the neighborhood. Locals flock to Roberta’s not just for the pizza, but for the experience of dining in a space that feels both edgy and homey. The wood-fired pizzas here embody authenticity, crafted with locally sourced ingredients that highlight Brooklyn’s commitment to quality and creativity in each bite.
5. L&B Spumoni Gardens (Gravesend)
Since 1939, L&B Spumoni Gardens has been a beloved institution in Gravesend, known for its unique, upside-down Sicilian-style pizza. With cheese layered beneath the sauce, each thick, doughy slice offers a texture and flavor distinct from Manhattan’s thinner varieties. The setting is as vibrant as the pizza, with outdoor tables bustling with families savoring every bite. It’s not just a place to eat but a gathering spot where generations come together. And don’t skip the spumoni for dessert – a sweet finish to a memorable dining experience that captures the heart of Brooklyn’s food culture.
6. Grimaldi’s (DUMBO / Brooklyn Heights)
Grimaldi’s in DUMBO stands as a coal-oven pioneer, offering pizzas with a charred-yet-tender crust. Its iconic skyline views are as much a draw as the smoky, old-school flavor found in every slice. The bustling atmosphere speaks to its popularity among locals seeking that signature, smoky taste that Manhattan’s offerings often lack. Whether you’re seated inside or enjoying the view outside, the aroma of fresh ingredients and dough baking is irresistible. As a timeless favorite, Grimaldi’s remains a go-to destination for those craving an authentic Brooklyn experience, where the past and present converge in delicious harmony.
7. L’Industrie Pizzeria (Williamsburg)
In Williamsburg, L’Industrie Pizzeria offers an elevated slice experience with its ultra-thin, crisp dough. Each piece speaks to a dedication to craft, featuring imported Italian ingredients and a long-fermented base. This attention to detail distinguishes it from the often more commercial slices found across the river. The setting is modern, with a focus on counter-side service where each pizza is made to order. Fans appreciate the authenticity that L’Industrie brings to Brooklyn’s pizza scene, proving that sometimes less is more when it comes to flavor. It’s a place where tradition and innovation blend seamlessly.
8. Best Pizza (Williamsburg)
Best Pizza in Williamsburg lives up to its name with a welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings. Known for its ‘Grandma Pie,’ this square slice boasts a vibrant tomato sauce, garlic, basil, and mozzarella. It’s a bold departure from the often safer Manhattan choices, offering generous toppings that thrill the palate. The rustic interior and friendly staff make each visit feel like coming home. As a beloved local favorite, Best Pizza combines the warmth of a neighborhood joint with the flavor of something truly special. Here, every slice tells a story of passion and community.
9. Paulie Gee’s (Greenpoint)
Paulie Gee’s in Greenpoint is celebrated for its innovative approach to pizza. With creative toppings and vegan options, it offers something for everyone, set in a warm, wood-fire ambiance. Locals highlight its willingness to push boundaries without losing the soulful element that defines Brooklyn pizza. The environment is cozy, almost like a hidden gem where patrons gather for good food and good company. The pizzas here are more than just meals – they’re expressions of culinary artistry. At Paulie Gee’s, the commitment to quality and creativity ensures each visit is a memorable experience.
10. Emmy Squared (Williamsburg)
Emmy Squared in Williamsburg is a must-visit for those craving something different. Known for its Detroit-style rectangular pies, it offers a thick, crispy crust that’s a refreshing contrast to Manhattan’s typical thin options. The bold combination of toppings – think hot honey, pickles, and pepperoni – adds an adventurous twist to every bite. The trendy dining space invites patrons to explore these unique flavors in a relaxed setting. It’s a place where creativity reigns, and locals love the distinct offerings that set Emmy Squared apart from the rest. Each visit is an exploration of taste.
