8 Chesapeake Bay Crab Houses That Locals Keep Secret

Culinary Destinations
By Lena Hartley

Chesapeake Bay’s rich seafood culture is synonymous with blue crabs, respected both locally and worldwide. Beyond the renowned tourist spots, hidden gems cherished by locals await with authentic flavors and unique atmospheres. Dive into these eight secret crab houses that offer a quintessential Maryland dining experience.

1. Cantler’s Riverside Inn

© cantlers.com

Cantler’s Riverside Inn, founded in 1974 by waterman Jimmy Cantler, remains a local treasure in Annapolis, MD. Nestled along the waterfront, this modest eatery boasts a no-frills atmosphere with picnic tables and dockside dining. The restaurant stays true to its roots by receiving fresh Maryland blue crabs delivered directly by boat. Locals cherish Cantler’s for its simplicity and authenticity, providing a genuine crabbing experience away from the tourist hustle. With its heartwarming vibe, it embodies the essence of Chesapeake Bay’s seafood heritage.

2. Schultz’s Crab House

© James Beard Foundation

Since 1969, Schultz’s Crab House in Essex, MD, has offered an unpretentious, welcoming atmosphere. The wood-paneled walls and nautical decor create a setting steeped in blue-collar tradition. Known for its robust seasoning and hearty portions, Schultz’s provides a dining experience rooted in authenticity rather than tourist appeal. Locals appreciate its year-round service and the consistent quality that defines Maryland’s crabbing culture, making it a cherished spot for those in the know.

3. L.P. Steamers

© The Johns Hopkins News-Letter

In Baltimore’s Locust Point neighborhood, L.P. Steamers offers a hidden oasis for crab enthusiasts. Housed in a charming rowhouse, this establishment provides stunning harbor views without the tourist crowds. The rooftop deck is a favored spot for locals who enjoy its relaxed vibe and perfectly steamed crabs. Offering crabs in all sizes, L.P. Steamers ensures a personalized dining experience. The quaint setting and commitment to quality make it a beloved retreat for Baltimore residents.

4. Tyler’s Tackle Shop & Crab House

© Nextdoor

Passing by, you might miss Tyler’s Tackle Shop & Crab House in Chesapeake Beach, MD, but step inside, and the aroma of steaming crabs greets you warmly. This unique spot combines both a tackle shop and crab house, offering an authentic experience. The staff, many former watermen, bring their expertise to every dish served. Known for its unassuming appearance and genuine atmosphere, Tyler’s stands as a testament to Maryland’s rich seafood tradition, cherished by those who value authenticity over glamour.

5. Waterman’s Crab House

© VisitMaryland.org

On Maryland’s Eastern Shore, Waterman’s Crab House in Rock Hall offers a serene escape with a deck overlooking the tranquil harbor. Locals are drawn to its peaceful setting, especially outside the tourist season. The crabs, often caught that morning, embody freshness and quality, setting Waterman’s apart from more commercial venues. The charming, boat-filled backdrop enhances the dining experience, making it a favorite for those seeking a genuine taste of the Chesapeake.

6. The Point Crab House & Grill

© The Washington Post

Tucked away in Arnold, MD, The Point Crab House & Grill offers a tranquil dining experience. Set along a creek, this hidden gem is perfect for those looking to enjoy crabs away from the bustling tourist paths. With its consistent quality and great seasoning, The Point remains a reliable choice for locals. The scenic cove views add to its charm, creating a serene atmosphere that complements the delicious seafood offerings.

7. Mike’s Crab House

© VisitMaryland.org

Established for decades, Mike’s Crab House in Riva, MD, captures the essence of a classic Maryland crab house. With its waterfront views and huge platters of steamed crabs, it has become a staple for locals. Known for its reliability, Mike’s offers a taste of genuine crabbing culture, where quality and tradition go hand in hand. A beloved spot for those who savor the authenticity of Maryland’s seafood heritage.

8. Bay Crawlers Crab Shack

© www.baycrawlersmd.com

Near the scenic Northeast River, Bay Crawlers Crab Shack in North East, MD, offers a casual, beach-themed setting with picnic tables and straightforward decor. Known for its all-you-can-eat steamed blue crabs, seasoned with a house blend, it’s a hit among locals for its earnest approach to seafood. The no-frills atmosphere captures the community spirit, making Bay Crawlers a treasured spot for a laid-back crabbing experience.