This Michigan Market Has Homemade Sandwiches That Are Absolutely Unforgettable

Food & Drink Travel
By Lena Hartley

Walk through the doors of Kingma’s Market on Plainfield Avenue in Grand Rapids, and the first thing you notice is the smell: warm bread, sliced dill pickles, and smoked turkey drifting from the deli. The sandwich board is busy, the slicer hums, and a line of regulars trades tips like stock pickers.

At Kingma’s Market, pretzel buns sit stacked beside loaves from local bakers, and you’ll hear someone ask for “extra giardiniera, please” like it’s a password. If you think you know deli sandwiches, wait until you watch one built here, layer by precise layer.

The Lunch Rush That Teaches Patience

© Kingma’s Market

Stand by the deli at 12:15 and you will feel the room tighten. The slicer ticks in brisk strokes while someone scoops potato salad into a compostable cup, tapping twice to level it.

A bell chimes for a pickup order and a staffer calls a name that half the line recognizes with a laugh.

Watch the choreography. Paper crinkles, knives flash, mustard swirls in a thin figure eight.

You smell dill, then smoked turkey, then the sharp breath of red onion. It is not fancy theater, just repetition turned into grace, like a drummer warming up before the set.

Minutes stretch. Nobody complains because every sandwich leaving the counter looks engineered: corners aligned, cheese melted only where requested, greens still perky.

When your number is called, you step forward and the world narrows to a board, a bun, and a person who remembers whether you like a pickle spear or coins.

Pretzel Bun Architecture

© Kingma’s Market

The pretzel bun has a gloss like a lacquered instrument. Your thumbs press into the crust and it gives with a soft sigh, showing a tight crumb that holds its line when the warm turkey lands.

Salt crystals wink on top, a small warning that the first bite will lean savory.

They split it neatly and swipe a light line of mayo, then a thinner stripe of mustard. The bottom bun gets the heavy build: turkey, Swiss, lettuce cut fine as Easter grass, tomato with its seeds dabbed, rings of red onion.

The weight is intentional so juices travel down and not out.

Halfway through, you notice the bun has not collapsed. It keeps chew and shape, resisting sog without posturing.

That small engineering choice means you taste each layer instead of slurry. You finish, lick a salt crystal from your lip, and realize you never needed a napkin until the end.

Turkey, Havarti, Heat

© Kingma’s Market

Ask for turkey with Havarti and they will raise an eyebrow: dill or plain. Pick dill and the cheese softens like a blanket, slipping around the edges once warmed.

A thin swipe of giardiniera mayo carries heat that shows up late, right when the turkey’s smoke begins to fade.

They add cucumbers shaved translucently, plus a handful of arugula that snaps like a twig when bitten. Bread choice matters.

On toasted multigrain, seeds crackle against the creamy cheese. On pretzel, the dill leans greener, almost grassy, brightened by the giardiniera’s vinegar hum.

You eat it standing, elbow crooked over the cart. The heat is polite, more nudge than shove, and it keeps you returning for another measured bite.

The last mouthful tastes of pepper and garden, a quick little chase scene that ends right when you want it to. Simple, balanced, repeatable.

The Reuben You Hear Before You Taste

© Kingma’s Market

The Reuben arrives with sound first. Buttered rye hisses on the press, a little singe at the edges sending out a toast smell that calls people from produce.

Corned beef goes down in ribbons, not slabs, so the steam can lace through and soften the curl.

Sauerkraut gets squeezed, not dumped, until it is damp rather than dripping. Swiss rounds it out, corners peeking like paper tabs.

When the press lifts, the bread shows freckles of char and the spread glows faintly coral at the seam.

The crosscut reveals strata that hold together even when you tilt it. Bite, and the kraut lifts the beef, then recedes, leaving caraway seeds pinging against your teeth.

It is tidy, a rare Reuben you can finish without a laundry plan. You will think about ordering two.

One is enough, but the thought lingers.

Pickle Logic At The Counter

© Kingma’s Market

Pickles here are not garnish, they are strategy. Whole spears ride shotgun with hefty builds, coin slices tuck inside where they can spark without flooding the bread.

Ask for extra and the deli person will decide which format makes sense for the sandwich you named.

Garlic dill dominates, but there is a brighter, almost lemony brine in the sliced coins that keeps mayo honest. A sweet chip sits off to the side, used sparingly, like a cymbal crash for cured meats.

The texture is decisive: snap first, then slide.

Listen to the tongs click against the pan. That sound repeats every minute, a metronome for the line.

You will carry the spear like a baton back to your cart, bite between items, and realize the pickle controlled the pacing of your lunch. It told you when to pause and when to proceed.

Catering That Moves Crowds

© Kingma’s Market

On pickup day, the counter stacks with kraft boxes marked in confident black marker: 25 whole sandwiches, 50 pretzel sliders. The staff runs through the order like pilots before takeoff, touching each label, confirming sauces on the side, counting spears.

You leave with the backseat perfumed like a bakery.

At the party, the sliders vanish first. Guests admire the buns like little lacquered helmets and then stop talking mid-sentence to chew.

Whole sandwiches get halved and stand on edge, fillings visible so people can choose by sight rather than label.

Leftovers are rare. When they happen, they keep their dignity in the fridge, bread still holding tomorrow.

That is the part you remember later. Not just volume, but reliability, the kind that makes hosts look calm.

It is logistics as hospitality, and it tastes like planning well executed.

Local Bread, Local Story

© Kingma’s Market

Bread tags tell a West Michigan map if you bother to read them. Multigrain from one bakery, sourdough from another, pretzel rolls from a third that specializes in short, tight fermentations.

Crusts vary: crackle thin, sturdy chew, or that pretzel flash of sheen.

A staffer explains which loaf hugs tuna salad without turning soggy and which rye likes heat under a Reuben. That guidance saves lunch.

You pick a sourdough with blistered freckles for tomorrow and a soft white pullman for the kids at home.

Later, you notice the small thing: the crumb matches the build. Egg salad sits proud, does not drown.

Smoked ham sings louder on a softer stage. Local bread is not a badge here, it is a tool.

It changes the bite, the sound, the way the sandwich collapses or resists.

Cheese Case Decisions

© Kingma’s Market

The cheese case glows like a library. Labels whisper origin and fat percentage, but the real answer arrives on a paper square placed in your palm.

A young Gouda leans milky and mild, good for kids. An aged one snaps like toffee at the edge and can boss pastrami without shouting.

Swiss bends; Havarti drapes; cheddar stands its ground. Samples teach you texture before you commit.

For the turkey sandwich, you choose dill Havarti again because it slides into every gap. For roast beef, a sharper Swiss gives lift without stealing the conversation.

Back at the counter, the slicer thread-counts the cheese into thin, obedient sheets. Stacked just so, they melt at room temperature, not a microwave in sight.

You taste dairy, pasture, time, then the sandwich snaps shut and all that thought becomes simple pleasure in hand-held form.

The Coffee Doorway: Sparrows Attached

© Kingma’s Market

There is a doorway near the front that pours espresso air into the aisles. Sparrows hums on the other side, a barista knocking a portafilter while a shopper debates pastrami or ham.

You grab a cappuccino and the foam steadies your hand before you order at the deli.

Coffee changes the sandwich clock. Hot sip, cold case, hot press, warm bread.

It is a rhythm you feel while drifting from cheese to meat to pickles. A couple near the wine section clinks sample cups and decides on a bottle for dinner.

On a gray Grand Rapids morning, that passage between market and cafe might be the city’s best mood lift. You carry the cup like a talisman, leave with a sandwich, and the day obeys.

Small convenience, big effect. The store knows this and built the doorway on purpose.

Why The Line Moves

© Kingma’s Market

Efficiency here is visible. Greens live in chilled bins fluffed with a fork so they do not mat.

Tomatoes get seeded before the rush. Knives live sharp, and the ticket numbers climb with an even tick that keeps nerves low.

One staffer handles hot press only, committed to flips and timing. Another manages condiments, wrists quick enough to paint mayo edge to edge without overloading the corners.

The builder at center assembles with straight wrists, elbows tucked, moving like a practiced line cook.

This is why the food tastes calm. It is not just ingredients, it is system.

You can feel the operating hours in their hands, eight to eight most days, the repetition settling into muscle. The line moves because each motion earns its keep, and the sandwiches taste like the sum of small, correct choices.