Michigan’s Best Pot Pies – Ranked by Locals Who Know Best

Food & Drink Travel
By Lena Hartley

Michigan is home to some of the most delicious pot pies, cherished by locals and visitors alike. Each establishment has its unique spin on this classic comfort food, offering a variety of flavors and styles. From traditional chicken pot pies to creative vegan options, the pot pie scene in Michigan is as diverse as it is delicious.

1. Grand Traverse Pie Company

© Grand Traverse Pie Company

Grand Traverse Pie Company is a staple in Michigan, renowned for its delectable pot pies. Known for their flaky crusts and hearty fillings, these pies are a comforting delight. Each bite offers a perfect blend of flavors, whether you choose chicken or beef.

Locals suggest visiting during lunchtime when fresh pot pies emerge from the oven, maximizing the crust’s texture and taste. The bakery-café ambiance adds a touch of warmth, making it an inviting spot for pie lovers.

Whether you’re in Ann Arbor or another Michigan location, this spot ensures a satisfying pot pie experience. It’s not just a meal; it’s a slice of local culinary tradition.

2. Great Lakes Pot Pies

© Woodward Corner Market

Great Lakes Pot Pies in Clawson is a treasure trove for pot pie enthusiasts. Specializing entirely in this comfort food, they offer everything from classic chicken to innovative vegan options. Each pie is handmade and locally sourced, ensuring freshness and quality.

The shop’s dedication to inclusivity stands out, with gluten-free varieties available, ensuring everyone can enjoy these culinary creations. The artisan touch is evident in every bite, making it a beloved choice among locals.

If you’re near Metro Detroit, this spot is a must-visit for hearty, home-style pot pies. It’s a testament to Michigan’s rich tradition in comfort food craftsmanship.

3. Achatz Handmade Pie Company

© Goldbelly

Achatz Handmade Pie Company, while famous for its desserts, also delivers exceptional savory pot pies. Their offerings include chicken, beef, and special seasonal varieties that rotate throughout the year.

Locals appreciate the quality and creativity infused into each pie, making it a standout choice. The cozy bakery setting in Armada offers a warm atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a delicious pot pie.

Asking about the seasonal specials adds an element of surprise to your visit, making each trip memorable. It’s a delightful spot for pie lovers seeking both sweet and savory indulgence.

4. Good Hart General Store

© UpNorthLive

In Good Hart, the General Store is a beloved landmark, offering “world-famous” pot pies that have delighted visitors since 1986. These pies are a staple of the local culinary scene, drawing people from near and far.

The store’s rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect stop for those exploring Northern Michigan. Their commitment to quality and tradition ensures each pie is a memorable experience.

For those who can’t visit in person, the store offers frozen pies for shipping, making it a delightful gift or a comforting meal to enjoy at home. It’s a taste of Michigan’s heartland.

5. CRUST Bakery & Cafe

© CRUST

CRUST Bakery & Cafe in Fenton offers a vibrant culinary experience, celebrated for its exceptional pot pies. Their savory offerings are a testament to the bakery’s commitment to quality and flavor.

The bustling atmosphere and friendly staff enhance the experience, inviting you to explore their wide array of baked goods. Each pot pie boasts a flaky crust and rich filling, making it a crowd favorite.

Asking for the savory pot pie counter selections ensures a satisfying meal, bridging the gap between traditional comfort food and artisanal baking. It’s a delicious journey for your taste buds.

6. Zingerman’s Bakehouse

© MLive.com

Zingerman’s Bakehouse, an Ann Arbor institution, is renowned for its bakery excellence, including savory pot pies. Their dedication to quality ingredients and innovative baking techniques sets them apart.

Weekends at Zingerman’s are busy, with locals and visitors lining up for their renowned comfort food dishes. The lively atmosphere and welcoming staff contribute to an unforgettable experience.

Arriving early ensures you get a taste of their delectable pot pies before they sell out. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that captures the heart of Ann Arbor’s culinary scene.

7. Marie Callender’s

© Brand Eating

Marie Callender’s, while a national chain, holds a special place in Michigan’s pot pie discussions. Known for their consistent quality, these pies offer a reliable and delicious option.

For those seeking familiarity, Marie Callender’s provides a comforting choice, with flavors that satisfy and a crust that delights. It’s a go-to for many who enjoy a known quantity without surprises.

Though not purely local, the brand’s presence in Michigan contributes to the state’s diverse pot pie narrative, offering a balance between tradition and accessibility.

8. Crane’s Pie Pantry Restaurant & Winery

© Saugatuck Douglas

Crane’s Pie Pantry Restaurant & Winery, located near the Lake Michigan shore, is a must-visit for pie enthusiasts. Known primarily for sweet fruit pies, their savory pot pies have earned a strong following.

The combination of pie and fresh farm cider is a highlight, especially during orchard season. Visitors are treated to a unique dining experience, blending culinary tradition with fresh, local ingredients.

The picturesque setting, part of Michigan’s rich agricultural landscape, adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for a relaxing meal. It’s a delightful convergence of flavors and ambiance.