Unearth The Voyage
Few sandwiches say “New York” quite like the Reuben. Layers of corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and tangy Russian dressing piled between slices of grilled rye – it’s a masterpiece of comfort food that’s both messy and magnificent. Whether you crave the classic deli version or a creative twist, here are the best spots in NYC serving unforgettable Reuben sandwiches, from iconic institutions to modern gems.
1. Katz’s Delicatessen – Lower East Side Legend
Katz’s Delicatessen, an icon since 1888, is the epitome of New York deli greatness. The Reuben here is a colossal masterpiece, featuring thick-cut corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing, all perfectly nestled between slices of grilled rye.
This legendary spot is worth the wait, with its bustling atmosphere and rich history adding to the experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Katz’s serves up nostalgia and flavor in every bite.
Pair your sandwich with a half-sour pickle and a Dr. Brown’s Cel-Ray soda to capture the full, timeless experience. It’s not just a meal; it’s a taste of New York history.
2. 2nd Ave Deli – Kosher Classic with History
Established in the 1950s, 2nd Ave Deli is a cornerstone of Jewish deli culture in New York. Known for its kosher-style offerings, their Reuben boasts generously stacked pastrami or corned beef, perfectly balanced with tangy sauerkraut and creamy Swiss cheese.
The deli’s historical roots and commitment to tradition are evident in every bite, making it a must-visit for purists and newcomers alike.
Pair your Reuben with a bowl of their famous matzo ball soup for a truly comforting meal. This beloved institution continues to delight with its authentic flavors and welcoming ambiance.
3. Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner – Old-School Charm, 24/7 Flavor
Open since 1964, Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner is a beloved 24-hour staple in Midtown East. Their Reuben is known for its towering size, juicy corned beef, and extra-salty punch, making it a perfect choice for late-night cravings.
The friendly, diner-like atmosphere offers a slice of old-school New York charm. With huge portions that satisfy even the heartiest appetites, Sarge’s has a loyal fan base that spans generations.
Whether you’re there at noon or midnight, the Reuben promises a satisfying experience with every savory bite. It’s a true New York classic.
4. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop – Retro Revival on Fifth Avenue
Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop, a nostalgic lunch counter since 1929, offers a textbook-perfect Reuben. With melty Swiss cheese and golden-brown crust, their sandwich is a delightful journey into the past.
Recently reopened under new ownership, Eisenberg’s maintains its vintage charm and sizzling griddle magic. Sitting at the counter, you can watch your Reuben being crafted to perfection.
With its retro vibe and dedication to tradition, Eisenberg’s provides a comforting escape from the hustle and bustle of Fifth Avenue. It’s a taste of history in every delicious bite.
5. Liebman’s Kosher Deli – The Bronx Treasure
Liebman’s Kosher Deli, a family-owned gem since 1953, is one of the last remaining old-school kosher delis in the Bronx. Their Reuben rivals Manhattan’s finest, featuring tender corned beef and tangy sauerkraut.
Nestled in a cozy corner of the Bronx, Liebman’s exudes nostalgia and warmth. It’s a place where tradition thrives, and every bite tells a story.
This beloved institution offers a hearty, satisfying meal that captures the essence of a true New York deli. Whether you’re a local or exploring the borough, Liebman’s remains a delightful discovery.
6. Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery – A Brooklyn Icon
Known for its world-famous cheesecake, Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery in Brooklyn surprises with a Reuben deserving of equal fame. Served on marble rye, the thick-cut corned beef is both hearty and approachable.
Junior’s offers a slice of New York authenticity with each sandwich, balancing tradition and innovation. The bustling atmosphere reflects its status as a beloved Brooklyn institution.
Don’t forget to leave room for dessert; Junior’s renowned cheesecake is the perfect ending to a classic New York meal.
7. PJ Bernstein – Upper East Side Favorite
PJ Bernstein, an Upper East Side neighborhood deli, is cherished for its perfectly balanced Reuben. Not too greasy or heavy, their sandwich features house-made Russian dressing with a slightly sweet twist.
Locals adore PJ Bernstein for its consistent quality and comforting atmosphere. It’s the perfect spot for a satisfying lunch after a leisurely Central Park stroll.
With its inviting vibe and expertly crafted sandwiches, PJ Bernstein offers a taste of home in the heart of New York City.
8. Harry & Ida’s Meat and Supply Co. – Creative, Smoky Twist
Transforming the traditional, Harry & Ida’s Meat and Supply Co. in the East Village offers a Reuben with a creative, smoky twist. Their sandwich features smoky pastrami, fresh pickles, and a proprietary “Deli Sauce.”
This hip, small deli embraces artisanal flavors and inventive combinations, setting it apart from conventional delis. Each bite provides a unique, flavorful experience.
With its vibrant, inventive approach, Harry & Ida’s redefines what a Reuben can be, making it a must-try for food adventurers.
9. Frankel’s Delicatessen – Brooklyn’s Modern Take on Tradition
Frankel’s Delicatessen in Greenpoint, Brooklyn channels classic deli energy with a modern twist. Their pastrami Reuben balances tender meat with just the right melt of Swiss cheese on rye.
This trendy spot attracts both locals and visitors with its fresh take on traditional flavors. The lively atmosphere and dedicated craftsmanship make each sandwich memorable.
Arrive early, as Frankel’s sandwiches are known to sell out by mid-afternoon. It’s a delicious tribute to classic Reuben flavors with a Brooklyn flair.
10. Lenny’s Clam Bar & Restaurant – The Unexpected Contender
Known primarily for seafood, Lenny’s Clam Bar in Howard Beach surprises with a standout Reuben sandwich. This Italian-American spot defies expectations, proving the Reuben’s universal appeal.
Locals rave about the unexpected delight of their Reuben, with its crispy, extra-toasted rye bread and flavorful filling. It’s a hidden gem in an unlikely setting.
Order it “extra toasted” for added crunch, and discover why Lenny’s Reuben has become a local favorite. It’s an unexpected treasure in Queens’ rich culinary landscape.
