15 Must-Try New York City Restaurants Loved by TripAdvisor Travelers in 2025

Food & Drink Travel
By Amelia Brooks

Explore the culinary delights of New York City with these 15 must-try restaurants, highly praised by TripAdvisor travelers in 2025. From fine dining to casual bites, each venue offers something unique and memorable. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, these spots promise unforgettable dining experiences.

1. Daniel (Upper East Side) – Fine Dining

© New York Magazine

Renowned for its exquisite French haute cuisine, Daniel offers an unparalleled dining experience. With white-glove service and an extensive wine cellar, it’s no wonder it topped the U.S. Fine Dining list.

A visit to this Upper East Side gem is like stepping into a world of elegance and refinement. Patrons often rave about the meticulous attention to detail.

As you savor each course, the ambiance envelops you in a luxurious embrace, making every dinner an event to remember.

2. Gramercy Tavern (Flatiron) – Fine Dining

© Eater NY

In the heart of Flatiron lies Gramercy Tavern, celebrated for its seasonal American menu and welcoming atmosphere. Recognized in the 2025 Best of the Best U.S. Fine Dining, it’s a favorite among locals and travelers alike.

The blend of rustic decor and modern culinary artistry creates an inviting space. Each dish tells a story of the season’s best offerings.

Known for its hospitable staff, Gramercy Tavern ensures every guest leaves with a smile and a satisfied palate.

3. Club A Steakhouse (Midtown East) – Fine Dining (U.S.)

© OpenTable

If you’re longing for an old-school steakhouse charm, Club A Steakhouse is the place to be. Family-run and full of character, it made the 2025 U.S. Fine Dining list.

Located in Midtown East, this restaurant is known for its hearty steaks and warm service. The ambiance is both inviting and nostalgic, perfect for meat lovers.

The attention to tradition is evident in every bite, making it a beloved spot for both regulars and newcomers.

4. The River Café (DUMBO, Brooklyn) – Fine Dining (U.S.)

© MICHELIN Guide

Nestled in DUMBO, Brooklyn, The River Café offers stunning views of the Manhattan skyline. Its celebratory tasting menus earned it a spot on the 2025 U.S. Fine Dining list.

The setting is nothing short of magical, with a romantic vibe perfect for special occasions. Each dish is crafted with precision and flair.

Whether you’re there for a celebration or a quiet evening, the experience is sure to be unforgettable, blending culinary excellence with breathtaking visuals.

5. Manhatta (Financial District) – Fine Dining (U.S.)

© Restaurant Hospitality

High above the bustling streets, Manhatta offers a dining experience like no other on the 60th floor. It’s not just the views that captivate; the award-winning wine list and expertly prepared dishes place it on the 2025 U.S. Fine Dining list.

Operated by Union Square Hospitality Group, the restaurant combines luxury with a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Every meal at Manhatta feels like a special occasion, where cityscapes and culinary artistry converge.

6. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio (SoHo) – Casual Dining & Hidden Gem

© OpenTable

Tucked away in SoHo, Piccola Cucina Estiatorio delights with its Sicilian seafood and pasta offerings. Voted a Hidden Gem in 2025, it’s a favorite for those seeking authenticity.

The atmosphere is intimate and warm, making you feel like family from the moment you walk in. Each dish reflects the heart of Sicily.

From fresh seafood to handcrafted pastas, the menu is a celebration of flavors and tradition that keeps patrons coming back.

7. Dos Caminos (Times Square) – Casual Dining (U.S.)

© The Business Journals

At the heart of Times Square, Dos Caminos buzzes with energy, offering a taste of Mexico with a twist. Known for its lively mezcal and margarita bar, it made the 2025 U.S. Casual Dining list.

The vibrant atmosphere complements dishes that are both flavorful and fun. It’s a place where friends gather to enjoy good food and better company.

Whether it’s for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Dos Caminos delivers excitement and satisfaction.

8. Petite Boucherie (West Village) – Casual Dining & Hidden Gem

© petite-boucherie.menu-world.com

Step into the charm of Paris in the West Village at Petite Boucherie. This bistro, listed as a Hidden Gem in 2025, brings a slice of France to NYC.

The intimate setting is perfect for a romantic dinner or casual brunch. With authentic French dishes, it’s a delight for any Francophile.

Known for its cozy atmosphere and exquisite cuisine, Petite Boucherie makes every meal feel like a getaway to Paris.

9. Patsy’s Italian Restaurant (Midtown) – Casual Dining (U.S.)

© Patsys Italian Restaurant

A Midtown staple, Patsy’s Italian Restaurant is beloved for its classic red-sauce dishes. Included on the 2025 U.S. Casual Dining list, it’s a slice of nostalgia.

The ambiance is both welcoming and familiar, with generations having dined at its tables. Each dish is a testament to authentic Italian comfort.

Whether it’s a family dinner or a nostalgic night out, Patsy’s offers a warm embrace of tradition and taste.

10. P.S. Kitchen (Times Square) – Vegan/Vegetarian (World)

© Tripadvisor

P.S. Kitchen is more than just a restaurant; it’s a mission-driven experience offering plant-based comfort food. Recognized on the 2025 global Vegan & Vegetarian list, it stands out in Times Square.

With a commitment to social impact, each meal supports positive change. The menu is as thoughtful as it is delicious.

From flavorful dishes to a welcoming space, P.S. Kitchen is where conscious dining meets culinary delight.

11. Eleven Madison Park (Flatiron) – Vegan/Vegetarian (World)

© Postcard

Elevating vegan cuisine to new heights, Eleven Madison Park offers a luxury tasting menu experience. Featured on the 2025 global Vegan & Vegetarian list, it redefines fine dining.

The sophisticated setting is matched by innovative dishes that surprise and delight. It’s a feast for both the eyes and palate.

Known worldwide for its excellence, it’s a must-visit for those seeking a unique, plant-based culinary journey.

12. Bleecker Street Pizza (West Village) – Quick Bites (U.S.)

© Lyssy in the City

For the quintessential NYC slice, Bleecker Street Pizza is unmatched. Ranked #1 on the 2025 U.S. Quick Bites list, it’s a staple in the West Village.

Known for its foldable slices, particularly the fan-favorite Nona Maria, it’s a haven for pizza lovers.

The casual, no-frills atmosphere lets the food speak for itself. It’s the perfect spot for a quick, delicious bite.

13. Joe’s Pizza (Multiple NYC locations) – Quick Bites (U.S.)

© sabihadivan

Joe’s Pizza remains the go-to spot for an authentic NYC slice. Featured on the 2025 U.S. Quick Bites list, its multiple locations keep New Yorkers satisfied.

Each location maintains the same quality and beloved flavor that patrons cherish. It’s a no-nonsense approach to pizza.

From tourists to locals, Joe’s is a universally loved slice of New York life.

14. NY Pizza Suprema (Penn Station/MSG) – Quick Bites (U.S.)

© Tripadvisor

At NY Pizza Suprema, the pizza is crafted with precision and passion. Its spot on the 2025 U.S. Quick Bites list is well-earned.

Located near Penn Station, it’s a convenient and satisfying stop for travelers and locals alike.

The old-school vibe and dedication to quality make every visit a delightful slice of NYC.

15. Shake Shack – Theater District (8th Ave) – Quick Bites (U.S.)

© The Infatuation

In the heart of the Theater District, Shake Shack serves up classic American fare. Ranked on the 2025 U.S. Quick Bites list, it’s an essential stop before or after a show.

Known for its burgers, crinkle-cut fries, and shakes, it’s a crowd-pleaser with a cult following.

The energetic vibe and consistent quality make it a beloved spot for both locals and tourists.