Unearth The Voyage
Craving that cool peppermint snap with your holiday sweets This list is your sleigh ride to Ohio’s most festive treats, from candy cane ice creams to show stopping cakes. You will find cozy bakeries, classic creameries, and a few delightful surprises worth the drive. Bring your stretchy pants and a sweet tooth, because peppermint season only comes once a year.
1. Pistacia Vera – Columbus
Pistacia Vera makes peppermint feel refined, not loud. Hunt for limited peppermint macarons and chocolate mint entremets with mirror shine, perfect for sharing or hoarding. The textures are delicate, the flavors precise, and you will leave plotting your next visit.
Ask what is seasonal because specials rotate quickly. Pair a peppermint treat with a cappuccino and linger by the window for cheerful Clintonville energy. If you are gifting, grab a box that looks boutique ready without extra wrapping.
2. Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream – Cleveland & NE Ohio
Mitchell’s nails holiday joy with bright peppermint stick ice cream, studded with crunchy candy shards. The flavor is creamy, refreshing, and wildly nostalgic. You can scoop it into a warm waffle cone or bring home a pint for movie night.
Ask about sundaes with hot fudge and crushed candy canes for extra sparkle. Northeast Ohio locations make it easy to swing by after lights displays. If you love seasonal flavors, grab a couple pints before they vanish.
3. Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams – Columbus
Jeni’s brings creative spins to peppermint with ultra smooth textures and punchy mint. Expect inspired pairings, like dark chocolate flecks or white chocolate ribbons, that make each spoonful feel grown up yet playful. Lines move fast, so do not be intimidated.
Grab a flight to compare seasonal scoops before committing to a pint. Staff are happy to recommend pairings for take home sundaes. If you are shipping gifts, their pints pack beautifully and arrive party ready.
4. Mozart’s Bakery – Columbus (Clintonville)
Mozart’s leans European with refined peppermint cakes, layered tortes, and delicate cookies. You will taste balance instead of overpowering mint, often paired with rich chocolate or airy creams. It is an ideal stop before a holiday concert or neighborhood stroll.
Ask about special orders for peppermint roulades and petit fours. A box of assorted treats turns any gathering into a Viennese inspired moment. Warm drinks, live music nights, and friendly staff complete the seasonal magic.
5. Wyoming Pastry Shop – Cincinnati (Wyoming)
This neighborhood gem makes peppermint approachable and generous. Think candy cane topped cupcakes, iced cookies, and chocolate mint bars that travel well. It is the kind of place where staff remember regulars and boxes are tied with string.
Call ahead for holiday preorder because weekends get busy. If you are road tripping, grab a peppermint assortment and hot cocoa for the drive. Prices are fair, portions are friendly, and everything tastes home baked.
6. Aglamesis Bro’s Ice Cream & Chocolates – Cincinnati
Step into Aglamesis for old school charm and peppermint delights that feel timeless. Peppermint stick ice cream is creamy and crisp, and the handmade peppermint bark is dangerously snackable. The marble counters and pastel decor set a festive mood instantly.
Build a gift box with bark, mints, and chocolates for easy hostess presents. Friendly staff happily suggest pairings and pack everything beautifully. Swing by after skating downtown, then warm up with a sundae.
7. Sugar Me Desserterie – Chagrin Falls
Sugar Me Desserterie specializes in polished, photogenic treats that still taste homemade. Expect peppermint cheesecake bars, festive cupcakes, and buttercream swirls with crushed candy canes. The shop is perfect for picking up a centerpiece dessert without stress.
Order ahead for parties because popular items sell quickly. Staff can customize decorations to match your table. Pair a peppermint item with something citrusy for a balanced dessert spread your guests will devour.
8. The Fat Apple Bakery – Bridgeport
The Fat Apple leans comfort first, with peppermint brownies and hefty cookies that travel well. Flavors are bold, chocolatey, and cheerfully minty, exactly what you want after caroling or a chilly walk. Portions are generous, so plan to share or freeze.
Call ahead for availability on holiday weekends. If you love variety, mix peppermint with peanut butter or snickerdoodle for a sampler box. Friendly service and fair prices make it an easy detour.
9. Kauffman’s Country Bakery – Millersburg
Out in Amish country, Kauffman’s offers peppermint whoopie pies, cookies, and seasonal breads worth the drive. The flavors feel nostalgic, like holiday bake sale favorites done right. You can wander the market, sip coffee, and load up on gifts.
Go early on Saturdays to beat the crowds. Peppermint treats sell quickly, especially anything chocolate dipped. Bring cash for faster checkout and do not skip the classic pies while you are there.
10. Ideal Bakery – Gibsonburg
Ideal Bakery delivers small town sweetness with peppermint frosted donuts and cheerful cookies. Everything tastes fresh, simple, and satisfying, like the holidays you remember. It is the perfect stop on your way to visit family or see lights.
Preorder if you need dozens for an office party. Pair a peppermint donut with hot coffee and you are set for the drive. Staff are kind, prices are reasonable, and the case empties fast.
11. Biagio’s Donut Shop & Pizzeria – Eastlake
Biagio’s surprises with peppermint glazed donuts that hit the sweet spot between soft and snappy. Candy cane sprinkles add crunch, perfect for dunking in cocoa. The combo donut shop and pizzeria setup means there is always something fun to try.
Go early for the freshest batches. If you are hosting, a mixed dozen with peppermint accents disappears fast. Friendly counter service keeps the line moving, even on busy weekends.
12. Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream – Youngstown & statewide locations
Handel’s keeps tradition alive with peppermint stick ice cream that tastes like childhood. The base is creamy, the peppermint is bright, and the candy bits crunch beautifully. It is a must after driving through neighborhood light displays.
Check rotating seasonal menus because some shops add peppermint sundaes. Grab quarts for family gatherings and stash one for January blues. Lines can be long, but they move quickly and it is worth it.
13. Remixx Ice Cream + Cereal Bar – Cleveland
Remixx lets you build your dream peppermint mashup with cereal crunch, brownies, and candy cane bits. The base is creamy and customizable, so you control mint intensity and texture. It is festive, playful, and totally Instagram worthy without sacrificing flavor.
Ask staff for their favorite peppermint combos to avoid decision fatigue. Chocolate drizzle and whipped cream never hurt. Late hours make it a perfect after dinner stop with friends.
