Unearth The Voyage
Ohio is home to numerous sandwich shops that have thrived without the need for flashy ads or promotions. These beloved establishments are cherished by locals for their delicious offerings and unique charm. We’ve compiled a list of 12 such sandwich shops that have garnered loyal followings through word of mouth and exceptional flavor.
1. Express Deli, Brook Park
Express Deli in Brook Park is a family-run gem that has built its reputation entirely by word of mouth. Known especially for its Reuben wrap and the famous “New Yorker Pita,” this deli doesn’t need flashy signage to attract customers. It offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere where quality meats and generous portions take center stage. People from all over Ohio make the drive just to savor their delicious sandwiches. Whether it’s the pastrami, corned beef, or the classic Reuben, each option is crafted with care, ensuring a memorable culinary experience. Express Deli’s consistent quality and unique flavors make it a must-visit spot for sandwich lovers.
2. The Brown Bag Delicatessen, German Village
Nestled in Columbus’s historic German Village, The Brown Bag Delicatessen is a beloved neighborhood staple. This modest storefront captivates with its cozy and unpretentious ambiance, offering a delightful escape from the everyday hustle. Their Cuban sandwich, a crowd favorite, stands out with its fresh ingredients and perfectly balanced flavors. Patrons appreciate the dedication to quality, from fresh meats to good bread, making each bite a taste revelation. The Brown Bag’s commitment to authentic deli classics, without reliance on advertising, keeps locals coming back for more. It’s a place where genuine flavors and community spirit thrive together.
3. Wario’s Beef & Pork, Columbus
What started as a humble walk-up window in Columbus, Wario’s Beef & Pork now enjoys a devoted following. The shop has carved its niche with high-quality cold cuts and the famous “The Cheesesteak – Wario’s Way,” which has residents raving. The secret lies in the taste and reputation, not in heavy advertising. Wario’s offers a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere where each sandwich is a testament to culinary excellence. From steak & cheese to other classic offerings, every creation is a flavor-packed masterpiece. Locals know that Wario’s is where quality and passion come together to create unforgettable sandwiches.
4. Katzinger’s Delicatessen, Columbus
Since 1984, Katzinger’s Delicatessen has been a beacon of quality in Columbus without relying on hype. Known for towering Reubens and a New York-style deli counter, this place offers more than just a meal. It’s an experience, complete with a “help yourself” pickle barrel that invites lingering. Fresh sliced meats, vegetarian options, and creative sandwiches fill the menu with delightful choices. The nostalgic setting adds to its charm, making it a favorite among locals and tourists alike. A visit to Katzinger’s is a step back in time, where word-of-mouth recommendations have built its revered status.
5. End of the Commons General Store, Mesopotamia
Ohio’s oldest operating general store, End of the Commons, is a historic treasure nestled in Amish Country. Built in 1840, this store isn’t just about nostalgia; it houses a deli/café serving hearty sandwiches with Amish meats and cheeses. The charm of its diary-fresh ingredients and authentic fare attracts daily visitors. Travelers and locals alike are drawn to its friendly atmosphere and rustic appeal, finding it a delightful retreat without the need for mass advertising. The store’s unique blend of history and flavor makes it a beloved destination for those seeking a taste of tradition.
6. Susie’s, Columbus
Susie’s in Columbus is synonymous with legendary Italian subs that draw fans from far and wide. Tucked away in a modest storefront, this shop doesn’t rely on flashy advertising; its reputation speaks volumes. The subs are crafted with fresh ingredients, precise layering, and perfect bread, creating a symphony of flavors. Each bite is an ode to quality, keeping patrons returning for more. Susie’s straightforward menu and dedication to excellence make it a favorite among locals. It’s a place where sandwiches feel like home, capturing hearts with every satisfying bite.
7. Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe, Greenville
Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe in Greenville is a modest establishment with a rich history. Since the 1930s, it has been serving its iconic loose meat sandwich, a simple yet magical combination of meat and soft bun. People often travel just to experience this culinary classic, which has maintained its charm without grand marketing efforts. Maid-Rite’s unassuming exterior belies the deliciousness within. Regulars appreciate the tradition and consistency, finding comfort in each bite. This shop stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of quality and simplicity, drawing loyal patrons who appreciate its authentic offerings.
8. J&W Sandwich Shoppe, Norwood
Cruising through Norwood, you might spot J&W Sandwich Shoppe, a blue-fronted haven for sandwich enthusiasts. Known for its classic clubs, BLTs, and Italian subs, this spot delivers sandwiches with care and consistency. The friendly service and solid ingredients create a welcoming environment that keeps patrons returning. J&W doesn’t depend on hype; its charm lies in simplicity and authenticity. Locals know that here, every bite delivers satisfaction. The shop’s reputation is built on word-of-mouth, making it a beloved destination for those seeking genuine, no-frills sandwiches.
9. Newfangled Kitchen, Bexley
Newfangled Kitchen in Bexley is a quaint café with a specialty in thick-cut meatloaf sandwiches. The creative options, like the ‘Joe Cool,’ pair flavors like portabellos and Swiss in delightful combinations. With a focus on quality and innovation, Newfangled Kitchen has drawn a loyal following without the need for extensive advertising. Its cozy atmosphere and innovative menu make it a unique spot for sandwich lovers. Each visit promises a new flavor adventure, making it a cherished destination for those seeking something different. The café’s culinary creativity and dedication to quality set it apart in Ohio’s sandwich scene.
10. Loops, Columbus
Loops in Columbus is a family-owned gem that has captured hearts with its sandwiches on grilled pita or hoagies. Featured on ‘Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives,’ this shop showcases a commitment to quality without the need for large-scale advertising. The menu, filled with flavorful options, offers something for everyone, making it a favorite among locals. Each sandwich is a testament to the passion and expertise that goes into every creation. Loops’ engaging atmosphere and culinary artistry make it a must-visit for those exploring Ohio’s vibrant sandwich scene.
11. Tommy’s Deli, Cleveland
Tommy’s Deli in Cleveland is a hidden treasure known for its stacked corned beef sandwiches. This no-nonsense deli doesn’t rely on marketing tricks; instead, it focuses on generous servings and authentic flavors. The unpretentious vibe makes it a favorite spot for those who appreciate quality without the frills. Each sandwich, packed with hearty ingredients, delivers a taste experience that keeps patrons coming back. Tommy’s dedication to excellence and consistency has earned it loyal customers who value its straightforward approach to delicious food. It’s a place where great taste speaks louder than any advertisement.
12. G&R Tavern, Waldo
G&R Tavern in Waldo is famous for its bologna sandwiches, a local favorite that has been enjoyed for generations. Nestled in a rustic setting, this historic tavern offers a unique dining experience that doesn’t rely on advertising to draw crowds. The bologna sandwich, expertly crafted with quality ingredients, is a culinary delight that has locals raving. G&R Tavern’s rich history and charming atmosphere create a welcoming environment where patrons feel at home. It’s a place where tradition and flavor unite, making it a beloved destination for those in search of authentic, hearty sandwiches.
