Unearth The Voyage
Tucked away in the small town of Chouteau, Oklahoma, the Amish Cheese House is a treasure trove of handcrafted goodies that will make your taste buds dance. This charming store offers everything from creamy cheeses to freshly baked bread, all made with traditional Amish methods passed down through generations.
If you’re craving authentic homemade treats and a shopping experience that feels like stepping back in time, this hidden gem is the perfect destination for food lovers and curious travelers alike.
Artisan Cheese Selection
Walking through the doors, you’ll immediately spot the star of the show: rows upon rows of handcrafted cheeses that would make any cheese lover weak in the knees. The Amish Cheese House specializes in varieties you won’t find at your average grocery store, from sharp aged cheddar to creamy Colby and everything in between.
Each wheel and block is made using traditional techniques that prioritize quality over speed.
What sets these cheeses apart is the attention to detail in every batch. The cheese-makers use high-quality milk and natural ingredients, avoiding the shortcuts that mass-produced brands rely on.
You can taste the difference in every bite—the flavors are richer, more complex, and genuinely satisfying.
Whether you’re planning a fancy charcuterie board or just want a snack that’s worth savoring, the cheese selection here won’t disappoint. The staff is happy to offer samples, so don’t be shy about trying before you buy.
From mild to extra sharp, smoked to herb-infused, there’s a cheese here for every palate and preference.
Fresh Baked Bread
The aroma of freshly baked bread hits you the moment you step inside, and it’s absolutely irresistible. Amish Cheese House bakes their bread daily using simple, wholesome ingredients that your grandmother would approve of.
No preservatives, no artificial flavors—just flour, water, yeast, and a whole lot of love.
They offer a variety of loaves, from classic white and hearty whole wheat to cinnamon raisin and sourdough. Each loaf has a perfectly golden crust and a soft, fluffy interior that makes store-bought bread taste like cardboard in comparison.
Grab a loaf while it’s still warm, and you might find yourself tearing off chunks before you even make it to the car.
Bread from the Amish Cheese House doesn’t last as long as the supermarket stuff because it lacks preservatives, but that’s hardly a problem—it’s so delicious that it’ll be gone within a day or two anyway. Toast it, make sandwiches, or just slather it with butter and enjoy the simple pleasures of real, honest-to-goodness bread.
Homemade Jams and Jellies
Forget everything you know about store-bought spreads—the homemade jams and jellies here are in a league of their own. Shelves are lined with jewel-toned jars filled with strawberry, raspberry, blackberry, peach, and even unique flavors like dandelion jelly.
Each jar is packed with real fruit and just the right amount of sweetness.
The texture is what really sets these preserves apart. Instead of the overly smooth, gel-like consistency of commercial jams, these have chunks of actual fruit that remind you what you’re eating.
Spread them on toast, swirl them into yogurt, or use them to jazz up a peanut butter sandwich—they make everything taste better.
Many of the jams are made in small batches using recipes that have been handed down through Amish families for generations. That means you’re not just buying a jar of jam; you’re taking home a piece of culinary tradition.
The flavors are bold and authentic, capturing the essence of summer fruit even in the dead of winter.
Bulk Food Section
Budget-conscious shoppers and home bakers will love the bulk food section, which is basically a treasure chest of ingredients at unbeatable prices. Here you’ll find everything from flour and sugar to exotic grains, dried beans, nuts, and baking mixes.
Buy as much or as little as you need, which is perfect for trying new recipes without committing to a giant bag.
The selection is impressive, covering staples you use every day and specialty items that are hard to find elsewhere. Looking for spelt flour or quinoa?
They’ve got it. Need chocolate chips for cookies or dried cranberries for salads?
No problem. The quality is consistently high, and the prices are refreshingly reasonable compared to fancy health food stores.
Shopping in bulk also means less packaging waste, which is a nice bonus for environmentally conscious folks. Bring your own containers if you want to be extra eco-friendly, or use the bags they provide.
Either way, you’ll leave with exactly what you need and probably discover a few new ingredients to experiment with in your kitchen.
Baked Goods and Pies
Save room in your basket for the baked goods and pies, because skipping this section would be a culinary crime. The bakery case is filled with treats that look like they came straight from a country kitchen: flaky fruit pies, rich cinnamon rolls, chewy cookies, and delicate pastries.
Everything is made from scratch, often using recipes that have been perfected over generations.
The pies are particularly noteworthy, with fillings that taste like pure fruit rather than overly sweet goo. Apple, cherry, peach, and berry pies feature generous amounts of filling encased in buttery, flaky crusts that shatter beautifully with each forkful.
They’re the kind of pies that make holidays feel special and ordinary Tuesdays taste like celebrations.
Cookies and pastries are equally tempting, from classic chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin to specialty items like snickerdoodles and frosted sugar cookies. The cinnamon rolls are legendary—massive spirals of dough swirled with cinnamon sugar and topped with cream cheese frosting.
Grab one for breakfast, and you’ll start your day on an undeniably delicious note.
Honey and Maple Syrup
Natural sweeteners take center stage in the honey and maple syrup section, where you’ll find pure, unfiltered products that put corn syrup to shame. The honey comes from local beekeepers and varies in flavor depending on the flowers the bees visited—some batches are light and delicate, while others are darker and more robust.
All of it is raw and unpasteurized, preserving the beneficial enzymes and nutrients.
Maple syrup here is the real deal, not the artificially flavored stuff that dominates supermarket shelves. It’s graded by color and flavor intensity, so you can choose exactly what suits your taste.
Lighter syrups have a subtle sweetness perfect for pancakes, while darker grades deliver a bold maple punch ideal for baking or glazing meats.
Both honey and maple syrup are versatile ingredients that go beyond breakfast foods. Use honey in tea, salad dressings, or marinades.
Drizzle maple syrup over roasted vegetables, stir it into oatmeal, or use it in place of sugar in recipes. These natural sweeteners add depth and complexity that refined sugar simply can’t match.
Canned Goods and Sauces
Stocking your pantry becomes a pleasure when you shop from the canned goods and sauces selection. Jars of homemade salsa, pasta sauce, pizza sauce, and apple butter line the shelves, each one bursting with flavor that makes meal prep easier and tastier.
These aren’t your typical mass-produced canned goods; they’re made in small batches with fresh ingredients and authentic recipes.
The salsa is chunky and vibrant, with a perfect balance of tomatoes, peppers, onions, and spices. Mild versions are family-friendly, while hot varieties bring serious heat for those who like their food with a kick.
Pasta sauces are rich and hearty, simmering down tomatoes with herbs and garlic until the flavors meld into something truly special.
Apple butter is another standout, slow-cooked until it reaches a deep, caramelized sweetness that’s perfect on toast, biscuits, or even as a pork chop glaze. These canned goods make weeknight cooking easier without sacrificing quality or taste.
Keep a few jars on hand, and you’ll always have the foundation for a delicious meal ready to go.
Candy and Confections
Your inner child will squeal with delight at the candy and confections section, which feels like stepping into an old-fashioned candy shop. Shelves overflow with nostalgic treats like saltwater taffy, peanut brittle, caramels, and fudge.
Many of the candies are handmade right in the store, ensuring freshness and quality that mass-produced sweets can’t touch.
The fudge is creamy and rich, available in flavors like chocolate, peanut butter, maple walnut, and seasonal varieties. It’s cut into generous squares that melt on your tongue, delivering intense flavor without being cloyingly sweet.
Peanut brittle is perfectly crunchy with just the right ratio of peanuts to candy, making it dangerously addictive.
Beyond the classics, you’ll find unique regional candies and imported European chocolates that add an international flair to the selection. Whether you’re treating yourself or assembling gift baskets, the candy section offers endless options.
Just be warned: it’s nearly impossible to leave without buying more than you planned. The combination of nostalgia and quality makes these treats irresistible.
Spices and Seasonings
Home cooks will appreciate the extensive spices and seasonings section, where you can find both common staples and hard-to-locate specialty blends. Everything is available in bulk, so you can buy exactly the amount you need without paying premium prices for tiny supermarket jars.
The spices are fresh, aromatic, and far more potent than the dusty bottles that have been sitting on store shelves for months.
The selection covers all the basics—cinnamon, paprika, garlic powder, black pepper—plus more exotic options like cardamom, turmeric, and various curry blends. Pre-mixed seasonings for specific dishes, like taco seasoning or Italian herb blend, save time without sacrificing flavor.
Many customers buy small amounts to try new spices, then return for larger quantities once they fall in love.
Freshness makes all the difference in cooking, and these spices deliver vibrant flavors that elevate every dish. Compare the aroma of freshly purchased cinnamon from here to a year-old jar from your pantry, and you’ll immediately understand why serious cooks shop for spices in bulk.
Your taste buds—and your wallet—will thank you.
Snack Mixes and Treats
Snacking reaches new heights with the homemade snack mixes and treats available at Amish Cheese House. From savory party mixes loaded with nuts and pretzels to sweet trail mixes bursting with dried fruit and chocolate chips, there’s something for every craving.
These aren’t your average grab-and-go snacks; they’re carefully crafted blends that balance flavors and textures beautifully.
The party mixes are addictive, seasoned with just the right blend of spices that make you reach for handful after handful. They’re perfect for road trips, movie nights, or keeping in your desk drawer for afternoon pick-me-ups.
Trail mixes offer wholesome energy with combinations of nuts, seeds, dried fruits, and sometimes a touch of sweetness from chocolate or yogurt chips.
What sets these snack mixes apart is the quality of ingredients and the thoughtful combinations. You won’t find fillers or stale components—just fresh, crunchy, flavorful bites that actually satisfy.
They’re also great for entertaining; pour them into bowls for parties, and guests will be asking where you found such delicious snacks. Stock up on a few bags for yourself and extras for sharing.
Coffee and Tea Selection
Caffeine lovers won’t be disappointed by the coffee and tea selection, which features both familiar favorites and unique regional blends. Whole bean and ground coffee options range from mild breakfast blends to dark, robust roasts that pack a serious punch.
Many varieties are flavored with natural essences like vanilla, hazelnut, or cinnamon, adding extra dimension to your morning cup.
The coffee is roasted in small batches to ensure peak freshness, which makes a noticeable difference in both aroma and taste. Beans retain more of their essential oils and complex flavors when they’re fresh, resulting in a smoother, richer brew.
If you’re used to grocery store coffee, the difference will be immediately apparent with your first sip.
Tea drinkers have plenty of options too, from classic black and green teas to herbal blends designed for relaxation or wellness. Loose-leaf varieties offer superior flavor compared to tea bags, and the bulk format means you can experiment with different types without breaking the bank.
Whether you’re a coffee devotee or a tea enthusiast, this section has quality beverages to fuel your days.
Gift Baskets and Sampler Packs
Can’t decide what to buy, or shopping for someone else? The gift baskets and sampler packs solve that problem beautifully.
Pre-assembled baskets feature carefully curated selections of the store’s best products—cheese, crackers, jams, honey, and candies arranged in attractive packages. They make fantastic gifts for housewarmings, holidays, or anyone who appreciates quality food.
Sampler packs let you try multiple products without committing to full-size portions, which is perfect for first-time visitors who want to experience a variety of offerings. Cheese samplers might include four or five different varieties, while jam samplers provide small jars of unique flavors.
It’s a great way to discover new favorites without overbuying.
You can also request custom baskets tailored to specific preferences or dietary needs, which adds a personal touch that generic gift baskets lack. The staff is happy to help you assemble something special, whether you’re celebrating a birthday, thanking a host, or just want to share a taste of Oklahoma’s Amish community with friends and family.
These baskets showcase the best of what Amish Cheese House offers in one beautiful, delicious package.
