Unearth The Voyage
Wisconsin is renowned for its rich tradition of pie-making, where every slice offers a taste of home. Whether you’re craving the tartness of cherries, the warmth of cinnamon apples, or the indulgence of chocolate mousse, these pie shops deliver homemade goodness that feels like a hug from Grandma herself. Here’s a delicious journey through eight pie havens in the Badger State.
1. Stockholm Pie & General Store – Stockholm, WI
Nestled by the riverside, Stockholm Pie & General Store is a Wisconsin treasure. Imagine stepping into a century-old building where the scent of freshly baked pies envelops you. Their Caramel Apple Crunch, Blackberry-Apple, and Rum-Soaked Apple Crisp are favorites that evoke childhood memories. Awarded the #1 Pie Shop in America by USA Today, this place is a slice of heaven for pie enthusiasts. The rustic charm and friendly atmosphere make it a must-visit. Each pie is crafted with love, ensuring every bite feels like a warm hug from Grandma.
2. Norske Nook (various locations)
Since 1973, Norske Nook has been a beloved pie institution across multiple Wisconsin locations. Renowned for their Scandinavian twist, they offer flavors like Cranberry Apple, Blueberry Crunch, and Chocolate Mousse. Each pie is made from scratch, a testament to their dedication to quality. With a cozy, welcoming vibe, it’s like visiting a beloved relative’s home. The pies are delightful, and the memories made while enjoying them last a lifetime. Whether you’re in Osseo, Rice Lake, DeForest, or Hayward, a slice from Norske Nook is a slice of tradition.
3. Market Street Diner & Bakery – Sun Prairie, WI
Step into Market Street Diner & Bakery and be transported back in time. This retro-style diner is famed for its wide selection of fresh pies, blending classic and seasonal flavors. Picture Apple Raspberry, Pumpkin Chocolate Chip, and Chocolate Walnut pies waiting to be savored. The lively decor complements the delicious offerings, creating an unforgettable experience. Whether you’re indulging in a nostalgic favorite or trying something new, each pie is a testament to their baking expertise. It’s a delightful trip down memory lane with every bite.
4. Sweetie Pies – Fish Creek / Door County
In the heart of Door County, Sweetie Pies captures the essence of cherry bliss. Known for their outstanding Cherry pies, they also offer Rhubarb, Peach, Pecan, and adorable “Cutie Pies” you can bake at home. The shop’s warm and inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for a sweet treat. Surrounded by picturesque cherry orchards, Sweetie Pies offers a taste of the region’s bounty. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a delightful experience that echoes the comforts of home. It’s a cherry lover’s paradise.
5. Crystal Cafe – Iola, WI
Crystal Cafe in Iola is synonymous with homemade goodness. Their slogan, “Pies 2 Die 4,” speaks to the quality of their offerings. Specializing in hand-made pies with vintage recipes, they use no canned fruit or preservatives. The Lemon Meringue pie stands out with its perfect balance of tart and sweet. This family-run diner exudes warmth and hospitality, making it a beloved local spot. Each pie is a tribute to traditional baking, providing comfort and nostalgia. It’s a cherished destination for anyone seeking authentic, homemade flavors.
6. The Elegant Farmer – Mukwonago, WI
The Elegant Farmer, famed for their iconic pies baked in brown paper bags, is a culinary gem. Located in Mukwonago, this unique technique results in an unparalleled crust and flavor. The apple pie, a crowd favorite, has achieved legendary status. Visitors are also charmed by the innovative “pie bar,” offering a fun, interactive way to enjoy these baked delights. The farmhouse setting adds to the rustic charm, making it a memorable visit. It’s a slice of Wisconsin tradition, served with a side of innovation.
7. Lake Geneva Pie Company
Lake Geneva Pie Company is an essential stop for pie enthusiasts. Known for baking from scratch, they offer a delightful array of flavors, served by the slice or whole. Each pie is a testament to the craftsmanship and passion for preserving traditional methods. The shop’s welcoming ambiance invites you to sit and savor each bite. With a focus on quality ingredients, every pie feels like a celebration of classic flavors. It’s a charming detour on any journey, capturing the essence of homemade goodness.
8. Pleasant View Bakery (Amish-style) – Dalton, WI
Tucked away in Dalton, WI, Pleasant View Bakery is a hidden gem. This Amish-style bakery is renowned for its heavenly pastries and commitment to traditional baking techniques. Each pie is crafted with love and an adherence to time-honored methods, resulting in exceptional flavors. The bakery’s rustic charm and serene setting provide a peaceful escape. Whether you’re savoring a fruit-filled delight or a creamy indulgence, the experience is pure and authentic. It’s a testament to the enduring allure of homemade treats.
