Unearth The Voyage
Wisconsin is a state known for its cheese, and it’s no surprise that the pizza scene is thriving. From Milwaukee to the Northwoods, each pizzeria brings its unique twist to this beloved dish. Whether you’re a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or anything in between, Wisconsin’s pizza spots offer a delightful culinary journey. Here’s a look at 15 standout pizzerias across the state, each with its own flair and flavor.
1. Zaffiro’s Pizza – Milwaukee
Zaffiro’s Pizza in Milwaukee is a slice of history. Known for its razor-thin crust, this iconic spot has been serving locals since the 1950s. With its charming, old-school atmosphere, patrons enjoy pizzas made with a meticulous approach to tradition.
The pizza here isn’t just food; it’s a piece of Milwaukee’s culinary heritage. Regulars rave about the “Everything But Fish” special, a testament to its popularity.
For a truly local experience, plan a visit on a bustling weekend. The combination of crispy crust and rich toppings keeps customers coming back. Zaffiro’s remains a beloved institution, a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts exploring Milwaukee.
2. Wild Tomato Wood‑Fired Pizza & Grille – Sister Bay
Sister Bay’s Wild Tomato is where wood-fired magic happens. Nestled in Door County, this family-owned gem emphasizes fresh, local ingredients. Wisconsin cheese curds adorn specialty pies, adding a unique twist.
The ambiance here is vibrant and welcoming, a perfect match for the scenic beauty of Door County. Patrons can enjoy their pizza on a cozy patio during summer months, enhancing the experience.
If you’re in the area, it’s a culinary stop you won’t regret. The fusion of local produce and innovative toppings makes each pizza a memorable creation. Wild Tomato offers not just a meal, but a Door County tradition.
3. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Madison
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. is a staple in Madison, known for its creative toppings and neighborhood charm. This local favorite offers a diverse menu that caters to adventurous taste buds.
The atmosphere is relaxed yet lively, with a focus on community engagement. Their half & half option allows patrons to indulge in multiple flavors, a feature cherished by regulars.
Whether for a casual dinner or a celebratory feast, Glass Nickel remains a preferred choice. It’s more than just a pizzeria; it’s a community hub where creativity meets culinary delight. With locations throughout the area, it’s accessible and consistently delicious.
4. Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant – Mount Pleasant
Wells Brothers offers a taste of tradition in Mount Pleasant. This historic Italian-American pizzeria has been delighting guests for generations with its time-tested thin-crust pies.
The setting is a charming nod to the past, with vintage decor and a welcoming ambiance. Regulars recommend the sausage-and-mushroom pizza, a classic combination that highlights their culinary expertise.
For those seeking an authentic experience, Wells Brothers remains a beloved choice. It’s not just the pizza, but the nostalgia and community spirit that make each visit special. Pairing a pizza with an Italian sub completes the experience.
5. Polito’s Pizza – Wisconsin Rapids
Polito’s Pizza in Wisconsin Rapids is famed for its giant New-York-style slices. These foldable delights are perfect for those with hearty appetites.
The atmosphere is lively, with a focus on generous portions and bold flavors. Patrons often share slices, making it a social experience as much as a culinary one.
Known for delivering both quality and quantity, Polito’s caters to pizza lovers who appreciate a well-executed classic. Whether for a casual lunch or a fun night out, it’s a staple in Wisconsin Rapids. It’s a taste of New York with a Midwestern twist, offering both familiarity and novelty.
6. Fixture Pizza Pub – Milwaukee
Fixture Pizza Pub combines Milwaukee’s rich history with modern pizzazz. Housed in a historic building, it offers both thin and deep-dish options, appealing to diverse palates.
The ambiance is inviting, with an emphasis on community and quality. It’s not just about the pizza; the live music and special events make it a destination for locals and visitors alike.
Fixture’s commitment to high-quality ingredients shines through in every bite. For a fun night out, it’s hard to beat the combination of delicious pizza and vibrant entertainment. It’s a modern classic in Milwaukee’s culinary scene, offering both tradition and innovation.
7. Christianos Pizza – Green Lake
Christianos Pizza in Green Lake is a serene escape for pizza lovers. Known for using 100% Wisconsin mozzarella, their brick-oven creations are a true delight.
The lakeside setting adds a peaceful backdrop to the dining experience. It’s a perfect stop for those exploring the region, offering a blend of culinary and natural beauty.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Christianos offers a taste of Wisconsin’s best. Pairing a pizza with a stroll by the water makes for a memorable outing. It’s a sanctuary for those seeking quality and tranquility in equal measure.
8. Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria – Green Bay
Cranky Pat’s is a local legend in Green Bay, known for its distinctive square-cut pizzas. This beloved spot draws strong local loyalty with its consistent quality and friendly atmosphere.
The pizzeria is deeply rooted in the community, often bustling with patrons savoring its unique offerings. A bratwurst-topped specialty pizza adds a regional twist, making every visit special.
For those seeking a genuine Wisconsin experience, Cranky Pat’s delivers. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a gathering place for friends and family. The combination of tradition and innovation keeps locals coming back for more.
9. Ian’s Pizza – Madison & Milwaukee
Ian’s Pizza is a vibrant fixture in both Madison and Milwaukee. Known for off-beat specialty pies like mac-and-cheese and smoked brisket, Ian’s offers an adventurous culinary experience.
The atmosphere is lively, embodying the fun, eclectic spirit of college towns. It’s a perfect spot for a late-night slice, with extended hours catering to night owls.
Ian’s is about embracing the unconventional, making it a go-to for those seeking something different. Whether you’re exploring new flavors or indulging in a classic favorite, Ian’s promises a memorable pizza journey. It’s a hub for creativity and community in Wisconsin’s urban centers.
10. Minocqua Pizza Company – Minocqua
In the heart of Wisconsin’s Northwoods, Minocqua Pizza Company offers a relaxed, vacation-friendly dining experience. Known for build-your-own pizzas, patrons enjoy crafting their perfect pie.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting, reflecting the area’s natural beauty. Signature bold toppings add a creative twist to classic offerings, appealing to adventurous eaters.
Whether it’s a day of fishing or exploring nature, a stop at Minocqua Pizza Company enhances the experience. It’s a local favorite that captures the spirit of the Northwoods, offering both comfort and creativity in every slice. A must-visit for anyone exploring northern Wisconsin.
11. Maria’s Pizza – Milwaukee
Maria’s Pizza in Milwaukee is a nostalgic homage to traditional pizza parlors. Known for its large oval pies, this spot offers an old-school atmosphere that charms patrons.
The ambiance is filled with warmth, reminiscent of family gatherings and classic pizzerias. Guests are encouraged to bring their appetite, as the generous servings are a hallmark of Maria’s.
It’s not just about the size, but the quality and tradition that make Maria’s a staple in Milwaukee. For those craving a slice of nostalgia, it’s a culinary trip back in time, offering both history and delicious pizza in every visit.
12. Novanta — Middleton
Novanta, near Madison, offers an elevated pizza experience with authentic wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies. Praised for precision and craftsmanship, it draws locals seeking quality and flavor.
The ambiance is refined yet welcoming, perfect for those after a more traditional pizza dining experience. Each pie is a work of art, with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients enhancing every bite.
Ideal for pizza purists, Novanta combines tradition with a modern touch. It’s a culinary destination for those appreciating precision and authenticity, making it a standout in the Middleton dining scene. A must for anyone craving true Neapolitan craftsmanship.
13. Geno’s Pizza – Eau Claire
Geno’s Pizza in Eau Claire offers a twist on tradition with its Chicago-influenced style. This western Wisconsin gem is a destination for those exploring unique regional flavors.
The atmosphere is cozy, with a focus on warmth and community. Patrons often pair their pizzas with local microbrews, enhancing the culinary experience.
For adventurers seeking something different, Geno’s provides a delicious detour from the ordinary. Its blend of traditional and regional elements makes it a must-visit in Eau Claire. It’s more than just pizza; it’s a flavorful journey through Wisconsin’s diverse culinary landscape.
14. Monical’s Pizza — Arbor Vitae
Monical’s Pizza in Arbor Vitae is a family-friendly spot offering both thin and deep crusts. Nestled in the Northwoods, it provides a welcoming environment for locals and visitors alike.
The setting is casual, with a focus on comfort and community. After a day outdoors, it’s a perfect location to unwind with a satisfying pizza and good company.
Whether vacationing or exploring, Monical’s adds a delicious layer to the Northwoods experience. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a slice of home in a beautiful setting. A great choice for anyone visiting northern Wisconsin, combining culinary delight with local charm.
15. Pizza Brutta – Madison
Pizza Brutta in Madison is focused on true wood-fired Neapolitan pies, crafted with precision and passion. Using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, each pizza is a testament to quality.
The atmosphere is intimate and inviting, offering a taste of Italy in the heart of Wisconsin. For those who appreciate traditional techniques and flavors, Pizza Brutta delivers in every slice.
It’s a haven for pizza purists seeking a genuine experience. The combination of authentic crusts, rich sauces, and thoughtful toppings makes it a standout in Madison’s culinary scene. A must for connoisseurs and casual diners alike, offering a true taste of Neapolitan excellence.
