Unearth The Voyage
Wyoming might not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of Italian cuisine, but the state is home to some surprising culinary delights. From family-run bistros to cozy trattorias, these hidden gems offer authentic flavors that transport you straight to Italy. Discover the best-kept secrets of Wyoming’s culinary scene with these ten Italian restaurants that locals might prefer to keep to themselves.
1. Glorietta Trattoria – Jackson, WY
Located at 242 N Glenwood St, Glorietta Trattoria is a blend of rustic elegance and contemporary flair. Handmade pasta and wood-fired specialties define their menu, with local ingredients taking center stage. The refined yet relaxed dining experience draws in both tourists and locals alike.
In a town bustling with visitors, this trattoria offers a hidden culinary retreat. The sophisticated interior design complements the expertly crafted dishes, making it a beloved spot for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. Its position in downtown Jackson makes it easily accessible, yet it still feels like a special secret to those in the know.
2. Napoli’s Italian Restaurant – Cheyenne, WY
Napoli’s Italian Restaurant, at 1901 Central Ave Suite A, offers a welcoming, family-friendly setting where Italian comfort food takes center stage. With a calm atmosphere and attentive service, it’s a standout choice in Cheyenne. Patrons enjoy genuine Italian fare crafted with care and tradition.
The restaurant’s wholesome environment makes it a favorite for families seeking a leisurely meal. Its location away from the city’s hustle allows diners to enjoy a tranquil dining experience. Despite being in a bustling area, it remains a hidden gem cherished by those who’ve discovered its delights.
3. Bosco’s Italian Restaurante – Casper, WY
Bosco’s Italian Restaurante in Casper is a local favorite that blends old-school charm with hearty, authentic Italian flavors. Tucked away at 847 E A Street, this family-run eatery has been serving comforting classics for years. The menu features generous portions of pasta, veal, seafood, and house-made sauces that taste like they came straight from Nonna’s kitchen. Diners rave about the lasagna, chicken marsala, and perfectly baked garlic bread. The cozy, dimly lit dining room adds a touch of romance without pretense, making it ideal for both family dinners and date nights. With warm service, affordable prices, and a loyal local following, Bosco’s remains one of Casper’s most beloved dining spots—a true Italian gem hiding in plain sight.
4. Orsetto Italian Bar & Eatery – Jackson, WY
Orsetto, located at 161 Center St, is a modern take on Italian-American dining. Its urban-casual vibe and stylish interior make it a standout in Jackson. Offering a full Italian wine list and craft cocktails, it’s a place where locals feel they’ve discovered something special.
The menu features Italian-American classics in a contemporary setting, creating a unique dining experience. Regulars appreciate its chic atmosphere and innovative culinary offerings. Positioned in the heart of Jackson, it draws a diverse crowd, yet maintains an air of exclusivity that sets it apart.
5. The Grumpy Italian – Saratoga, WY
The Grumpy Italian at 113 W Bridge Ave offers a laid-back atmosphere where pizza and pasta are the stars. Beloved by locals for its authentic flavors, this spot provides a casual setting perfect for a relaxed meal. The friendly vibe makes it a go-to for comfort food enthusiasts.
While it may lack the upscale feel of other venues, it more than compensates with genuine culinary delights. This unpretentious eatery ensures guests leave satisfied and smiling. Nestled in Saratoga, it’s a true hidden gem that few tourists stumble upon, making it special for those in the know.
6. Palermos Italian Restaurant – Laramie, WY
Palermos, at 207 3rd St in Laramie, is a cozy neighborhood spot that serves up Italian favorites. Its warm ambiance makes it popular among students, professors, and locals alike. This under-the-radar venue offers a slice of Italy in a relaxed setting.
Known for its simple yet genuine dishes, Palermos has a loyal following that appreciates its unpretentious charm. The restaurant’s inviting environment encourages long conversations over plates of delicious pasta. It’s a hidden treasure where friendly faces and good food go hand in hand.
7. Bella’s Bistro – Saratoga, WY
At 218 N 1st St, Bella’s Bistro charms guests with a warm, intimate feel. Run by the husband-and-wife team, Tommy and Cassie Orduno, they craft each dish from scratch, offering traditional pastas and fresh seafood. Their attention to detail and commitment to quality create a sense of being in an Italian home.
With award-winning wines and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s a destination for those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The setting in a historic 1904 home adds an extra layer of charm. Locals love it for its secluded feel and warm hospitality, making it a treasured escape in Wyoming.
8. Mulino Italian Bistro – Lander, WY
Mulino Italian Bistro, at 129 Main St, brings Italian flair to Lander’s small-town setting. This hidden gem is worth the detour for those who appreciate authentic flavors. With a charming decor and intimate atmosphere, it’s a delightful spot for a leisurely meal.
The menu offers a mix of traditional and innovative dishes, pleasing locals who crave something unique. Its location away from major routes adds to its allure, making it an exclusive discovery for those who venture off the beaten path. Mulino’s local sensibility combined with Italian taste is its defining feature.
9. Bosco’s Italian Restaurante – Casper, WY
Bosco’s Italian Restaurante, at 847 E A St, offers a comfortable dining experience with a wide selection of pasta dishes. This Casper restaurant prides itself on its local feel and welcoming atmosphere, making it a beloved choice for residents.
While it might lack the flashy appeal of city eateries, it compensates with warmth and authenticity. The restaurant’s friendly service and delicious offerings create a memorable dining experience. Bosco’s stands out for its homey environment and dedication to satisfying its patrons.
10. Il Villaggio Osteria, Teton Village
Nestled amidst the scenic landscapes of Teton Village, Il Villaggio Osteria offers a slice of Italy in the heart of Wyoming. Known for its rustic charm, the restaurant serves classic Italian dishes with a modern twist.
The wood-fired pizzas and house-made pastas are particularly popular among locals. The ambiance, accentuated by warm lighting and wooden interiors, makes it a perfect spot for a cozy meal.
With the breathtaking backdrop of the mountains, dining here feels like a European escape. It’s a hidden gem in the bustling village, cherished by those who discover it.
11. Calico Bar & Restaurant, Wilson
Calico Bar & Restaurant in Wilson is a beloved spot that combines Italian traditions with a touch of local flair. The restaurant boasts a welcoming atmosphere with its delightful outdoor patio.
Guests often enjoy the signature dishes such as the creamy risottos and savory lasagnas. The bar also offers a wide selection of Italian wines to complement the meals.
It’s not just a place to eat but a community hub where stories are shared over delicious food. The unique charm of Calico makes it a cherished haunt for locals and visitors alike.
12. Pizza Carrello, Gillette
In the heart of Gillette, Pizza Carrello stands as a vibrant testament to Italian culinary passion. Known for its artisanal wood-fired pizzas, this eatery captures the spirit of Italy with every slice.
The open kitchen offers a lively view of the skilled chefs at work, creating an engaging dining experience. Beyond pizzas, the menu features a variety of fresh salads and unique appetizers.
Despite its small-town location, Pizza Carrello is a culinary powerhouse, attracting food lovers from all around. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking genuine Italian flavors in Wyoming.
