Some people plan road trips around museums or ballparks. Others plan them around a slice of cheesecake, and honestly, they might be onto something.
A truly good cheesecake is a small project of patience, with bakers fussing over crusts, baking times, and toppings for years before they get it right. Across America, a handful of shops have turned that fussing into a full-time job.
One bakery swapped the usual graham cracker crust for a cookie base and turned it into a city symbol. Another sells out of flavors like Peach Cobbler and Lucky Charms Cookie before lunch on a busy weekend.
A few are century-old Italian bakeries where cheesecake shares the counter with cannoli made to order. This list covers 12 stops in cities large and small, with real details on signature flavors, opening hours, ordering tips, and the history behind each counter.
Some are tiny specialty shops with lines out the door, while others are family bakeries that have outlasted several generations of customers. Read on to find out where to skip the main course, which days to show up early, and why a few of these places deserve two visits.
Your fork will thank you.
1. Eli’s Cheesecake Company, Chicago, Illinois
Back in 1980, a cheesecake made its public debut at the very first Taste of Chicago and walked away as the festival’s most popular dessert.
Eli Schulman created the recipe in the late 1970s for his restaurant, Eli’s The Place for Steak. The cake proved so popular that it soon became its own company.
The secret is a butter shortbread cookie crust instead of graham crackers. The filling uses cream cheese, sour cream, eggs, sugar, and vanilla, and the cakes are baked hot and fast without a water bath.
Today the action happens at Eli’s Cheesecake World in the Dunning neighborhood, home since 1996. The site includes a 62,000-square-foot bakery, offices, and a bakery cafe where visitors can order a slice.
Flavors range from the Original Plain to chocolate chip, strawberry, and vanilla bean. Seasonal flavors and vegan options also rotate through.
Every cake is hand-decorated. Grab a sampler if choosing one flavor feels like an unfair test.
2. Kitty’s Cheesecakes & More, Ferndale, Michigan
Superman Cheese Cake is a real menu item here, and yes, it is as colorful as the name suggests.
Kitty’s Cheesecakes & More is a family-owned bakery at 681 Eight Mile W, just north of Detroit. It has served Metro Detroit for more than 15 years.
The flavor list reads like a dessert wish list written by a fourth grader with excellent taste. Options include Orange Creamsicle, Pineapple Upside Down, Reese’s Peanut Butter, Strawberry Lemonade, Banana Pudding, Cinnamon Roll, and Black Forest.
Classic New York style is also on hand for purists. Seasonal varieties pop up throughout the year.
Customers praise the friendly staff and fair prices. The shop has earned a 4.8-star rating across more than 600 reviews, which is a lot of happy forks.
Timing matters. Kitty’s is open Wednesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. and closed Sunday through Tuesday.
Need something for a party? The bakery also makes custom cakes, cookies, and pastries.
3. Papa Haydn, Portland, Oregon
Two full pages. That is how long the dessert menu at Papa Haydn often runs, before anyone even mentions the specials.
This Portland institution has been around since 1978. Heidi and Jeff Van Dyke founded it, and Heidi’s sister Evelyn Franz later expanded the sweets with European-inspired creations.
The pastry case near the entrance tends to stop people in their tracks. Plenty of guests study it before they even look at the dinner menu.
Cheesecake fans have solid choices. The Fig and Honey Cheesecake leans elegant, while the New York Cheesecake takes an unusual route.
That New York version is crustless and poached, which makes it naturally gluten-free. It arrives with crème fraîche and fresh blueberries.
The Northwest location sits at 701 NW 23rd Ave, a busy street lined with shops and restaurants. Lunch and dinner are served too.
Pro tip: order dessert first if the case is calling your name. Nobody here will judge.
4. Big Nita’s Cheesecakes, Louisville, Kentucky
One Facebook recipe changed everything for Nicole Burks.
She stumbled onto a banana pudding cheesecake bar recipe, started baking as a hobby, and kept going. That hobby became Big Nita’s Cheesecakes, now a storefront at 1011 E Main St in Louisville’s Butchertown neighborhood.
Banana Pudding is still a signature, along with Caramel Banana Pudding. From there, the menu gets gloriously creative.
Peach Cobbler, Lucky Charms Cookie, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Frosted Animal Cookie all appear on the list. Stuffed varieties like Apple Pie Stuffed and Pumpkin Pie Stuffed hide a whole extra dessert inside.
Here is the catch. The shop usually opens only Friday through Sunday and often sells out.
Customers line up early to claim favorite flavors. Arriving late in the day can mean slim pickings.
The smart move is to pre-order slices, samplers, or cookies online. Whole cheesecakes are ordered by calling the shop directly.
5. Hank’s Cheesecakes, St. Louis, Missouri
October 1987 marks the month Hank’s started slicing, and the shop has stuck with cheesecake ever since.
This small, locally owned St. Louis bakery gives every flavor its own individual recipe. Rather than tossing toppings on one base, each cake is built from scratch to suit its flavor.
Hank’s Original is the logical first order. After that, the list branches into Apricot Almond, Apple Strudel, German Chocolate, Dreamsicle, and Strawberry Shortcake.
Chocolate fans can pick from Double Chocolate, Dark Chocolate Raspberry, Chocolate Swirl, and Peanut Butter Chocolate. Key Lime and Lemon cover the tangy side.
Gluten-free diners are not left out. Gluten-Free Turtle and a Double Chocolate with nut crust are both offered.
Locations include 1063 S Big Bend Blvd and 5390 Southwest Avenue. Each has a casual, neighborhood feel instead of a formal dining room.
Hours run late, until 9 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays. Whole cakes come in several sizes for birthdays and office parties.
6. Banham’s Cheesecake, Phoenix, Arizona
Late-night dessert cravings in Phoenix have a reliable answer that stays open until 10:30 p.m. on weekends.
Banham’s Cheesecake, at 2836 E Indian School Rd, focuses entirely on gourmet cheesecake. There is no long dinner menu competing for attention.
Traditional and Strawberry lead the lineup. Both also come in gluten-free versions, which is a thoughtful touch.
Bolder picks include Salted Caramel Pretzel, Cookie Butter, Strawberry Crunch, and Blueberry Crumble. Seasonal options like Pumpkin and Halloween Brownie show up when the calendar allows.
Locals clearly approve. Banham’s holds a 4.9-star rating from more than 1,000 delivery app ratings, a number most restaurants would frame.
Everything is made fresh to order. For a whole cheesecake, give the shop about 48 hours of notice.
Hours start at noon daily and run until 9:30 p.m. Sunday through Thursday.
That schedule makes it an easy post-dinner stop or a mid-afternoon treat after errands.
7. Southern Sweets Bakery, Decatur, Georgia
Nancy Cole started out baking pies from scratch for an Atlanta steakhouse. In 1992 she opened Southern Sweets Bakery, and the dessert menu has been growing ever since.
Cheesecake here starts with a classic New York Style base. The Strawberry Swirl version folds fresh strawberry puree into that original recipe on a graham cracker crust.
The Oreo Cheesecake goes all in, packed with cookies and set on an Oreo crust. In season, the Sweet Potato Praline Cheesecake brings a proudly Southern twist.
Groups with mixed tastes do well here. One friend can order cheesecake while another picks pie and a third chooses layer cake.
Vegan and gluten-free desserts are part of the regular lineup. That keeps everyone at the table included.
Breakfast and lunch are also served, with sandwiches, soups, and salads. A slice after a lunch salad counts as balance, according to our very official math.
8. Modern Pastry Shop, Boston, Massachusetts
Some of the recipes at Modern Pastry are more than 150 years old, older than the shop itself.
The Picariello family opened this Hanover Street bakery in 1930 after arriving from Italy. They wanted to share authentic recipes, and the family still runs it today.
Cannoli are the headliner, filled to order so the shells stay crisp. Cheesecake, though, deserves a spot in your box.
The Plain Cheesecake is New York style on a buttery graham cracker crust. Strawberry Cheesecake adds a fruit topping to that same base.
Turtle Cheesecake gets caramel, pecans, and a chocolate drizzle. In fall, the Pumpkin Cheesecake takes a seasonal turn.
There is also a Cherry Cheesecake Square, baked into a tart shell and finished with cherry filling and whipped cream.
Expect a busy counter, especially on weekends. Plan to wander the North End’s historic streets afterward, pastry box in hand.
9. Termini Bros Bakery, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Philadelphia cream cheese in a Philadelphia cheesecake just makes sense.
Termini Bros Bakery, a multi-generational family business in the Italian Market neighborhood, uses it in its New York style cheesecake. Chocolate chips are folded right into the filling.
The crust is the local twist. Instead of graham crackers, the cake sits on a buttered cake crumb crust, a style tied to Philadelphia baking.
Of course, the cannoli get plenty of fans too. Shells are filled fresh to order with ricotta, vanilla Italian cream, or chocolate Italian cream.
Display counters are packed with cookies, cakes, and coffee ring cakes. Specialty cookie boxes make easy gifts for anyone who stayed home.
Freshness is a point of pride here. The bakery uses no preservatives and suggests enjoying products within 24 hours.
That gives you a perfect excuse to finish your slice quickly. Then take a walk through the Italian Market stalls nearby.
10. Incredible Cheesecake Company, San Diego, California
Calling yourself incredible is a bold move, so the menu had better back it up.
At 3161 Adams Avenue in Normal Heights, the Incredible Cheesecake Company offers more than twenty slice flavors. That is enough to visit weekly for months without repeating.
Laura’s Recipe is the plain classic and a smart starting point. Ricotta, Lemon Cream, and Pumpkin keep things traditional.
The playful side includes Naughty Hula, Chunky Monkey, Turtle Pecan, and Merv Griffin, a chocolate-on-chocolate creation. Mudd Pie comes on a chocolate cookie crust.
Regulars keep ordering the Key Lime slice, which ranks among the most popular items. Whole cakes include Ube and a Sugar Free Plain option.
Cheesecake cupcakes and cheesecake brownies help when a whole slice feels like too much commitment.
The shop opens seven days a week, starting as early as 7 a.m. on weekdays. Pickup and delivery are both available.
A stroll along the Adams Avenue shops makes a fine way to work up an appetite.
11. Angelo Brocato, New Orleans, Louisiana
At just 12 years old, Angelo Brocato Sr. began learning Sicilian confections in Palermo. He brought those skills to New Orleans and opened his shop in 1905.
More than a century later, Angelo Brocato is the city’s oldest Italian bakery. It now sits on Carrollton Avenue in Mid-City.
The ricotta cheesecake is a lighter, traditional Italian style. It differs from the dense cream cheese cakes found elsewhere on this list.
Gelato and spumoni draw big crowds, and cannoli shells are homemade and filled with ricotta to order. Biscotti round out the pastry case.
Ornate tile floors and marble counters keep the room looking much as it has for generations. Recipes are passed down carefully within the family.
The bakery was a James Beard award semifinalist for outstanding bakery in 2023.
It opens Tuesday through Sunday at 10 a.m. and closes Mondays. Beignets can wait one day.
12. Papa Haydn, Portland, Oregon
Saving the sweetest for last, the list returns to Portland for one more look at Papa Haydn.
This time, head to the Sellwood location at 5829 SE Milwaukie Ave. It offers the same dessert-focused approach in a calmer, neighborhood setting.
Visitors who tried the Fig and Honey Cheesecake on round one can switch to the poached New York version. It skips the crust entirely, a rare choice that also suits gluten-free diners.
Fresh blueberries and crème fraîche come alongside. The pairing keeps the plate simple and focused.
The restaurant has served Portland since 1978, so it knows how to handle a celebration. Birthday groups and date nights both fit right in.
Menu tip: ask about specials before ordering. The regular dessert list is long, and featured items change often.
Sharing two desserts among friends is a popular move here. It is also the easiest way to end a cheesecake road trip with zero regrets.
Share this story
