Some of the best dinners in Ohio happen at places you could drive past a hundred times without noticing. A modest storefront or an old brick building turns out to hold a meal you keep thinking about for weeks.
The suburbs and neighborhoods around Columbus are packed with spots like that, and they reward anyone willing to leave downtown behind for an evening. Grab your keys and an appetite, because these eight tables are worth every mile.
1. The Whitney House, Worthington, OH
Old Worthington already feels like a storybook, with brick sidewalks and historic storefronts lining North High Street. Tucked into that scene, The Whitney House serves American and global dishes with modern, seasonal twists that keep the menu rotating.
Starters like whipped goat cheese set a relaxed pace, while the Tavern Stack Burger keeps things hearty. A creamy tomato soup and carrot cake round out the comfort side of the kitchen.
Vegan and vegetarian diners get full menus of their own, which is rarer than it should be.
Inside, a fireplace warms an intimate room that manages to feel both cozy and polished. Servers know the menu well and happily steer you toward a great match for your plate.
Dinner runs Tuesday through Sunday, starting at 4 PM, and the place is closed Mondays. Reservations are smart, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings, and street parking can take a little patience.
2. Tucci’s Italian Steakhouse, Dublin, OH
Live music drifting over plates of steak and pasta sets a certain mood, and Tucci’s leans into it beautifully. The restaurant sits at 35 N High St in Historic Dublin, where charming old buildings meet a lively dining scene.
Steak, seafood, and pasta share the spotlight here. Red wine braised short ribs, veal chop Parmesan, and shrimp and sausage rigatoni are standouts, and the seafood lineup includes seared salmon, walleye, and halibut.
Short rib arancini and crispy calamari make easy openers for the table.
Seating options add to the appeal. A four-season room keeps things bright year-round, and a patio opens up when Ohio weather cooperates.
Staff move quickly and keep things friendly without fuss.
Parking is usually plentiful, with garages and lots nearby. Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekend evenings when the room hums with celebrations big and small.
3. Asterisk Supper Club, Westerville, OH
Menus hidden inside old books. A speakeasy feel.
Afternoon tea served in the same room where supper unfolds later on. Asterisk Supper Club in uptown Westerville plays by its own rules, and that is exactly the charm.
Behind an unassuming front on North State Street, the space opens into a quiet, stylish room with decor that sparks conversation. Afternoon brings a full tea service with orange cranberry scones and a strong tea selection.
Come evening, the kitchen turns to upmarket American cooking. Flat iron steak with smoked horseradish, truffle fries with garlic aioli, chicken pot pie, and fried chicken with waffles all appear, though menus change regularly with fresh creations.
Vegetarians can lean on mushroom toast or grilled cheese with tomato soup.
Service is polished yet laid-back, and prices feel reasonable for the experience. Doors open at noon Tuesday through Sunday, with Mondays closed.
4. La Tavola, Grandview Heights, OH
Homemade gnocchi has a way of making the whole world slow down. At La Tavola, that kind of comfort is the whole point, served in a warm little dining room on West 1st Avenue in Grandview Heights.
The kitchen puts modern spins on traditional Italian cooking. Bolognese is a signature, chicken parmesan delivers pure nostalgia, and nightly specials lean on farm-to-table ingredients.
Save room, since dessert is a strength here too.
Grandview Heights sits just west of downtown, so the drive is short, yet the neighborhood feels like a small town with its own walkable charm. Service is attentive and genuine, the kind that remembers how you like things.
Dinner only, starting at 5 PM Tuesday through Sunday. Saturday evenings fill fastest, so book ahead.
Parking can be a bit tricky, so give yourself a few extra minutes before your table is ready.
5. Subourbon Southern Kitchen and Spirits, Columbus, OH
Shrimp and grits in central Ohio? Absolutely, and it tastes like a trip south without leaving the 614.
Subourbon brings upscale Southern cooking to a cozy spot on West Dublin-Granville Road in the Linworth and Worthington area.
Gumbo anchors the menu, joined by BBQ shrimp, blackened catfish, and a hot chicken sandwich. The chicken dinner, topped with honey butter, is the kind of plate people drive across town for.
Perfectly cooked short rib also earns plenty of attention.
Lighter picks hold their own. Fried green tomatoes and a beet salad are both vegan, and deviled eggs make a fun starter to share.
Servers know the menu inside and out, and the vibe stays casual and friendly. Hours run 4 to 9 PM Monday through Saturday, closed Sunday.
Parking is easy, and reservations help on busy Friday and Saturday nights.
6. Three Creeks Kitchen + Cocktails, Gahanna, OH
Special occasion coming up? Gahanna has an answer that rivals any high-end table in the region.
Three Creeks Kitchen + Cocktails on Granville Street serves upscale New American cooking built around steaks and seafood.
Seared scallops, salmon, walleye, and beef short rib headline the menu, with chicken marsala offering a classic comfort option. Pickled onion rings make a tangy, crunchy starter, and full vegan and vegetarian menus mean nobody is stuck with a side salad.
The room strikes a nice balance between relaxing and stylish, so it works for anniversaries and casual celebrations alike. Prices land on the higher end, roughly $50 to $100 per person, which fits the polished experience.
Valet parking adds a touch of ease, and free lots are available too. Open nightly from 4 PM, with later hours on Friday and Saturday.
Reserve ahead for Friday evenings, the busiest stretch of the week.
7. Giuseppe’s Ritrovo, Columbus, OH
Jazz on a weeknight, a plate of smoked chicken ravioli, and a cozy table on East Main Street. That combination is pure Bexley, and Giuseppe’s Ritrovo has perfected it.
The kitchen sticks to Italian classics done right. Pizzas, pastas, and eggplant Parmesan share the menu with bruschetta and seasoned dishes that taste carefully made.
Organic options appear too, along with full vegan and vegetarian menus.
Live music gives evenings a special glow, and outdoor tables are lovely on mild nights. A private dining room handles bigger gatherings, and families will find high chairs and a kids’ menu.
Fun fact: ritrovo roughly means a gathering place in Italian, which suits the friendly buzz here. Dinner runs Tuesday through Saturday starting at 5 PM.
Expect a wait even on Tuesdays, so reservations are wise, and street parking may take a short loop around the block.
8. Olive & Lime Cafe, Columbus, OH
Warm bread straight from the oven changes everything about a meal. At Olive & Lime Cafe in Clintonville, that handmade bread arrives alongside flavorful shawarma and a Lebanese-Mediterranean menu that feels both homey and generous.
Dinner standouts include red snapper, shrimp kabob, lamb chops, and chicken kebab. Plant-based eaters get a full menu with lentil soup, fattoush salad, and crispy fried cauliflower.
Finish with pistachio cake and a cup of Turkish coffee for a sweet, bold ending.
A fireplace makes the dining room especially inviting on cold Ohio nights, and the quiet setting works for date night or catching up with friends. Prices stay friendly, around $20 to $30 per person.
Reservations are not accepted, so plan around busy Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings. Closed Tuesdays, with plenty of free parking along North High Street.
Share this story
