Unearth The Voyage
Craving something warm, flaky, and downright irresistible. Oklahoma’s fried pie scene delivers golden pockets of joy that taste like a road trip and a hug from grandma. From mountain pit stops to city icons, these shops sling classics and clever twists that make choosing just one flavor impossible. Let’s hit the sweetest trail in the state and find your next favorite bite.
1. Arbuckle Mountain Original Fried Pies – Oklahoma City
In Oklahoma City, the Arbuckle name meets city speed without losing its soul. The lineup runs deep, from classic apple to coconut cream and a peppery beef option for savory fans. Everything comes out golden, handheld, and audibly crisp.
It is perfect for a lunch break splurge or a late afternoon treat. Grab two, stash one for later, then fail to resist and eat both. That flaky pocket keeps you coming back.
2. Jimmy’s Round-Up Cafe & Fried Pies – Oklahoma City
Jimmy’s is a diner dream where fried pies share the stage with chicken fried steak and bottomless coffee. The crust is hearty and slightly salty, a perfect match for sweet fillings. Ask about seasonal fruit or a scoop of vanilla on top.
The vibe is easygoing and local, like everyone knows your usual order. Slide into a booth, trade bites, and let the conversation linger. You will leave full, happy, and plotting a return trip soon.
3. Pie Junkie – Oklahoma City
Pie Junkie is famous for slabs of luscious pie, but keep an eye out for handheld specials and savory take and bakes. The bakers riff on tradition without losing the soul of butter, sugar, and flaky mastery. Every bite lands with purpose.
The Plaza District energy makes grabbing dessert feel like a celebration. You can split slices or hoard your own. Either way, the crust shatters, the fillings sing, and the line proves you chose wisely.
4. Amish Country Store & Restaurant – Muskogee
This Muskogee stop radiates small town comfort, with fried pies that taste like a family recipe passed down. Fruit fillings are bright and not overly sweet, letting cinnamon and butter shine. Grab a jar of jam to take the flavor home.
There is a quiet pleasure in eating a warm pie beside shelves of pickles and preserves. It feels honest and unpretentious. Expect friendly smiles, generous portions, and pies that disappear faster than you planned.
5. Sweetie Pies Amish Bakery & Cafe – Tulsa
Tulsa’s Sweetie Pies bakes with patience and pride, turning out fried pies that crunch outside and stay tender within. Fruit flavors lean classic, with seasonal surprises appearing alongside cream fillings. You can taste real ingredients in every bite.
Pair a pie with fresh coffee and settle into a sunlit corner. The staff makes you feel like a regular on the first visit. It is the sweet pause your day has been missing.
6. Boomarang Diner – Various Locations (including Norman & Shawnee)
Boomarang serves dependable diner comfort across Oklahoma, and many spots keep fried pies on deck. After a burger or breakfast plate, that golden turnover calls your name. Apple with ice cream is simple perfection.
The charm is consistency and friendly service that treats every guest like a neighbor. Whether Norman or Shawnee, it feels familiar. Sit, relax, and end the meal with a warm pie that tastes like a throwback done right.
7. Martin House Country Store – Davis
Martin House feels like stepping into a postcard, complete with fried pies wrapped in wax paper. The country store shelves sparkle with local honey, nuts, and candies that pair perfectly with dessert. It is a must when passing through Davis.
Pick a pie, snag a soda, and linger on the porch. Time slows, stories start, and crumbs gather on your lap. This is simple pleasure, Oklahoma style.
8. PatiG’s Tacos And More LLC – Tahlequah
PatiG’s Tacos And More LLC is a beloved spot in Tahlequah for pie enthusiasts. Known for its comforting ambiance, this shop offers an array of flavors.
From classic apple to spicy jalapeño cheese, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The crisp, golden crust envelops fillings that burst with flavor.
The owner’s dedication to quality ingredients is evident in every bite. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Patti’s Place is a must-visit.
9. Field’s Pies – Pauls Valley
Field’s Pies in Pauls Valley captures the essence of homemade goodness. This quaint stand is famous for its light, flaky crusts.
Each pie is crafted with meticulous care, offering both sweet and savory options like cherry and pepperoni. It’s a taste of nostalgia wrapped in pastry.
Locals rave about the friendly service, making it a delightful pit stop. Drive by and treat yourself to this hidden gem.
10. Angie’s Circus City Diner – Hugo
Angie’s Circus City Diner in Hugo is as lively as its name suggests. The diner, known for its retro vibe, serves pies that are a joy to discover.
From pecan to peach, each pie is a celebration of flavor. The diner’s colorful history and vibrant atmosphere add to the experience.
It’s a place where the past meets the present in the most delicious way. Stop by for a bite and enjoy the friendly banter.
11. The Pie Hole – Tulsa
The Pie Hole in Tulsa offers a trendy twist on traditional fried pies. The cafe’s sleek design complements its innovative flavors.
From bourbon pecan to bacon cheeseburger, the creativity is boundless. Every pie is a testament to culinary artistry.
The Pie Hole thrives on pushing boundaries, drawing in adventurous food lovers. It’s a dynamic spot to explore new tastes.
12. Cowpokes Cafe – Kenton
Cowpokes Cafe in Kenton is a charming slice of the Wild West. Serving hearty fried pies, it’s a favorite among locals and travelers.
The menu ranges from classic fillings to unique combinations like green chili beef. Each pie carries a hint of the local spirit.
The cafe’s rustic charm and friendly staff make it an inviting stop. Enjoy a taste of cowboy hospitality with every bite.
13. Katy’s Pantry – Enid
Katy’s Pantry in Enid is where tradition meets taste. This charming bakery is known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and delicious pies.
The selection includes family favorites like buttermilk and chocolate cream. Each pie is lovingly baked to perfection.
Katy’s Pantry is a beloved community spot, celebrated for its quality and service. It’s a perfect place to indulge in sweet memories.
