Ina Mae Tavern brings the spirit of New Orleans straight to Chicago’s Wicker Park neighborhood. This funky Southern restaurant serves up authentic Louisiana favorites like crispy fried chicken, overflowing po’ boys, and sweet beignets that taste like they came straight from the French Quarter.
With live music, a lively atmosphere, and dishes packed with bold Creole flavors, Ina Mae offers a taste of the Big Easy without leaving the Windy City.
The Famous Po’ Boy Sandwiches
Po’ boys reign supreme at Ina Mae, and locals can’t stop raving about them. These massive sandwiches arrive on perfectly crusty French bread that crunches with every bite.
The fried shrimp version stands out as a customer favorite. Plump shrimp get coated in a light, crispy batter before being piled high with fresh lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and tangy remoulade sauce.
One reviewer from New Orleans called it the best po’ boy they’d ever had outside their hometown, which speaks volumes. The bread stays crispy on the outside while remaining soft inside, just like it should.
The blackened shrimp option offers a spicier twist for those who like a little kick. Each sandwich comes loaded with enough filling to satisfy even the hungriest appetite.
Whether you choose fried or blackened, these sandwiches deliver authentic Louisiana flavor. The generous portions mean you might have leftovers for later, though they’re so good you’ll probably finish the whole thing right there.
Crispy Fried Chicken Done Right
Golden and crunchy on the outside, juicy on the inside. Ina Mae’s fried chicken brings serious Southern comfort to every plate.
The kitchen fries each piece to perfection, creating a satisfying crunch that customers love. While some reviewers mention the chicken could use more seasoning in the meat itself, the breading delivers plenty of flavor.
Smart diners pair their chicken with the restaurant’s house-made sauces. The honey hot sauce adds a sweet and spicy kick that complements the crispy coating beautifully.
Portions are generous, and the chicken holds up well even as leftovers. Several guests mentioned enjoying their chicken just as much the next day after reheating.
The chicken tenders offer an alternative with slightly more seasoning throughout. Both options get fried in fresh oil, ensuring that clean taste without any greasiness.
For the full Southern experience, order your chicken with classic sides like mac and cheese or collard greens. The combination creates a meal that feels like Sunday dinner at grandma’s house.
Beignets That Bring the French Quarter
Fluffy pillows of fried dough arrive at your table covered in a snowstorm of powdered sugar. These beignets capture the essence of New Orleans in every sweet bite.
The dough gets fried until golden and puffy, creating pockets of air inside. Each beignet stays light and airy rather than heavy or greasy.
Powdered sugar coats every surface generously, just like at the famous Cafe du Monde. Don’t wear black when you order these because you’ll definitely end up covered in white powder.
The beignets work perfectly as a dessert after a hearty meal or as a sweet treat with coffee. They’re best enjoyed fresh and hot, right when they arrive at your table.
Share an order with friends or keep them all to yourself. Either way, you’ll understand why customers mention these treats in their reviews again and again.
The restaurant keeps the recipe traditional, proving that sometimes the classics don’t need any fancy updates. Simple ingredients and proper technique create something magical that transports you straight to Jackson Square.
Rich and Hearty Gumbo
A steaming bowl of gumbo sits before you, dark and rich with the flavors of Louisiana. This classic stew showcases the restaurant’s commitment to authentic Creole cooking.
The gumbo base starts with a deep, dark roux that takes time and patience to make properly. Chunks of sausage, seafood, and vegetables swim in the flavorful broth.
Customers rave about the bold seasoning and complex flavors. The dish comes with rice on the side, ready to soak up every drop of that delicious liquid.
Interestingly, Ina Mae serves their gumbo over potato salad, a traditional New Orleans style that some people love and others find surprising. The creamy potato salad adds another layer of texture and flavor.
The portion size makes this a filling meal on its own. The gumbo tastes even better the next day after the flavors have had more time to blend together.
With 60 mentions in customer reviews, this dish clearly makes an impression. Whether you’re a gumbo expert or trying it for the first time, Ina Mae’s version won’t disappoint.
Hushpuppies with Pimento Honey Butter
These little balls of fried cornmeal goodness arrive hot and crispy at your table. Hushpuppies might seem simple, but Ina Mae elevates them with perfect execution and creative accompaniments.
The exterior fries up golden and crunchy while the inside stays moist and tender. Each hushpuppy has just the right amount of sweetness from the cornmeal.
The real star here is the pimento honey butter served alongside. This sweet and slightly savory spread melts into the warm hushpuppies, creating an irresistible combination.
One reviewer specifically praised how well-fried these were, with that ideal contrast between crispy outside and soft center. They make an excellent starter to share while you wait for your main dishes.
The pimento flavor in the butter could be stronger according to some guests, but the honey sweetness balances nicely with the savory cornmeal. Pop one in your mouth and you’ll immediately understand the Southern tradition of these simple fritters.
Order these as an appetizer or as a side to your main course. Either way, you’ll probably wish you’d ordered more.
Red Beans and Rice
Comfort food doesn’t get much better than a bowl of creamy red beans ladled over fluffy white rice. This Monday tradition in New Orleans shines any day of the week at Ina Mae.
The beans cook low and slow until they reach that perfect creamy consistency. Chunks of smoky andouille sausage add meaty richness to every spoonful.
Reviewers consistently praise the seasoning and flavor of this dish. The beans taste like they’ve been simmering for hours, developing deep, complex flavors.
This side dish often steals the show from the main course. Many customers mention it specifically in their reviews, calling it one of the best items on the menu.
The portion size works well as either a side or a light meal on its own. The dish reheats beautifully, so don’t hesitate to take leftovers home.
One guest even said the red beans and rice tasted just as good reheated the next day. The flavors continue to develop and meld together even after leaving the restaurant.
For an authentic taste of Louisiana cooking, this dish delivers exactly what you’re craving.
Live Music and New Orleans Vibes
Music fills the air at Ina Mae, creating an atmosphere that transports you straight to Bourbon Street. Live bands play regularly, adding authentic New Orleans energy to your dining experience.
Blues and jazz musicians set up in the restaurant, providing a soundtrack to your meal. The music isn’t just background noise but a central part of the experience.
Customers mention the live music in over 50 reviews, showing how much it adds to the visit. Some nights feature burlesque shows that bring extra entertainment and excitement.
The volume can get loud when bands are playing, so be prepared for a lively atmosphere rather than a quiet dinner. This energy matches the festive New Orleans spirit perfectly.
Mardi Gras decorations cover the walls year-round, from colorful beads to funky artwork. The retro Southern styling creates a fun, relaxed environment that makes you want to stay for another round.
Whether you’re catching a weekend show or enjoying the regular background tunes, the music enhances every bite. The combination of great food and live entertainment makes Ina Mae more than just a restaurant.
Buttermilk Biscuits
Warm, flaky biscuits arrive at your table, ready to soak up gravy or get slathered with butter. These Southern staples showcase the kitchen’s baking skills and attention to traditional recipes.
The biscuits bake up golden brown with distinct layers that pull apart easily. Each one has that perfect combination of crispy exterior and soft, tender interior.
Multiple reviewers call these biscuits perfect, praising their texture and flavor. They work wonderfully as a side dish or as part of a breakfast meal.
The restaurant does charge extra for butter, which some guests found surprising. However, the biscuits taste delicious even on their own thanks to the buttermilk tang.
These biscuits pair especially well with the fried chicken or catfish dishes. Use them to sop up any sauces or gravies left on your plate.
Some customers wish jam or jelly came with the biscuits, but the simple preparation lets the quality of the baking shine through. The slight sweetness from the buttermilk makes additional toppings optional rather than necessary.
Order at least one for the table because everyone will want a taste.
Blackened Catfish
Spicy, charred, and full of flavor. The blackened catfish brings serious Cajun heat to your plate with its dark, seasoned crust.
The kitchen coats fresh catfish in a blend of bold spices before searing it in a screaming-hot pan. This cooking method creates that signature blackened exterior while keeping the fish moist inside.
Several reviewers mention the catfish as a standout dish, praising its preparation and taste. The spice blend adds complexity without overwhelming the delicate fish flavor.
You can order the catfish as part of a dinner platter with sides like grits or mac and cheese. The combination creates a satisfying Southern meal that fills you up.
The fish arrives hot and fresh from the kitchen. Unlike fried options, the blackening method offers a lighter preparation that still delivers big flavor.
Some guests recommend this dish specifically in their reviews, calling it a must-try item. The catfish shows the kitchen’s ability to handle different cooking techniques beyond just frying.
For those who want authentic Louisiana cooking without the heavy breading, this dish hits the spot perfectly.
The Full Outdoor Patio Experience
When the weather cooperates, Ina Mae opens its windows and doors to create a breezy, open-air dining experience. The patio seating brings a taste of New Orleans outdoor dining to Chicago’s streets.
Fresh air flows through the space on nice days, creating a relaxed atmosphere perfect for weekend brunch or evening meals. The indoor-outdoor connection makes the whole restaurant feel more spacious and welcoming.
Customers love grabbing a spot on the patio during warmer months. The setting works great for casual gatherings with friends or low-key date nights.
Bar seating offers another option for solo diners or those who want to watch the action. The bartenders stay attentive and friendly, keeping drinks flowing and conversations going.
Over 20 reviews mention the outdoor seating specifically, showing how much guests appreciate this option. The patio adds to the laid-back vibe that makes Ina Mae feel different from typical Chicago restaurants.
Whether you’re watching Cubs games on TV from the bar or enjoying the breeze on the patio, the space encourages you to relax and take your time. This casual atmosphere matches the Southern hospitality and comfort food perfectly.
Share this story
