Most thrift stores make you work for it. You dig through racks, sift through shelves, and leave with maybe one or two finds if you’re lucky.
But there’s a store on the north side of St. Paul that regulars have been returning to for over a decade, some driving in from suburbs far away just to see what showed up on the floor that week. One shopper once found a designer perfume worth over a hundred dollars selling for ten.
Another walked out with a working musical instrument at a price that seemed like a mistake. The range of what lands here is genuinely hard to predict, and that unpredictability is exactly what keeps people coming back.
From bridal gowns to vintage sports collectibles, the inventory shifts constantly, and the color-coded discount system makes every visit feel like a fresh opportunity.
What MyThriftStores St. Paul Actually Is
MyThriftStores St. Paul sits at 1657 Rice St, St Paul, MN 55117, and it has been a community shopping anchor in this neighborhood since before it carried its current name. Long-time shoppers remember when this same building operated as Unique Thrift back in the 1990s, and the sense of community loyalty has carried forward through every name change and ownership shift.
The store is large, well-organized, and stocked with a rotating inventory that covers almost every category you can think of. Electronics, clothing, kitchen goods, furniture, jewelry, puzzles, pet supplies, and sports collectibles all share space under one roof.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 8 PM, with Sunday hours from 11 AM to 5 PM. The parking lot is spacious and shared with neighboring businesses, making it easy to pop in without circling the block.
The Color Tag Discount System That Keeps Shoppers Hooked
There are thrift stores that mark things down occasionally, and then there is MyThriftStores, where the discount system has become a legitimate reason people plan their week around shopping trips. The store runs a rotating color tag deal where three different colored tags are discounted each day at 25%, 50%, or 75% off the listed price.
Regulars who know the system shop strategically. If a jacket is priced a little higher than expected, a shopper might return on the day that color goes to 75% off and walk away paying almost nothing.
It rewards patience and repeat visits in a way that feels genuinely rewarding rather than gimmicky.
Holiday sales push discounts even further, sometimes dropping everything in the store to 50% off. For anyone hunting specific categories like clothing or home goods, timing a visit around these sales can make a serious difference in what you spend.
Sports Memorabilia and the Thrill of the Hunt
Sports fans with a collector’s mindset tend to gravitate toward the memorabilia section, and MyThriftStores does not disappoint. Jerseys, pennants, trading cards, signed photos, and team merchandise cycle through the store regularly, reflecting the passionate sports culture of the Twin Cities area.
The unpredictability is part of the appeal. You genuinely do not know if today’s haul will include a vintage Minnesota Vikings jersey or a framed autograph that someone’s basement no longer has room for.
Resellers who frequent the store specifically mention finding sports items that sold for strong profits on platforms like eBay.
The best strategy is to visit consistently and early in the week when new inventory tends to appear on the floor. Regular shoppers develop a sharp eye for what is underpriced, and in a store this size, overlooked gems do surface.
The community of regulars here openly celebrates each other’s finds, which adds a warm social layer to the hunt.
Electronics You Can Actually Test Before Buying
One of the most frustrating parts of buying secondhand electronics is not knowing whether something works until you get home. MyThriftStores addresses this directly by allowing customers to test electronics in the store before purchasing, which is a bigger deal than it sounds.
Shoppers have found working musical instruments, kitchen appliances, and tech gadgets at prices well below retail. Knowing you can plug something in and confirm it functions before handing over money removes a lot of the risk that usually comes with thrift store electronics shopping.
The electronics section draws a steady crowd of resellers, hobbyists, and practical shoppers alike. A functioning speaker or a working stand mixer at thrift store prices is a real find, and the test-before-you-buy policy makes those purchases feel much safer.
It is one of the specific reasons regulars cite when explaining why they prefer this store over nearby competitors.
The Jewelry Counter and What It Holds
The jewelry counter at MyThriftStores is a dedicated glass display case that holds a rotating selection of rings, necklaces, earrings, and bracelets. Unlike the open shelves in the rest of the store, the jewelry section requires asking a staff member to unlock the case, which gives it a slightly more curated feel.
Shoppers have found pieces that looked purely costume at first glance but turned out to carry real value once examined more closely. Sterling silver, vintage brooches, and beaded sets show up unpredictably, which makes the counter worth checking even if jewelry is not normally your focus.
Prices in the jewelry case vary, and like the rest of the store, applying a color tag discount on the right day can bring a piece down significantly. The counter draws dedicated browsers who visit specifically to check what has rotated in since their last trip, treating it almost like a mini antique case tucked inside a larger store.
Clothing for Every Size, Age, and Style
The clothing section at MyThriftStores is one of the largest parts of the store, with racks covering kids, women, and men across a wide range of sizes and styles. Shoppers have found everything from casual everyday basics to formal gowns, winter coats, and athletic wear, all rotating through as donations arrive.
Pricing on clothing has drawn mixed reactions from shoppers. Some dresses have been tagged above what similar items cost new at discount retailers, which frustrates bargain hunters.
The color tag discount system helps significantly here, since a 50% or 75% off tag can bring even higher-priced pieces into reasonable territory.
Children’s clothing tends to be a strong category, with a wide selection at prices that make sense for items kids outgrow quickly. Shoppers who focus on the kids’ section consistently report finding quality pieces at genuinely low prices, making it one of the more reliable parts of the clothing floor for families watching their budget.
Home Goods, Kitchen Finds, and the Knick-Knack Aisle
Walk past the clothing racks and the store opens up into a sprawling section of home goods that regulars describe as genuinely affordable. Kitchen appliances, sets of dishes, glassware, small decorative items, and the kind of random objects that make thrift shopping fun all compete for shelf space here.
Puzzles, picture frames, candles, vases, and seasonal decorations rotate through constantly. Shoppers who focus on this section rather than clothing consistently report finding prices that feel fair and sometimes surprisingly low compared to what similar items cost at discount home stores.
The knick-knack and decorative aisle draws a particular type of shopper, one who enjoys the visual randomness of not knowing what will appear next. A ceramic figurine sits next to a vintage clock next to a set of mixing bowls, and somewhere in that mix is usually something worth taking home.
This section rewards slow, unhurried browsing more than anywhere else in the store.
Furniture, Bedding, and the Bigger Finds
Beyond the smaller items, MyThriftStores carries a selection of larger household goods including blankets, weighted blankets, sheets, towels, and occasionally furniture pieces. For anyone furnishing an apartment on a budget or looking for extra bedding without paying full retail, this section is worth a dedicated look.
Weighted blankets in particular have shown up here at prices that represent significant savings over new retail cost. Given how expensive quality weighted blankets can be, finding one in good condition at a thrift store price is a practical win for shoppers who know what they are looking at.
The furniture and larger goods inventory changes less predictably than the smaller items, so it takes more patience. But shoppers who visit consistently report that worthwhile pieces do surface, and the size of the store means there is usually more to see in this category than at a smaller thrift operation down the street.
The Reseller Community That Calls This Place Home
A quiet but active community of resellers treats MyThriftStores as a regular sourcing stop. eBay sellers, vintage resellers, and online marketplace flippers visit on a weekly schedule, often on specific days when they know new stock tends to appear on the floor.
What makes this store particularly useful for resellers is the combination of high inventory volume and the color tag discount system. Buying an item at 75% off and selling it online for a profit is a straightforward equation, and the store’s wide variety means resellers across different niches, sports, fashion, electronics, home decor, can all find something worth picking up.
The reseller regulars have built a genuine social scene around their shared visits. Long-time shoppers report friendly exchanges, tips about overlooked finds, and a community atmosphere that turns a routine shopping trip into something closer to a social outing.
That kind of repeat engagement says something real about what this store has built over the years.
Practical Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Visit
A few habits separate the occasional browser from the shopper who consistently walks out with great finds. Arriving early in the week, particularly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, tends to align with when fresh inventory hits the floor at MyThriftStores.
Getting there early in the day also helps before other regulars have worked through the new stock.
Check the store’s color tag schedule before you go. Knowing which colors are discounted that day helps you prioritize what to look at first and whether it is worth holding off on a purchase until the right discount day arrives.
The 75% off days in particular can make previously overpriced items genuinely worth buying.
Bring a bag or basket since the store no longer uses traditional shopping carts. The store is open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 8 PM and Sunday from 11 AM to 5 PM, giving you plenty of scheduling flexibility to plan around the best discount days.
Why Locals Keep Coming Back Year After Year
There is a reason some shoppers have been visiting MyThriftStores monthly for over a decade. The store sits in a neighborhood that has a strong sense of community identity, and the store itself has become part of that fabric in a way that newer thrift chains rarely manage.
The rotating inventory keeps things fresh. No two visits look the same, and the combination of unpredictable stock and a discount system that rewards loyalty gives regulars a genuine reason to return consistently.
For many shoppers, the store is not just a place to save money but a weekly ritual that connects them to a familiar community of fellow browsers.
The location on Rice Street, with its spacious shared parking lot and neighboring businesses, makes a visit easy to fold into a larger errand run. That convenience, combined with the genuine variety of what you might find on any given day, is ultimately what keeps this place on the regular rotation for so many St. Paul shoppers.
Share this story
