Some of the best food finds in Oklahoma hide down gravel county roads, behind plain storefronts you might drive right past. You step inside expecting a quick stop and walk out with a box full of fried pies, thick-cut bologna, and jars of homemade jam.
These Amish and Mennonite bulk food stores are where smart shoppers fill their pantries without emptying their wallets. Grab a cooler, because once you see the shelves, you will want to take home more than you planned.
1. Troyer’s Discount Grocery, Oklahoma, Coalgate
Out on County Road 1730, past fields and fence lines, sits a grocery that feels like a secret the locals have kept to themselves. Troyer is a classic Amish family name, and the shelves here back it up with Amish-made breads, cheeses, and sweets.
The homemade fried pies are the first thing many shoppers grab, and for good reason. Next come the jellies and jams, lined up in bright rows that make picking just one nearly impossible.
Meat is a big draw too. The selection is large and the prices are friendly, which makes stocking the freezer feel less like a chore and more like a win.
Bulk goods and fresh produce round out the trip.
Staff here are warm and genuinely care about the folks coming through the door. Hours run Monday through Saturday, 9 AM to 5:30 PM, with Sundays closed.
Saturdays get busy, so a weekday visit gives you more elbow room and on-site parking is easy.
2. Amish Cheese House, Oklahoma, Chouteau
Bring a cooler. That single piece of advice sums up a trip to this Chouteau favorite, where the deli case alone can fill your back seat.
And if you forget one, freezer bags are sold right at the store.
Chouteau is home to a sizable Amish community, along with some Mennonite families, and the goods here come straight from those local households. Specialty cheeses take center stage, joined by lunch meats, scrapple, and homemade jellies and jams.
What sets this stop apart is its everything-under-one-roof setup. A deli, bakery, gift shop, and bulk food area share the space, and homemade ice cream waits for anyone needing a cool treat before the drive home.
Dried soup mixes and snacks make easy pantry fillers.
Find it at 101 S Chouteau Ave, open weekdays 9 AM to 6 PM and Saturdays until 5 PM. Saturday afternoons are the busiest stretch.
3. Ropps Hitching Post, Oklahoma, Chouteau
Some shoppers happily drive 45 minutes each way, every single week, just to fill up here. That kind of loyalty says plenty about a little store tucked along the country roads of Chouteau’s Amish farm settlement.
Ropp is a family name with deep Anabaptist roots, and the store keeps things practical. Think meats, canned goods, and dairy at prices that make a weekly haul worthwhile.
No fancy displays or frills, just a wide variety of affordable food and bulk items. It is the kind of place budget-minded families build their grocery routine around.
Hours are Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM, and Saturday from 8:30 AM to 4 PM. Weekday mornings are calm, while Saturdays bring the crowds.
4. Amish Country Store & Restaurant, Oklahoma, Muskogee
Breakfast first, shopping second. That is the winning game plan at this Muskogee spot, where a cozy restaurant and a well-stocked Amish store sit side by side.
On the dining side, homemade Amish bread turns burgers and chicken salad sandwiches into something special. Momma Yoder’s Meatloaf, chicken and dumplings, blueberry pancakes, and big biscuits with gravy keep plates full, usually for $10 to $20 a person.
Cross over to the store and the hunt begins. Shelves hold pickled eggs, okra chips, bologna, jars, snacks, and a huge spread of homemade fudge.
You will even spot drinks from Amish areas in Pennsylvania.
Open Monday through Thursday 8 AM to 3:30 PM and Friday and Saturday until 4:30 PM. Parking is free and plentiful, and kids are welcome with their own menu.
5. Martin House Country Store, Oklahoma, Davis
Heading south on US-77 toward the Arbuckle Mountains? Pull over in Davis, because this country store carries a little bit of just about everything.
Warm cinnamon rolls and fried pies lead the bakery lineup, and a cup of coffee makes them even better. Then comes the deli treasure: good old Amish bologna, which pairs nicely with any cheese from the case.
Shoppers watching their sugar will find a surprisingly big range of healthy and sugar-free items. Many products here are hard to track down anywhere else in the area.
Hours run Monday through Friday 8:30 AM to 5 PM and Saturday 9 AM to 4 PM. With a free lot and takeout available, it makes an easy road trip pit stop.
6. Three Rivers Pecans Llc, Oklahoma, Calera
Pecans and fudge in the same store sounds like a sweet tooth’s dream, and Calera delivers it. Located off the service road, this cheerful shop mixes a candy counter with an Amish-style pantry.
Fresh pecans and other nuts are the stars, perfect for holiday baking or a snack stash. Homemade fudge, cheeses, and artisanal snacks fill out the shelves.
Fun fact: Oklahoma ranks among the top pecan-producing states, so grabbing a bag here is about as local as it gets. Curbside pickup makes busy trips quick.
Open Monday through Saturday, mostly 9 AM to 5:30 PM, closing at 5 PM on Wednesdays.
Share this story
