A prime rib sandwich named after a famous downtown steakhouse sits on the menu at a Northside spot, and it keeps stealing the show. The meat comes tender, with au jus on the side for dipping.
That alone made me curious.
Then there’s the shrimp cocktail. It’s spicy, it’s famous, and the horseradish kick is the stuff of local legend in Indiana dining circles.
I like how this place blends old-school steakhouse polish with a relaxed neighborhood feel. Dark wood, soft lighting, and made-to-order bread pudding all share the same room.
I can’t imagine a better excuse for a long lunch or a special dinner. Sliders, fried green tomatoes, and French onion soup round things out nicely.
So what makes a sandwich worth the drive across town?
A Northside Steakhouse With Downtown Roots
Harry & Izzy’s calls the Northside of Indianapolis home, right near the busy Keystone Crossing area. It’s an upscale steakhouse that gives the classic chophouse formula a modern twist.
The menu goes beyond steaks, too. You’ll find chops, seafood, pasta, and even pizza, which makes the place feel friendlier than a stuffy old dining room.
A second location operates downtown, and the two share plenty of DNA. Some diners actually hop a few exits north when the downtown spot is booked solid.
That move often pays off. The Northside location is known for feeling less crowded, with plenty of parking to spare.
So why does a steakhouse earn a whole article? The answer lives between two slices of bread, plus a shrimp cocktail with real attitude.
Indiana has its share of beloved steak spots. Still, few manage to balance white-tablecloth polish with a menu that includes sliders and a famous sandwich.
Think of it as the dressed-up cousin who still loves comfort food. It knows how to impress without forgetting how to relax, and that balance shows up in nearly every corner of the menu.
The St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich Everyone Talks About
Sandwiches rarely headline a steakhouse menu. At Harry & Izzy’s, the St. Elmo prime rib sandwich manages exactly that, and it does it with confidence.
The name nods to St. Elmo Steak House, the iconic downtown Indianapolis institution. Both restaurants share family ties, so the tribute feels earned rather than borrowed.
What makes it special? Diners describe the prime rib as remarkably tender, served with au jus that’s flavorful enough to deserve its own fan club.
Fries usually ride along on the plate. That combo makes it a strong lunch pick when a full steak dinner feels like too much commitment.
Some guests split it with a friend alongside a pasta dish. It’s a smart strategy for sampling more of the menu without leaving uncomfortably full.
Work travelers seem to love it too. A sandwich this good turns a quick business lunch into the highlight of an otherwise ordinary trip.
Here’s my take: if a restaurant puts this much care into its sandwich, the rest of the kitchen probably knows what it’s doing. The steaks back that theory up nicely.
That Famous Shrimp Cocktail And Its Fiery Sauce
Horseradish lovers, this one’s for you. The shrimp cocktail is easily the most talked-about dish at Harry & Izzy’s, and the sauce is the reason.
It’s a spicy cocktail sauce loaded with horseradish heat. The kind that wakes up your sinuses and makes you laugh about it afterward.
Not into the burn? You can ask for the sauce on the side, which lets you control the intensity one dunk at a time.
Even non-seafood eaters have praised the sauce itself. That says a lot about how much flavor is packed into that little bowl of red.
The recipe connects back to the St. Elmo legacy downtown, where a similar cocktail became an Indianapolis legend. Ordering it here feels like tasting a piece of local food history.
Many tables order it as a starter without even glancing at the menu. Some groups order two, which seems wise when everyone wants more than one shrimp.
Fair warning: once you try it, ordinary cocktail sauce may seem pretty tame. That’s a risk worth taking.
Steaks With Toppings Worth Bragging About
Medium rare, cooked just right, with a pat of horseradish gorgonzola butter melting on top. That’s one of the signature moves at this Indianapolis steakhouse.
The menu covers the classics, including filet, ribeye, and New York strip. Each one can be dressed up with a topping that adds serious personality.
Filet Oscar style is a luxurious option. It comes crowned with lump crab, asparagus, and béarnaise for a rich but balanced bite.
There’s also the ribeye Izzy style, served with an orange butter sauce and a bold peppery kick. It’s a fun twist for anyone tired of plain steak.
Smaller appetites can grab an eight-ounce filet. It proves you don’t need a giant slab of beef to enjoy a top-tier dinner.
Sides deserve respect here as well. Brussels sprouts and green beans earn attention, and some diners argue the sides nearly outshine the steaks.
Harry & Izzy’s clearly takes its beef seriously. Yet those creative toppings keep things playful instead of predictable, which is exactly the modern twist the place promises.
Starters That Could Steal Dinner
Grilled slab bacon as an appetizer? Yes, and it’s every bit as indulgent as it sounds.
The starter list at Harry & Izzy’s is packed with temptations. Fried green tomatoes bring a Southern touch, while crab beignets add a crispy seafood surprise.
Sliders are another big hit. Filet and fried chicken versions both get strong praise, and they’re perfect for sharing around the table.
Then there’s the seared ahi tuna. It arrives with a dipping sauce good enough that some people call it a meal on its own.
French onion soup holds a loyal following too. At least one out-of-towner returned twice in a single trip just for a bowl.
Prime beef meatballs round out the lineup nicely. They’re described as tender and light rather than dense, which is a happy surprise.
Calamari and lobster sacchetti also appear on the radar. Honestly, you could build an entire evening out of small plates and never feel like you missed anything.
My advice? Order with friends so everyone can taste a little of everything.
Pasta, Pizza, And Seafood For The Non-Steak Crowd
Not everybody wants steak, and that’s perfectly fine here. Harry & Izzy’s makes sure the rest of the table eats just as happily.
Pasta gets real attention on the menu. Radiatore with lemon chicken offers a bright, zesty flavor, while rigatoni and penne cover the comfort side.
The chicken Alfredo earns enthusiastic praise for being creamy and full of flavor. It’s a crowd-pleaser for anyone craving something familiar.
Pizza might seem like an odd fit for a steakhouse. Yet the Tuscan pizza shows up as a favorite starter to share before the main event.
Seafood fans have choices too. Grilled salmon, flaky cod, and rotating daily specials like monkfish give fish lovers something new to try.
The Caprese salad keeps things fresh, with tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and a balsamic drizzle. A Caesar and a generous house salad are also available.
Variety like this matters for families and mixed groups. Picky eaters and adventurous diners can sit side by side without anyone settling for second best.
Bread Pudding Made To Order Is Worth The Wait
Patience pays off at dessert time. The bread pudding at Harry & Izzy’s is made to order, so servers often give a heads-up that it takes a little longer.
Nobody seems to mind the wait. It arrives fresh and warm, finished with a sweet drizzle on top that adds another layer of flavor.
It’s easily the most famous dessert in the house. Birthday groups, date-night couples, and first-timers all seem to end up ordering it.
Need a backup plan? The brownie à la mode gets plenty of love, and a strawberry crème brûlée has made fans as well.
Smart diners order the bread pudding early in the meal. That way it lands right as the plates are cleared.
Celebrating something special? The restaurant has allowed guests to bring in their own celebration cake, which is a thoughtful touch for big occasions.
I believe dessert should feel like a reward. Here, it feels like the grand finale of a very good show.
Dark Wood, Soft Lighting, And A Lively Hum
Low lights and dark wood set the mood the moment you sit down. The dining room at Harry & Izzy’s feels warm, polished, and quietly energetic.
Comfortable seating and soft lighting create a classic steakhouse vibe. Still, the space carries a neighborhood buzz that keeps things from feeling formal or stiff.
One practical tip: the dining room can run a bit cool. Packing a light wrap is a smart idea if you get chilly easily.
Outdoor seating is available too. It’s a nice option when Indiana weather cooperates on a pleasant afternoon or evening.
The holidays bring extra sparkle. The restaurant has transformed into a festive North Pole setup with Christmas decorations and a photo spot.
That seasonal version runs on a limited menu. So check ahead if you’re craving something specific during the holiday season.
Overall, the setting strikes a sweet spot. It’s dressy enough for an anniversary yet relaxed enough for a casual weekday lunch with a coworker.
Service That Makes First-Timers Feel Like Regulars
Great food gets you through the door. Great service is what brings people back, and Harry & Izzy’s seems to understand that well.
Servers are known for being knowledgeable without being pushy. They offer clear recommendations and pace courses so conversation flows naturally.
Dietary needs are taken seriously. Staff have gone out of their way to check details when a guest had a dairy allergy.
Drinks get refilled without anyone asking. Small touches like that make an evening feel easy and cared for.
The space works for many kinds of gatherings. Families, anniversary couples, and business groups all find it a comfortable fit.
Large parties are welcome too. Just know that big groups can raise the volume if you’re hoping for a quiet date night.
The bread service also earns a mention here. It arrives fresh and buttery, setting a generous tone before the first course even lands.
Hospitality like this turns an ordinary dinner into a celebration. It’s no wonder so many birthdays end up here.
Hours, Dress Code, And Getting There
Planning is simple. Harry & Izzy’s sits at 4050 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, close to Keystone Crossing on the city’s Northside.
The doors open at 11 AM every day. Monday through Thursday, service runs until 10 PM.
Friday and Saturday stretch later, closing at 11 PM. Sunday wraps up a little earlier at 9 PM.
Lunch is a great way to try the prime rib sandwich. Dinner, meanwhile, is prime time for steaks and that made-to-order bread pudding.
Reservations are a smart move, especially on weekends. The upscale setting also means it’s best to dress a bit nicer than usual.
Budget-wise, expect classic steakhouse pricing. It’s a splurge, but many diners feel the quality matches the bill.
Parking is plentiful, which is a relief compared with downtown. Traveling around Indiana or visiting for a big convention?
A short drive north can save you the hassle of a packed city dining room.
Why This Sandwich Deserves A Spot On Your Calendar
Some meals blur together. Others stick with you, and Harry & Izzy’s lands firmly in the second group.
The prime rib sandwich is the quiet star. Tender beef, savory au jus, and a proud St. Elmo connection make it worth a special trip.
Add that fiery shrimp cocktail and the warm bread pudding. Suddenly you’ve got a meal that hits every note from spicy to sweet.
The menu’s range makes it a strong pick for nearly any group. Steak lovers, pasta fans, and seafood seekers all leave satisfied.
It also works for many occasions. Business lunches, family birthdays, and romantic anniversaries all fit naturally in the dark-wood dining room.
Is it a splurge? Yes, but it’s the kind that feels thoughtful instead of flashy.
Indiana has plenty of places to grab a good steak. Few deliver a sandwich this memorable alongside such polished service.
So the next time you’re near Keystone Crossing and hungry, consider swinging by. That sandwich might just become your new favorite reason to visit Indianapolis.
Share this story
