Some of the best meals in Wisconsin hide inside buildings you could drive past a hundred times without a second glance. This one sits in an old converted house just outside Milwaukee, with a front porch, a wraparound counter, and a short menu built around one famous idea.
The burger here comes topped with real Wisconsin butter, and the recipe has barely changed since the 1930s. Stick around to learn why people plan road trips around a stool at this tiny counter.
A Converted House on Port Washington Road
Solly’s Grille sits at 4629 N Port Washington Rd, Glendale, WI 53212, just north of Milwaukee in Wisconsin. From the street, it looks more like a home than a restaurant.
That is because it is an old house conversion. Guests enter through the front porch and land right at the counter, where the cooks and servers work in the middle of everything.
The spot is listed as a hamburger restaurant, and the label fits. The menu leans on Wisconsin-sourced American fare, with the signature butter burger leading the way.
Getting here is simple. The building sits close to major highway exits, so it is not tucked away in some hard-to-reach corner.
Plenty of parking spaces surround the property too, which helps on busy days. It is also just up the street from the Sprecher soda operation, a handy landmark for first-timers.
Small outside, big on reputation inside, the story only gets better from here.
Nearly Ninety Years of Flat-Top History
Back in 1936, the butter burger started hitting the flat-top here, and it has not stopped since. That is close to ninety years of the same core idea.
The restaurant calls itself the home of the original butter burger. Locals treat it as a true Milwaukee landmark, the kind of place people take out-of-town relatives.
Here is a fun detail. The restaurant has moved over the years, but the counter itself is the original bar, carried along to the current building.
Longtime owner Joe Bartolotta remains part of the story, and regulars still point out his favorite seat at the counter. His legacy is woven into how the place runs today.
Plenty of diners pretend to be old. This one simply is.
The decor reflects that long run, with older, antique touches that stay clean and cared for rather than dusty. History here is lived in, not staged for show.
The Butter Burger Itself
Butter on a burger sounds like a joke until the plate lands. At Solly’s, it is the whole point.
The patties are made from 100 percent sirloin, fresh and never frozen. Cooks smash them on the flat-top, then finish them with real Wisconsin butter and the signature stewed onions.
The butter soaks into the toasted bun, and some diners are surprised by how generous the portion is. A few find it too much, which is why locals suggest asking for light butter.
Cheese is a popular add-on, especially among self-described cheeseheads. Some regulars say the burger is good enough to skip ketchup entirely.
Size is modest, so bigger appetites sometimes order two. Other options include a mushroom Swiss burger on a pretzel bun and a jalapeño-style Peño burger.
Health food it is not. A Wisconsin tradition served the same way for decades, absolutely.
Malts in a Steel Can
Save room, or better yet, plan for it from the start. The malts at Solly’s earn almost as much chatter as the burgers.
Chocolate malts are a favorite, and they arrive thick. The extra stays in the steel mixer cup, so each order comes with a bonus refill.
The hot fudge shake gets special mention because the fudge is blended in rather than simply drizzled on top. Banana malts also have their fans.
Many diners order a shake alongside the meal instead of after it. Given the size, that approach makes sense.
Root beer floats are on the menu too. There is even red cream soda on tap, a nod to the soda fountain spirit of the place.
Classic diners and malts belong together, and this counter keeps that pairing alive. Oversized, old-fashioned, and made the way they have been for generations, these drinks are not an afterthought.
Curds, Crinkle Fries and Other Sidekicks
No trip through Wisconsin is complete without cheese curds. Solly’s serves them, and they are a common first-time order for travelers.
The crinkle cut fries draw steady praise for arriving hot and fresh. Many tables share a plate between them.
Onion rings are another option, with a solid crunch that avoids being greasy. Solly chips round out the side choices.
The menu stretches beyond burgers more than some expect. Grilled cheese works well for kids, and the chili has its own following.
A steak tenderloin sandwich and a BLT are available for those who want something different. Friday brings a fish fry, a beloved Wisconsin custom.
Dessert lovers should look for the homemade pies, served warm. They are a fine way to stretch a visit a little longer.
Sides here are not filler. They are part of why the meal feels like a complete Wisconsin experience.
Breakfast on Fridays and Saturdays
Early risers get a small reward at the end of the week. On Fridays and Saturdays, the doors open at 7 a.m.
Those early hours bring breakfast into the picture. Hashbrowns come up often among regulars, making them a natural place to start.
Plenty of first-time guests leave planning a return trip just to try the morning menu. It is a different side of a place mostly known for lunch and dinner.
Morning visits can also mean an easier time grabbing a stool. Weekend lunch rushes tend to fill the counter quickly.
From Tuesday through Thursday, the opening time shifts to 10:30 a.m., so breakfast plans should center on the later part of the week.
A butter burger at breakfast is not off the table either, for the truly committed. Either way, the weekend mornings here offer a quieter look at a busy local institution.
Horseshoe Counters and Swivel Stools
Forget booths. Seating at Solly’s means horseshoe-shaped counters lined with swivel stools.
The counters wrap around the cooks and wait staff, so every meal comes with a front-row view of the flat-top. Guests watch their food come together from start to finish.
Space is tight. The dining room holds roughly 25 people, and there are no regular tables indoors.
A few outdoor seats exist for warmer days. Still, the counter is the true heart of the experience.
Some compare the feel to eating in a grandparent’s living room. Others describe it as a real working diner rather than a themed one.
That setup encourages conversation. Strangers chat with neighbors and staff, giving it an old-school, friendly community spirit.
Restrooms are not available, so plan accordingly before arriving. Small quirks like that come with a building this old and this cozy.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
Warm welcomes are a big part of the Solly’s routine. Many guests are greeted at the door and thanked on the way out.
Servers are known for being quick and easygoing, the classic diner style. One staffer, Steven, gets frequent shout-outs for keeping things running smoothly even when short-handed.
Families with kids tend to feel at home. Staff have been noted as attentive to food allergies, including a peanut allergy, without making a fuss.
The crowd is a lively mix. Regulars sit beside tourists, and people of all ages share the counter.
Busy stretches can slow things down, though. Some guests have waited a while for orders to be taken, and there is no formal host system during rushes.
Patience pays off. Once seated, most find the chatter and attention part of the charm.
It is hospitality without polish, and that seems to be exactly the point.
Hours, Waits and Game-Day Plans
Timing matters at a place this small. Solly’s is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
Tuesday through Thursday, hours run from 10:30 a.m. to 7 p.m. Friday and Saturday stretch from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Evening diners should note that early 7 p.m. close. Late cravings will need a backup plan.
Waits are common, especially on weekends, since seating is limited. Arriving at off-peak times can help.
Some guests find prices a little high for the burger’s size. Others feel the history and quality justify the cost.
The location makes it a smart stop before a Brewers game in Milwaukee. Highway access is easy, and parking is plentiful.
More details are available on the official site, sollysbutterburgers.com. Checking ahead before a long drive is always a good habit.
Plan around the schedule, and the visit goes smoothly.
Worth a Stool and a Detour
Awards rarely find their way to tiny counters in converted houses. Solly’s earned a James Beard America’s Classics honor anyway.
That recognition celebrates restaurants rooted in their communities, and this spot fits the bill. It does one thing, does it the same way, and has done so since 1936.
Not everyone falls for the butter-heavy style. Fans of gourmet burgers may find it too simple or too rich.
For anyone curious about a true Wisconsin tradition, though, it is a must-try at least once. The history alone makes it memorable.
Families, road-trippers, sports fans and longtime locals all seem to find a seat here eventually.
Order the original with stewed onions, grab a malt, and maybe ask for light butter on a first visit. Then settle onto a swivel stool and watch the flat-top work its decades-old routine.
Some traditions are simply worth the drive.
Share this story
