One New Jersey bakery opens its doors at 4:30 in the morning, and custard tarts are the headliner. That early start tells me somebody takes this tiny pastry very seriously.
The pastel de nata is small enough to hold in two fingers. Yet it packs a crackly, layered shell and a creamy egg custard center with a toasty top.
I love that these tarts often show up in plain neighborhood shops. Think bakery cases next to deli counters, breakfast sandwiches, and strong coffee.
Nothing fancy on the outside, then one bite changes the whole morning.
New Jersey has a deep Portuguese baking tradition, and five spots below prove it in buttery detail. Some sit on busy avenues, and one hides along a highway.
So which one earns your first flaky crumb, and how many tarts can you honestly carry home?
1. Pinho’s Bakery

Some bakeries pick a lane, and Pinho’s happily ignores that rule. You’ll find pastries, breads, cakes, and a deli counter making sandwiches under one roof.
Still, the natas are the reason to plan this stop. These Portuguese egg custard cups sit at the heart of a big lineup of Portuguese treats.
Family-run and rooted in Roselle, the shop feels like a true neighborhood bakery. It’s the kind of place where you grab bread for dinner and sneak a tart for the car.
Sweet tooth running wild? The dessert case also features custard cakes, banana and strawberry cake, bread pudding, pies, and chocolate mousse cake.
Birthday cakes are on the menu too, which makes Pinho’s handy for celebrations. Picture showing up with a cake and a box of natas, and suddenly you’re the favorite guest.
Early birds get rewarded here. Doors open at 5 AM Tuesday through Saturday, and 6 AM on Sunday.
Breakfast sandwiches and coffee make a morning visit even easier to justify. Grab one savory item and one custard cup, and call it balance.
Weekends bring the biggest crowds, especially Saturday and Sunday mornings. Weekday evenings tend to be calmer if you want a relaxed browse of the cases.
The bakery is closed Mondays, so plan around that. Free lot parking and free street parking keep the trip simple.
Address: 1027 Chestnut St, Roselle, NJ 07203
2. Pão da Casa

Budget-friendly and buttery is a fine combination. Pão da Casa in Union keeps prices low while turning out fresh baked goods that punch well above their cost.
The pasteis de nata here lean flaky. They’re also known for a custard that’s not overly sweet, which is great news if sugary pastries usually wear you out.
Empanadas share the spotlight in a big way. Pair a savory empanada with a custard tart, and you’ve built a snack plan that covers both cravings.
Coffee rounds out the experience, naturally. A tart and a cup make an easy breakfast for anyone heading through Union on a weekday.
Speaking of early starts, the bakery opens at 5 AM Monday through Friday. Weekend hours begin at 7 AM, with doors closing at 4 PM daily.
That afternoon closing time matters. Show up after work and you’ll be staring at a locked door, which is a sad way to meet a craving.
Delivery is available, so you can bring the tarts to you. That’s a dangerous option to know about on a slow Saturday.
Visiting in person? Paid street parking is the setup here, so keep that in mind before you pull up on Stuyvesant Avenue.
Quick stops are the name of the game. Order, grab your box, and maybe eat the first tart before you reach the car.
Address: 945 Stuyvesant Ave., Union, NJ 07083
3. Flavors of Portugal Cafe

Route 22 isn’t where most people expect a slice of Lisbon. Yet Flavors of Portugal Cafe sits right along the highway in White House Station, serving Portuguese pastries with real pride.
The menu calls its star the Pastel de Belem. It’s a nod to the Lisbon neighborhood linked to the famous custard tart’s history.
Expect a rich custard inside a flaky crust. The tarts here are often served with a warm, creamy center that isn’t overly sweet.
Unlike some grab-and-go counters, this spot invites you to stay a while. The room is casual and quiet, with free Wi-Fi for anyone sneaking in some laptop work.
Hungry for more than dessert? Breakfast and lunch sandwiches give the visit some heft, and the coffee holds its own.
Chocolate fans should peek at the chocolate mousse. It’s a smooth, rich option for anyone who wants a second treat after the tart.
Families are welcome, and the cafe even accepts reservations. That’s a nice perk for a small group planning a pastry brunch in Hunterdon County.
Parking is easy, with an on-site lot and street spaces nearby. You won’t have to circle the block hunting for a spot.
One catch: the cafe closes Mondays and Tuesdays. Wednesday through Sunday, it runs from 8 AM to 4 PM.
Address: 422 US-22, White House Station, NJ 08889
4. North Avenue Bakery

A 4:30 AM opening time says a lot about a bakery. North Avenue Bakery in Elizabeth fires up before sunrise, and the custard tarts are a big reason why.
Here, pasteis de nata are made fresh throughout the day. That means your afternoon tart can be just as fresh as the first batch of the morning.
Family-owned and mom-and-pop in style, the shop carries the feel of a classic Portuguese bakery. Elizabeth has long been a center of Portuguese life in New Jersey, and this place fits right in.
Want the full experience? Order a galao, the Portuguese coffee made with espresso and plenty of milk, served in a tall glass.
The galao and a custard tart make a smart pair. One is creamy and mellow, while the other brings crisp layers and rich custard.
Espresso drinkers are covered too. The coffee program is a real strength, not an afterthought next to the pastry case.
Sandwiches and other pastries expand the menu beyond sweets. You could easily turn a tart run into a full breakfast.
Late hours set this bakery apart from others on the list. It stays open until 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 8 PM on Sunday.
Mornings get busy, especially Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. Evenings tend to be quieter, and free street parking and Wi-Fi add convenience.
Address: 1034 North Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201
5. Canela Bakery

Specializing in one pastry takes confidence. Canela Bakery in Newark puts the pastel de nata front and center, and the menu proudly lists its Original Pastel de Nata.
Wilson Avenue sits in the Ironbound, Newark’s well-known Portuguese neighborhood. Opening a nata-focused bakery here means facing some serious hometown competition.
The tarts answer that challenge with a perfectly flaky crust and a rich, creamy custard. Simple pastry, done with focus, tends to win people over.
A friendly owner runs the shop, adding to its neighborhood charm. Small counters like this one often feel personal in the best way.
Night owls and early risers take note. Canela opens at 4 AM on weekdays and 5 AM on Saturday.
The busiest stretches actually land in the overnight and early morning hours. Afternoons are calmer, though the bakery closes at 2 PM.
That early finish means planning matters. Swing by in the morning so you’re not left dreaming about custard at 2:15.
Sundays are closed, so save this one for the workweek or Saturday. Free street parking makes a quick stop manageable.
Prices stay friendly, which makes grabbing a half dozen a little too easy. Coffee is on hand for a proper Portuguese breakfast.
Delivery is available as well. Still, eating one fresh right outside the shop feels like the most New Jersey way to finish this tart tour.
Address: 180 Wilson Ave, Newark, NJ 07105
Share this story

