Some of the best afternoons in Ohio start with a plain storefront and a bell that jingles when the door swings open. Step inside, and suddenly there are glass jars, penny-candy bins, and chocolate counters that look like they never left the 1950s.
Grandparents point and grin, kids grab paper bags, and everyone leaves with sticky fingers and a story. If you have a sweet tooth and a full tank of gas, these seven shops are worth the drive.
1. Wittich’s Candy Shop, Circleville, OH
Bragging rights do not come much bigger than this. Wittich’s Candy Shop on West High Street is known as the oldest family-owned candy store in the United States, and it sits right in the heart of downtown Circleville.
Walking through the door feels like stepping into a family photo album. The old-fashioned charm hits you first, followed by the smell of handmade chocolates lined up in neat rows behind the glass.
Then there is the soda fountain, serving classic treats the way your grandparents remember ordering them on a Saturday in town.
Plan for a quick stop, though you may linger longer than expected. Hours run Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM, and the shop is closed Sundays.
Free parking is available in a lot and along the street. Saturdays get busy, so a weekday morning offers a calmer look at those famous counters.
Curbside pickup is also offered.
2. Boyd’s Retro Candy Store, Toledo, OH
Three generations can shop the same shelves here and each one will find a childhood favorite. That is the magic of Boyd’s Retro Candy Store on Phillips Avenue in Toledo.
The selection reaches back further than most stores dare. You will spot the candy you grew up with, plus treats your parents traded on the playground, and even a few your grandparents bought with pocket change.
It turns a simple shopping trip into a family history lesson, one wrapper at a time.
Bottled sodas add another layer of fun. Rows of glass bottles in bright flavors make a perfect pairing with a bag of old-school sweets for the ride home.
Doors open Monday through Saturday from noon to 6 PM, and the store stays closed on Sundays. Friday and Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds.
For a slower browse, Monday afternoons tend to be the quietest window of the week.
3. Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop – Middletown, OH
Got a big family with very different cravings? Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop on Central Avenue in Middletown solves that problem with one word: buffet.
The signature candy buffet is the star of the show. Bulk containers and novelty jars stretch across the room, packed with the old-school sweets many Ohioans grew up munching.
Kids get to scoop and choose, while grandparents happily point out the classics they remember from corner stores decades ago.
Beyond candy, the shop pours craft sodas in all kinds of flavors and serves ice cream for anyone needing something cold. It is the kind of stop that makes an ordinary evening feel like a small celebration.
Hours are generous, running 10 AM to 9 PM Monday through Saturday and 10 AM to 7 PM on Sundays. Weekend afternoons and evenings fill up fast.
Mondays are usually the calmest, and delivery is offered too.
4. Marie’s Candies, West Liberty, OH
Back in 1956, a little candy shop opened its doors in West Liberty, and word spread across the countryside faster than gossip at a church picnic. Marie’s Candies earned its name with old-fashioned, high-quality confections, and that reputation still draws drivers down Zanesfield Road today.
West Liberty is a tiny village of under 2,000 people, which makes the shop feel even more like a hidden treasure. Inside, the counters and displays overflow with chocolates and traditional sweets.
You can pick from neat pre-boxed assortments or choose pieces straight from the counter.
Boxed candy makes an easy gift for birthdays or holiday visits with grandma. Counter candy is better for building your own sampler.
Marie’s is open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM and closed Sundays. Saturday mornings bring the biggest crowds, and parking is available in a nearby lot.
5. b.a. Sweetie Candy Company, Cleveland, OH
More than 4,500 items. Let that number sink in for a second, because b.a.
Sweetie Candy Company on Brookpark Road is not a corner shop. It is a full-blown candy superstore on Cleveland’s southwest side.
The aisles are organized like a sugar-powered map. There is a huge sugar-free section, a soda section, a chocolate and handmade candy area, and a spot for scooping by weight.
The bulk area even sells individual Pez and Smarties flavors, so you can load up on only your favorite color.
Classic vintage candies from past decades sit right beside modern treats, which keeps every age group busy. A soda shop rounds out the visit with a fizzy reward.
Hours run 10 AM to 7 PM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM to 5 PM on Sundays. Free on-site parking and free Wi-Fi make things easy.
Weekday mornings are the quietest.
6. Dietsch Brothers, Findlay, OH
Ask anyone in Findlay where to take the grandkids for a treat, and the answer usually comes back fast. Dietsch Brothers on West Main Cross Street is a hometown staple, famous for homemade ice cream and handcrafted chocolates.
Hand-scooped ice cream is the main event. Locals point to the banana split as the best in town, and real root beer floats bring back soda-counter memories.
Sundaes come in favorites like hot fudge, chocolate, and tin roof, and you can even take home a box of sixteen ice cream balls.
The candy side deserves equal attention. Chocolates, sherbet, and roasted nuts fill the shop, and prices feel like a steal.
Hours run Tuesday through Friday 9 AM to 9 PM, Saturday 10 AM to 9 PM, and Sunday noon to 5 PM. Mondays are closed.
Friday evenings get crowded, so morning visits move quicker.
7. Olympia Candy (Sweeties Olympia Treats), Strongsville, OH
Lunch and candy under one roof sounds like a kid’s dream plan, yet Olympia Candy on Pearl Road in Strongsville makes it real. Known locally as Sweeties Olympia Treats, the shop pairs a sweets counter with casual lunch and dinner options.
Old-time candy is the heartbeat of the place. Shelves hold the treats many moms and grandmas grew up with, so family trips often turn into a game of who remembers what.
Fudge, chocolate, popcorn, and craft soda add even more reasons to wander.
Then there is the ice cream. Flavors run from familiar to playful, including a creamy cotton candy option that is not overly sweet.
The shop opens 10 AM to 8 PM on weekdays and 11 AM to 8 PM on weekends. Free parking, free Wi-Fi, and delivery make it convenient.
Weekend afternoons are busiest, while mornings stay pleasantly calm.
Share this story
