Some of the best food in Illinois hides inside plain little strip malls you could drive past a hundred times. I almost did, until the smell of warm bread and a line spilling out the door made me pull over.
What I found was a tiny counter shop where the bagels taste like somebody actually cares. It is the kind of place you leave already planning your next trip back.
A Strip-Mall Counter on Touhy Avenue
Blink on West Touhy Avenue and you might miss it. New York Bagel & Bialy Corporation sits at 4714 W Touhy Ave in Lincolnwood, a quiet suburb just north of Chicago, tucked into a modest strip mall with a small parking lot out front.
From the outside, nothing shouts for attention. Inside, though, you find a snug counter shop turning out bagels, bialys, and deli sandwiches for a steady stream of hungry people from the moment the doors open.
The setup is simple. You line up, you order at the counter, and you head out with a warm paper bag that smells better than any car air freshener ever invented.
Some visitors note it works mostly as a take-out spot, which suits the grab-and-go crowd perfectly. Think of it as a neighborhood bakery and deli rolled into one tight, busy room where the bagels are clearly the main event.
Decades of Loyal Regulars
Ask around and you will hear stories that stretch back a long way. One regular says they started coming when they were about three years old.
Another has been stopping in for twenty to thirty years and claims the place has never missed a beat.
That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident. Families pass the habit down, and people who grew up nearby keep returning even after moving away.
Several longtime fans love bringing first-timers in just to watch their faces light up at the first bite.
Not every memory is rosy, of course. Some old-timers mention that staffing has changed and the shop used to run around the clock before posting new hours.
Still, the bagels themselves remain the anchor that keeps generations walking through that same door, ordering the same favorites, and arguing happily about which flavor wins.
Bagels Baked All Day Long
Six in the morning, and the ovens are already working. Doors open at 6 am every single day, so early risers can grab bagels while most of the neighborhood is still asleep.
Regulars point out that baking does not stop after breakfast. The shop keeps turning out fresh batches through the day, which is why an afternoon bagel can still arrive warm.
One visitor who grew up in New Jersey said it was the first place in the area that reminded them of real New York bagels.
Fans describe the ideal result: crunchy on the outside, soft and warm inside. One customer even noted the bagels stay soft a day or so later, which makes buying a bag to go a smart move.
Opinions do vary, and a few folks find them too fluffy, but the steady crowd suggests most people leave very happy.
The Bialy, Bagel’s Humble Cousin
Here is a fun bit of bakery trivia. A bialy looks a bit like a bagel, but it is not boiled and has no hole, just a shallow dip in the center usually filled with onion.
The name traces back to the Polish city of Bialystok.
It is right there in the shop name, and bialys come up again and again when people talk about this spot. For anyone who has only known bagels, ordering one is a small adventure in chewy, savory comfort.
Try one plain to taste the bread itself, or ask for a smear of cream cheese to balance that onion punch. Since the shop runs a huge selection, it is easy to grab a mix and compare side by side at home.
Picking a favorite between the two cousins might take several visits, and honestly, nobody will complain about the research.
Cream Cheese Worth Talking About
Prepare for a gloriously messy experience. Customers warn that the spreads here are applied generously, so a napkin or three will come in handy.
Cream cheese is one of the most talked-about items at the shop, and it is easy to see why. Chive cream cheese earns frequent praise, especially on an everything or cheddar bagel.
The veggie version gets called incredible by fans, and the lox spread, a salmon cream cheese, has its own loyal following.
One visitor said words could not describe how good the cream cheese tastes on the everything bagel. Others like to buy a medium container to take home with a bag of extras.
A few longtime customers feel the vegetable spread has changed a bit over the years, but plenty of newcomers still rave. Whichever flavor you choose, expect a thick, generous layer rather than a thin swipe.
Lox, Sable, and Smoked Fish
Picture a poppy seed bagel stacked with chive cream cheese, lox, tomato, red onion, capers, and cucumber. That is one longtime regular’s go-to order, and they call it phenomenal.
For smoked fish fans, this counter is a serious stop. The Lox Sandwich Regular is a popular pick, and sable also gets high marks from people who know their fish.
Whitefish salad and chopped liver sit among the deli choices too.
Experiences can differ. One visitor felt their lox sandwich, around $12.99, was too heavy on onions and tomato and light on fish, so it helps to say exactly how you want it built.
Ask for extra cream cheese or skip toppings you do not love. When it comes together right, a classic lox bagel here feels like a little trip to an old-school deli without leaving the suburbs.
Corned Beef, Pastrami, and the Reuben
Not a breakfast person? No problem.
The deli side of the menu holds its own, with corned beef and pastrami sandwiches ranking among the most mentioned items.
The Reuben bagel is a standout. One fan ordered it on a toasted sesame seed bagel with Muenster cheese and liked it so much they came back the very next day.
Another visitor called the tender Reuben a must-try.
Sandwiches are described as huge and reasonably priced, so splitting one is a real option. A tip from regulars: if you like your corned beef warm, say so when ordering.
There is also a pizza bagel that one happy customer called amazing, plus tuna and other classic fillings. The beauty of building these on a fresh bagel is the chew, which holds up to piles of meat far better than ordinary sandwich bread.
The New York Breakfast Sandwich
Breakfast sandwich lovers, this one is for you. Order the New York Breakfast on an everything bagel and you will understand why it keeps appearing in conversations about this shop.
One self-described breakfast bagel fan called it the best she had ever had, praising how fresh and warm the bagel was. A visitor who drove up from Andersonville on a Saturday morning ordered the same sandwich and left impressed by the price for the portion.
Sausage, egg, and cheese combinations are also available for those who like a classic. Small mix-ups can happen during busy rushes, like a sandwich landing on the wrong bagel, so double-check your bag before you leave.
Pair your sandwich with a hot coffee or a cold soda, find a spot in the car, and enjoy what many consider the perfect way to start a morning in Lincolnwood.
Rugelach, Pickles, and Dr. Brown’s
Save room for the extras. The dessert case is stocked with fresh-baked sweets, and the rugelach gets special love.
Raspberry, apricot, chocolate drizzle, and cinnamon raisin all have fans, and one customer happily bought two of each.
Pickles might sound like an afterthought, but a regular insists they are great and not to be missed. Crunchy and tangy, they cut right through a rich deli sandwich.
Then there is Dr. Brown’s soda, the classic deli drink. One first-timer tried the black cherry flavor and described it as light, refreshing, and not too fizzy, like a cross between cherry cola and a spicy soda.
Zero sugar options are available too. Grabbing a can and a pastry turns a quick bagel run into a full little feast, and it is a fun way to sample a deli tradition.
Long Lines and a Cozy, Busy Room
Yes, there will probably be a line. Long waits are one of the most talked-about parts of a visit, and the shop stays busy from morning to evening.
The good news is that it tends to move. Some guests ordered within about ten minutes on a Saturday, while others suggest planning for twenty to thirty minutes, longer when big orders pile up.
Staff juggle shouted orders behind the counter, and many visitors say they work fast under pressure.
Inside, the space is small and can feel tight when crowded. Some people love the mom and pop feel, while service experiences have been mixed lately, with a few longtime fans hoping for warmer counter manners.
Patience pays off here. Bring a friend, chat in line, and soak up that smell of baking bread drifting over everything.
It all adds to the old-school charm.
Hours, Prices, and Parking Tips
Plan ahead and the trip gets easier. Hours run 6 am to 7 pm Sunday through Thursday, stretching to 10 pm on Friday and Saturday.
Older listings mention 24-hour service, but posted hours have changed, so check before a late-night run. Call 847-677-9388 or visit the website for updates.
Prices feel friendly. One customer picked up three bagels with cream cheese, four extra bagels, three minis, and a medium tub of cream cheese for around 25 dollars.
Note that paying by card adds a 4 percent fee, so cash is handy.
Parking is a small lot with limited spaces, and it runs one way, so enter carefully. It can get tight during rushes.
The menu board may feel overwhelming at first, so peek at options while you wait in line and have your order ready.
Worth the Drive to Lincolnwood
So, should you make the trip? If you crave a bagel with real chew, generous spreads, and old deli flavor, the answer leans toward yes.
Fans come from Chicago neighborhoods, nearby suburbs, and even people who grew up out east chasing a taste of home. The shop is not fancy, and service can be hit or miss on a busy day, but the core of it, warm bagels pulled fresh throughout the day, keeps people loyal for decades.
Go early for the calmest experience, bring cash, and leave with an extra dozen for later. Try a bialy, grab some rugelach, and do not forget a pickle.
For Illinois food lovers who treasure unassuming local spots, this little Touhy Avenue counter feels like a secret worth sharing carefully, maybe with just a few good friends.
Share this story
