One dairy farm in Pennsylvania’s northern tier runs a self-serve store with no cashier, just an honor system and coolers filled with ice cream, cheese, milk, cottage cheese, baked goods, and other farm-made staples.
God’s Country Creamery in Ulysses makes small-batch ice cream from milk produced by its own herd, with flavors like Turtle Pond, Butter Hoof, Black Raspberry Pie, and Mint Mash.
The farm also produces artisan cheeses and other dairy products, making the roadside stop feel more like a working farm pantry than a typical ice cream shop.
A Farm Store Hidden on a Hillside in Potter County
The address is 439 Pushersiding Road, Ulysses, Pennsylvania 16948, and the drive there feels like the countryside is slowly pulling you further from everything familiar. The road narrows, the hills roll wider, and suddenly a modest metal barn-style building appears on a grassy slope in Potter County, part of the Pennsylvania Wilds region often called God’s Country.
This is God’s Country Creamery, a working dairy farm and self-serve store that operates seven days a week, year-round. The store opens as early as 5:30 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, which tells you something about the kind of community it serves.
There are no flashy signs or tourist traps here, just honest farm goods and a freezer full of small-batch ice cream waiting inside.
The setting alone is worth the trip. Lush hillsides stretch out in every direction, and on a clear summer day, the milking herd grazes peacefully across the slopes.
It feels less like a shopping stop and more like a reminder of what food used to look like before it came wrapped in plastic.
How a Dairy Farm Became a Community Creamery
The story of this creamery did not begin with ice cream. Back in 2008, the Bachman and Peangatelli families, including Mark, Melanie, Rachel, Eric, and Hannah, started making artisan cheese as a way to sustain their dairy farm and keep the operation financially viable.
It was a practical decision rooted in love for the land and the animals they cared for every day.
By late 2019, the farm had expanded into fluid raw milk sales, giving local customers direct access to fresh, unprocessed dairy. Then 2020 arrived with its disruptions, and instead of pulling back, the family pushed forward.
They added a commercial kitchen, began selling pasteurized milk, and launched their now-celebrated homemade ice cream line.
What could have been a crisis became a turning point. The creamery grew into something much bigger than a cheese operation, and the community responded with genuine enthusiasm.
The family’s willingness to adapt while staying true to their farm-first values is exactly what makes their story feel so worth telling.
The Cows Behind Every Scoop and Slice
Every pint of ice cream and every wedge of cheese at this creamery starts with the same group of hardworking animals grazing the hillsides outside. The herd is made up of three distinct breeds, each chosen for what they bring to the dairy operation.
Holsteins are the high-volume producers, Jerseys contribute milk that is rich in butterfat, and Brown Swiss offer milk that is especially well-suited for cheese-making.
What makes this herd feel different from a commercial operation is the level of personal attention each cow receives. Every animal has a name, and calves are typically named using the first letter of their mother’s name, a small tradition that speaks volumes about how the family views their animals.
Cow comfort is not just a phrase here; it shapes every decision about feeding, housing, and care.
Visitors in summer can watch the herd graze from the hillside and even meet the baby calves up close in their individual hutches. That kind of farm access is rarer than people realize, and it makes the ice cream taste just a little bit sweeter.
Ice Cream Flavors That Earn Their Unusual Names
Turtle Pond. Cow Mash.
Butter Hoof. Black Raspberry Pie.
These are not flavors you will find at a chain ice cream shop, and that is exactly the point. The homemade ice cream at this creamery launched in 2020 and quickly became the most talked-about item in the store, with more than twelve varieties available at any given time.
The ice cream is made in small batches using milk from the farm’s own herd, which means the base is as fresh as it gets. The result is a richness and depth of flavor that commercial brands rarely match.
Black Raspberry Pie and Key Lime draw repeat visitors, while Turtle Pond and Mint Mash have their own devoted fans who plan trips around restocking their freezers.
Sizes range from pints to half-gallons, making it easy to grab one for the road or load up for the week ahead. One practical tip worth knowing: bring a metal spoon, because the ice cream is dense enough to challenge even the sturdiest plastic utensil.
Thirteen Artisan Cheeses Made the Old-Fashioned Way
Long before the ice cream became a sensation, cheese was the craft that built this farm’s reputation. The creamery produces thirteen varieties of artisan raw milk cheese, all made directly on the property at Wellwyn Farm.
The lineup includes Caraway Havarti, Boondocks Cheddar, and Golden Harvest Gouda, each one developed with the specific qualities of the farm’s milk in mind.
Raw milk cheese carries a depth of flavor that pasteurized versions often cannot replicate, and the family is meticulous about making sure that quality comes through safely. Their process emphasizes clean raw milk, free from artificial growth hormones and antibiotic residue, with strict attention to cleanliness across every part of the operation.
The Havarti in particular has earned a loyal following among regular visitors.
For anyone new to raw milk cheese, this is an excellent place to start exploring. The variety is broad enough to satisfy a curious palate, and the freshness is immediately noticeable compared to what most grocery store shelves offer.
Cheese and a snack meat stick make a surprisingly satisfying road trip combination.
The Honor System Store That Runs on Trust
There is no cashier waiting at the counter inside this store. No scanner, no checkout line, no employee hovering nearby.
The entire operation runs on an honor system, and that simple fact tends to catch first-time visitors completely off guard. You walk in, browse the coolers and shelves, tally up what you want, and leave payment in cash or through Venmo.
The store is open every day of the week, year-round, with early morning hours starting at 5:30 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. That kind of access reflects a genuine trust in the community and in the visitors who make the trip out.
The store is well-organized and consistently clean, with coolers stocked with ice cream, cheese, raw milk, yogurt, cottage cheese, eggs, fresh produce, baked goods, and even frozen meats.
First-time visitors are sometimes surprised to find baked oatmeal, homemade bread, soups, and chocolate sheet cake alongside the dairy staples. The selection shifts with the seasons and what the kitchen is producing, which gives every visit a slightly different feel and a reason to come back soon.
Raw Milk, Cottage Cheese, and Why People Drive Hours for Both
Raw milk is not easy to find in most parts of Pennsylvania, which makes this creamery a genuine destination for people who seek it out. The fluid raw milk here comes straight from the farm’s grass-fed herd, bottled without the processing that strips away much of its natural flavor.
First-time drinkers often describe the taste as cleaner and richer than anything they have bought at a grocery store.
The cottage cheese deserves its own moment of recognition. It has developed a quietly passionate following among visitors who describe it as the best they have ever tasted, praising both its texture and its fresh, mild flavor.
For cottage cheese enthusiasts, that is not a small claim. People who try it once tend to return specifically for it on every subsequent visit.
Both products reflect the farm’s broader commitment to minimal processing and maximum freshness. When you can trace your food back to a specific herd on a specific hillside in Potter County, something about the eating experience changes in a way that is hard to explain but very easy to taste.
Baked Goods That Steal the Show From the Ice Cream
The ice cream gets most of the attention, but the baked goods at this creamery have their own devoted audience. The chocolate sheet cake has been called the best by visitors who consider themselves serious judges of such things.
Homemade bread, cinnamon buns, chocolate chip cookies, peanut butter cookies, and Monster Cookies all make regular appearances in the store, alongside seasonal items like Wild Leek Bread.
The kitchen also produces prepared foods that lean toward comfort: soups like Chicken Parm, baked oatmeal, pasta salads, and ready-to-make meals that give the creamery an almost general-store quality. These items rotate based on what the kitchen is preparing that week, so the selection is never entirely predictable.
Brownies have earned their own fans among repeat visitors, with the homemade version described as rich and satisfying in a way that feels distinct from anything store-bought. The baked goods section alone is worth building a cooler and a road trip around, especially for visitors who want to bring a little piece of the farm home with them.
What “God’s Country” Actually Means Up Here
Potter County earned the nickname “God’s Country” for reasons that become obvious the moment you crest a hill and see the landscape spread out in every direction. The rolling terrain, the dense forests, the quiet that settles over everything, and the exceptionally dark night skies combine to create an atmosphere that feels genuinely removed from the modern world.
This is part of the Pennsylvania Wilds, a region defined by its natural character rather than its development.
The creamery’s name is not just clever branding. It is a direct acknowledgment of the land that makes the whole operation possible.
The grass-based diet the herd enjoys, the clean air, the unhurried pace of life on the farm, all of it connects back to the environment surrounding Ulysses and the northern hills of Pennsylvania.
Summer evenings here have a particular quality, with the herd grazing across the hillsides as the light fades and the sky darkens into something spectacular. For visitors who have never experienced truly dark skies, Potter County offers one of the best opportunities on the entire eastern seaboard to do exactly that.
The Ice Cream Trail and a Creamery That Belongs on It
God’s Country Creamery is one of the participating stops on “Scooped: An Ice Cream Trail,” a statewide Pennsylvania initiative that connects visitors with working dairy farms through their most crowd-pleasing product. The creamery was specifically invited to join because very few dairy operations north of Route 80 were represented, leaving the Pennsylvania Wilds largely off the map for trail participants.
Being part of the trail has helped draw new visitors who might not have otherwise made the drive to Ulysses. Families with kids find the combination of farm animals, fresh air, and ice cream sampling to be an ideal day out.
The trail format also encourages people to think about where their dairy comes from and to appreciate the farm families who produce it.
For the Bachman and Peangatelli families, participation in the trail is both a promotional opportunity and a point of pride. Their creamery represents a corner of Pennsylvania that rarely gets this kind of spotlight, and the attention has been well-deserved.
The northern tier of the state has always had its own quiet charm, and the ice cream trail is finally helping people discover it.
Practical Tips for Your First Visit to the Farm Store
A few practical details will make your first visit much smoother. The store accepts cash and Venmo only, so arriving without either means leaving empty-handed.
An ATM is not exactly around the corner out here, so plan ahead. Most visitors recommend bringing more cash than you think you will need, because the selection has a way of expanding your shopping list the longer you browse.
Bring a cooler. This is genuinely important advice, not just a suggestion.
The ice cream, raw milk, cottage cheese, and frozen meats all benefit from cold transport, especially on a warm summer day. A metal spoon is also worth tossing in the bag, since the dense, rich ice cream can defeat a standard plastic spoon fairly quickly.
The store is open every day of the year, with hours running from 5:30 AM to 9 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, and 5:30 AM to 7 PM the rest of the week. The phone number is 814-848-7262 if you want to check on specific product availability before making the drive.
The website at godscountrycreamery.com also keeps visitors updated on seasonal offerings and special items.
Share this story
