Some of the best meals in North Carolina hide behind the plainest front doors, the kind you might drive past a dozen times without a second look. Then one day you pull in, hungry and a little curious, and the smell of fried chicken and simmering greens hits you like a hug from someone’s grandmother.
Suddenly you understand why folks drive hours just to fill a plate here. This is the story of a no-frills buffet that turned out to be a whole lot more than lunch.
A Soul Food Landmark on Oleander Drive
Wilmington is famous for beaches, riverfront strolls, and historic streets, yet one of its most talked-about stops sits right along a busy stretch of road. Casey’s Buffet lives at 5559 Oleander Dr, a sprawling, no-frills spot built around one simple promise: all-you-can-eat Southern cooking.
Nobody comes here for fancy decor. Guests come for barbecue, fried chicken, and a long line of sides served at lunch and dinner, the kind of food that tastes like a family reunion.
Visitors talk about it as a place you cherish once you find it. Some locals have been eating here since childhood, while travelers heading toward Wrightsville Beach or further south stop in and leave planning their next visit.
For a city known for its coastline, it’s a little funny that a buffet on a commercial road ends up being the memory people carry home.
Owners Who Greet You Like Family
Ask regulars what makes Casey’s special, and plenty of them start with the people running it. Owner Larry Casey gets described as a wonderful man with a heart for people and a real passion for food.
Guests also mention meeting Gena, an owner with a smile that seems to light up the whole room. One family said she made them feel right at home from the moment they sat down.
Another visitor simply called the owners some of the nicest people you could meet.
That warmth matters at a family-run spot. When the folks in charge walk the dining room, chat with tables, and check on first-timers, a quick meal starts to feel like Sunday dinner at a relative’s house.
It’s a big reason people who stumble in once tend to come back again and again, sometimes bringing friends along to share the discovery.
Fried Chicken That Earns a Road Trip
Crunchy outside, juicy inside. That’s how diners keep describing the fried chicken here, and it shows up in conversation more than almost anything else on the line.
One road-tripper heading south said it came very close to his favorite chicken from Memphis, which is high praise from someone who clearly takes fried chicken seriously. Others simply pile drumsticks and thighs onto their plates and go back for more.
Fair warning, though: experiences can vary. A few guests have found pieces drier than expected or noticed trays stacked high, so arriving when fresh batches come out may help.
Staff are said to restock the buffet steadily, which keeps things moving during busy hours.
Pair the chicken with mashed potatoes, gravy, and corn, a combo one visitor said compliments everything else on the plate. It’s simple, filling, and exactly what a Southern buffet should be.
Barbecue, Pork Chops, and Hearty Meats
Barbecue sits right at the heart of this place, and Google describes Casey’s first and foremost as a stop for all-you-can-eat BBQ. The pulled pork gets called moist and tender, the sort of thing that sends people straight back for seconds.
Meat lovers have more to explore than just barbecue. Regulars rave about fried pork chops and roast, and fried fish and catfish come up often too.
One guest said the fried fish was a highlight even on a visit that didn’t win them over completely.
Eastern North Carolina has a proud pork tradition, so finding good barbecue near the coast feels right at home. Here, it shares space with Southern classics rather than standing alone.
Build your plate slowly. With this many meats, the smartest move is a small taste of each before committing to a second round of favorites.
Old-School Dishes You Rarely See Anymore
Pig feet, chitlins, and other old-fashioned favorites make Casey’s stand out from chain buffets. These recipes come from a time when nothing went to waste, and families turned humble cuts into dishes worth gathering around.
Fans say the pig feet fall right off the bone and melt with each bite. Another guest said the chitterlings were prepared with care and worth trying for anyone who loves authentic soul food.
Not everyone agrees, of course. One out-of-state buyer felt the chitterlings mixed in other pork parts and wasn’t happy, so if you have strong preferences, it may help to ask staff before ordering a takeout pint.
Still, for many travelers, finding these traditional plates is the whole point of the trip. They taste like history, served hot, and they’re hard to track down at most restaurants today.
Collards, Mac, and a Parade of Sides
Here’s a secret about great Southern cooking: sides often steal the show. At Casey’s, the vegetable line runs long.
Collard greens are a frequent favorite, and guests also name green beans, okra, sweet potatoes, cheesy mac, potato salad, and biscuits. One road-tripper listed collards right alongside pig feet and fried chicken as proof of Southern food at its best.
Opinions do differ on certain dishes. One first-time diner felt the mac and cheese and potato salad needed more flavor while loving the sweet potatoes, so tasting a spoonful before loading up makes sense.
Variety is the real win. A plate here can hold three meats and five vegetables without any guilt, and that freedom is exactly why buffets exist.
Grab a biscuit to mop up the last of the greens, then wander back for whatever caught your eye the first time.
The Cobbler Corner and Its Sweet Rewards
Save room. Seriously.
The dessert section might be the most dangerous part of the building.
Guests describe a spread of cobblers, crisps, banana pudding, cakes, cookies, and ice cream. Peach cobbler and banana pudding come up again and again, and one visitor loved a peach crisp topped with ice cream.
A self-described sweet-tooth fan tried the apple and blueberry cobbler and called it crispy, crunchy, hot, and amazing. Their advice to fellow dessert lovers?
Get one, no matter how full you feel.
Cobbler has deep roots in Southern kitchens, where cooks turned seasonal fruit and simple dough into something cozy. Eating a warm bowl here feels like a nod to that tradition.
Pro tip: grab your dessert while it’s fresh from the oven, then let a scoop of ice cream melt over the top while you finish your coffee.
A Dining Room That Smells Like Grandma’s House
Walk inside and your nose gets the news first. Fried chicken, pork chops, and collard greens fill the air, and one guest said the smell sent him right back to his grandmother’s kitchen.
Lunch hour brings plenty of elders, which tells you something about how trusted this place is locally. One visitor felt the whole vibe, from the layout to the people, echoed grandma’s cooking.
Let’s be honest, it’s not a magazine-ready room. Some guests have mentioned cleanliness concerns and warm temperatures on certain visits, so expectations should match a casual, lived-in spot.
For many, though, that’s part of the charm. Strangers smile across tables, staff chat easily, and the mood stays relaxed.
One couple said they enjoyed the company and the community as much as the food, which says plenty about why people keep returning.
Servers Who Keep Your Glass Full
Buffets aren’t usually known for table service, but Casey’s flips that idea. Servers come by often, keep water glasses full, and make sure you have what you need.
Diners describe the staff as friendly, attentive, and easy to talk with. One family returning after years away said their waitress was out of this world and made them feel at home.
Another group singled out a server named Corrine for treating them so kindly.
Here’s a surprise many visitors don’t expect: one guest reported that the kitchen will take a request and cook something on the spot. That kind of flexibility is rare at an all-you-can-eat spot.
Workers also stay busy restocking trays, which helps the line keep pace with the lunch crowd. Even critical guests have praised the service, so good manners clearly run deep in this dining room.
Catering for Birthdays and Big Gatherings
Planning a party? Casey’s food travels beyond the dining room.
One mom shared that the restaurant helped make her daughter’s birthday celebration extra special. Guests kept complimenting the flavor, and several asked where the food came from, promising to order in the future.
That’s a pretty sweet endorsement for a family event. When a birthday crowd leaves full and curious, the cooks clearly did something right.
Takeout is another option for folks heading home or out of town. Some travelers even buy pints of their favorite dishes to carry back to other states.
One heads-up: a delivery customer wasn’t happy with a recent app order, so picking up in person may help you get the freshest results. For gatherings, calling ahead at 910-798-2913 lets you talk through plans directly with the staff.
Hours, Prices, and Planning Your Stop
Timing matters, because Casey’s keeps a slightly unusual schedule. The buffet is closed Monday and Tuesday, then open Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 9 PM.
That makes it easy to plan a weekend beach day around a big Southern lunch. One couple did exactly that, stopping in before heading to the sand, and it’s a smart plan in summer when the coast is calling.
Pricing is described as reasonable for a buffet, and many guests feel it’s worth what they pay. A critical visitor compared the cost to a big chain buffet, so expect standard all-you-can-eat pricing rather than bargain-bin rates.
Find it at 5559 Oleander Dr, a straightforward drive from downtown Wilmington. Check the website at caseysbuffet.com for current details, and remember a weekday lunch may be calmer than a busy weekend dinner.
Why the Drive Might Be Worth It
One devoted fan says they drive four hours each way just to eat here. That kind of loyalty doesn’t happen by accident.
Casey’s isn’t perfect. Some visitors have left disappointed by cleanliness or certain dishes, and it’s fair to know that before you go.
Yet many more walk away full, happy, and already planning their return.
What keeps the fans coming is the mix: crispy chicken, tender barbecue, rare old-school recipes, warm cobbler, and owners who treat strangers like neighbors. A first-timer even called the meal life changing.
If you love food with a story, soulful flavors, and no-fuss comfort, this Wilmington buffet deserves a spot on your next coastal trip. Come hungry, try a little of everything, and leave room for cobbler.
You might just become one of those folks who plans a whole road trip around a plate of collards.
Share this story
