Unearth The Voyage
Florida has a lot going for it, but the pie scene might just be the sweetest secret of all. From the Florida Keys to the Atlantic coast, local pie shops are turning out slices so good that visitors drive hours just for a taste.
Key lime pie gets most of the spotlight, but there are also cream pies, pecan pies, and indulgent creations that deserve serious attention. Whether you’re a longtime Florida local or just passing through, these 12 pie shops are absolutely worth stopping for.
Kermit’s Key Lime Shop – Key West
Walk into Kermit’s and the smell of fresh-baked Key lime pie hits you before you even reach the counter. This Key West shop has become so well-known that it’s practically a required stop on any Florida road trip.
VISIT FLORIDA even lists it as a classic Keys experience, which tells you everything you need to know.
The menu goes way beyond a standard slice. Chocolate-dipped Key lime pie on a stick is the crowd favorite, and it’s easy to see why.
The tart, creamy filling wrapped in smooth chocolate is the kind of snack that makes people stop mid-bite just to appreciate it.
Kermit’s also carries Key lime candies, cookies, and bars for anyone who wants to take the flavor home. The shop has a fun, laid-back vibe that perfectly matches its Key West location.
First-timers rarely leave without buying more than they planned.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop – Miami & Fort Lauderdale
Former firefighter Derek Kaplan traded in his gear for a rolling pin, and honestly, South Florida is better for it. Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop built its reputation on pies that are unapologetically rich, bold, and impossible to forget.
The backstory alone makes the first bite taste even better.
The “World Famous Key Lime Pie” is the headliner, but regulars know to explore the full menu. Every pie on the shelf looks like it was made to impress, and the taste backs that up completely.
Miami and Fort Lauderdale both have locations, so there’s really no excuse to skip it.
What sets this shop apart is the personality behind it. Derek started with a passion for baking and turned it into a full-on dessert destination.
The pies feel handcrafted rather than mass-produced, which makes every visit feel a little special. Fans keep coming back for that reason alone.
Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village – Sarasota
Yoder’s has been feeding Sarasota for decades, and the pies are the reason most people keep coming back. The Amish Village setting gives the whole place a warm, unhurried feel, like you’ve stepped into a slower, sweeter version of Florida.
That atmosphere alone makes the pie taste better.
Whole pies are available to take home, which is dangerous information for anyone with a sweet tooth. The connected Piecraft Coffee shop makes it easy to pair a slice with a great cup of coffee without going anywhere else.
It’s the kind of setup that turns a quick stop into a two-hour afternoon.
The homemade quality here is obvious from the first forkful. Yoder’s doesn’t rush its recipes, and the results speak for themselves.
Whether you order cream pie, fruit pie, or something seasonal, the consistency is impressive. Sarasota locals treat this place like a well-kept neighborhood secret worth sharing.
Bob Roth’s New River Groves + Davie
Old-school Florida charm is alive and well at Bob Roth’s New River Groves, a citrus stand in Davie that has quietly become one of the best pie stops in the state. Terry’s pies are the main attraction here, and the lineup is genuinely impressive.
Key lime, coconut cream, banana cream, chocolate mousse, pecan, apple, and more all share space in the display case.
The variety alone makes this place stand out. Most specialty pie spots focus on one or two flavors, but Bob Roth’s goes wide without sacrificing quality.
Each pie tastes like it was made by someone who actually cares about the outcome, not just the volume.
Regulars say the coconut cream and banana cream pies are especially hard to resist. The citrus stand setting adds a nostalgic Florida roadside feel that big-city bakeries just can’t replicate.
If you’re driving through Davie, pulling over here is a very smart decision.
The Florida Key Lime Pie Company – Cocoa Beach
Cocoa Beach has the ocean, the surf, and now a very good reason to stay off the beach for a few minutes. The Florida Key Lime Pie Company serves up slices, whole pies, and the crowd-pleasing Key lime pie on a stick, all made with the kind of care that keeps people talking long after they leave.
VISIT FLORIDA has flagged this spot as a must-try, which lines up with what locals and tourists have been saying for years. The tart, creamy filling hits exactly the right balance, and the crust holds up without crumbling all over your hands.
That sounds basic, but it’s harder to pull off than it looks.
The tropical dessert menu extends beyond Key lime, giving indecisive visitors a welcome problem to solve. The shop has a breezy, beachy feel that matches the Cocoa Beach vibe perfectly.
First-time visitors almost always leave with more than one item in their hands.
Blue Heaven – Key West
Blue Heaven might be the most photogenic restaurant in all of Key West, and the Key lime pie somehow matches the atmosphere. Roosters wander the outdoor seating area, string lights hang from the trees, and somewhere in the middle of all that, someone is eating one of the best slices of pie in Florida.
Food and Wine has listed Blue Heaven alongside Kermit’s as a top spot for Key lime pie in the state, which is serious company to keep. The pie is creamy, tart, and just sweet enough, served with a fluffy whipped cream topping that finishes everything off perfectly.
The full restaurant experience is worth it on its own, but plenty of people stop in just for dessert. Blue Heaven has a loyal following that stretches well beyond Key West regulars.
Once you’ve had the pie here, it becomes your new benchmark for every other Key lime pie you try.
Joe’s Stone Crab Take Away – Miami Beach
Joe’s Stone Crab is one of the most famous restaurants in Miami Beach, and the Key lime pie has somehow earned its own loyal following completely separate from the stone crab fame. That’s impressive when you think about it.
The dessert is holding its own against one of the most iconic seafood dishes in Florida history.
The Take Away counter is the move for anyone who wants the pie without waiting for a full sit-down meal. The Key lime pie here is dense, smooth, and rich in a way that feels intentional rather than accidental.
It’s the kind of slice that makes you slow down and actually pay attention.
Miami Beach visitors often treat it as a standalone dessert stop, grabbing a slice before heading back to the beach. The combination of the legendary restaurant name and a genuinely excellent pie makes this one of the most satisfying dessert detours in South Florida.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen – Key Largo
License plates cover the walls, the menu is written on chalkboards, and the Key lime pie is the kind of thing people mention by name when they talk about their Florida Keys trips. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo is one of those places that feels completely authentic, because it genuinely is.
Sitting right on the Overseas Highway, it’s the perfect mid-Keys stop for anyone driving between Key West and the mainland. The casual, no-fuss atmosphere is part of the appeal.
Nobody here is pretending to be fancy, and the food is better for it.
The Key lime pie has a loyal fan base that includes both longtime locals and first-time tourists. The filling is creamy with a good tart punch, and the graham cracker crust has the right amount of crunch.
Mrs. Mac’s proves that a great pie doesn’t need a fancy setting to make a lasting impression on everyone who tries it.
Key Lime Pie Bakery – Key West
Some shops try to do everything. Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West made a very different choice: do one thing and do it exceptionally well.
The entire shop leans into the local dessert, and the focus shows in every single slice they serve. There’s no distraction, just really good pie.
Housemade Key lime pies are available by the slice or as whole pies to take home, making it easy to bring a taste of the Keys back with you. The shop also carries gifts and souvenirs, so it doubles as a fun stop for travelers looking for something more memorable than a magnet.
The filling here is smooth and properly tart, made the way Key lime pie is supposed to be made. Regulars appreciate that the bakery doesn’t cut corners or mess with the classic recipe.
When a shop commits this fully to one dessert, the result is usually worth every bite.
Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe – DeLand
Not everyone can make the trip down to Key West, and Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe in DeLand is a very welcome solution to that problem. The DeLand location brings the full Kermit’s experience north, including authentic Key lime pies, bars, cookies, candies, and a whole lineup of citrus treats that would make any Keys fan happy.
The pies here carry the same quality that made the Key West original famous. Kermit’s doesn’t dilute the recipe just because the location changed.
That consistency is exactly what loyal customers count on when they stop in.
DeLand locals love having a world-class Key lime destination without the drive south, and visitors passing through Central Florida get a genuine taste of Keys culture in an unexpected spot. The shop is cheerful, citrus-scented, and stocked with enough options to make choosing difficult.
It’s the kind of place that turns a five-minute stop into a twenty-minute browsing session.
Mangrove Mama’s – Summerland Key
Tucked into the greenery of Summerland Key, Mangrove Mama’s feels like a place that was specifically designed to be discovered by people who take the scenic route. The tropical setting is relaxed and unhurried, and the Key lime pie fits that energy perfectly.
Creamy, tart, and served without any unnecessary fuss.
After a plate of fresh seafood, finishing with a slice of Key lime pie here feels like the most natural thing in the world. The combination of the lush surroundings, the easy atmosphere, and genuinely good dessert makes for a meal that’s hard to forget.
Repeat visitors often say it’s the pie that brings them back.
Mangrove Mama’s has a devoted following among Keys regulars who appreciate a spot that doesn’t try too hard. The pie speaks for itself without any marketing or hype needed.
Sometimes the best food comes from the places that look the most unassuming from the road.
The S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill – Marathon
Marathon locals don’t need a flashy sign or a famous name to know where the good pie is. The S.S.
Wreck and Galley Grill has built a devoted reputation through word of mouth, one slice at a time. The Key lime pie here is simple, creamy, and exactly what you want after a long day on the water.
The filling is smooth with a satisfying tartness, and the crust is sturdy enough to hold everything together without overpowering the flavor. That balance is trickier to achieve than most people realize, and this kitchen gets it right consistently.
Regulars appreciate that the recipe doesn’t change just to chase trends.
There’s something refreshing about a pie that doesn’t need a gimmick to stand out. The S.S.
Wreck and Galley Grill delivers a very Florida experience: good food, relaxed setting, and a dessert worth talking about. Marathon may be a small town, but its pie game is anything but small.
