One seafood counter on Raritan Bay still sells fried fish by the pound, the old-school way. That detail alone made me hungry before I even knew what else was on the menu.
Then I kept finding more places like it across New Jersey. A lobster market near the water that closes by midafternoon.
A crab cake shop on a busy highway. A gourmet counter selling hummus and local cheese right beside the fish.
What they share is simple. Each one will pack up a seafood platter for you, so dinner rides home in the passenger seat while you try not to snack at red lights.
I love that idea for a weeknight, a backyard get-together, or a lazy Sunday. No reservations, no dress code, just a box full of shrimp and a fork.
So which counter is closest to your kitchen?
1. Keyport Fishery

Fried fish sold by the pound sounds like something from your grandparents’ era, and that is exactly the charm here. Keyport Fishery calls itself a storied seafood market and take-out spot, and it wears that label proudly.
The menu covers a lot of comfort ground. You’ll find soups, sandwiches, platters, and fried fish by the pound, all ready to travel.
Shrimp platters are a smart place to start. They’re built for the drive home, so dinner can still be hot when you finally open the lid at your own table.
The setting helps too. The shop sits on West Front Street in Keyport, a bayside town looking out over Raritan Bay.
It’s the kind of address that makes a seafood run feel right.
Plan around the calendar a little. The market is closed on Mondays, and it opens at 9 AM Tuesday through Sunday.
Friday and Saturday afternoons into the evening tend to get busy. If you’d rather breeze in and out, mornings on most days are usually calmer.
Hours run a bit later at the end of the week. You can stop in until 8 PM on Friday and Saturday, and until 7 PM on the other open days.
Getting there is easy on the nerves. There’s a free parking lot plus free street parking, so you won’t circle the block for long.
One practical heads-up: there’s no restroom and no delivery. Think of it as a grab-and-go mission with a delicious reward waiting at home.
Address: 150 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735
2. Bob’s Seafood Market of Northfield

Seven days a week, the doors open at 10 AM. That steady schedule makes Bob’s Seafood Market of Northfield a rare friend in the dinner-planning department.
Monday cravings don’t have to wait here. Plenty of seafood shops take that day off, but this one keeps the counter going right through the week.
So what’s the draw? The market pairs fresh fish with prepared seafood platters, which means you can choose your own adventure.
Feeling ambitious? Grab fresh fish and cook it your way.
Feeling tired? Let the platter do the heavy lifting and call it a win.
The takeout platters are a big part of the reputation. They pair nicely with prices that feel reasonable for good seafood, which never hurts.
You’ll find the shop on Tilton Road in Northfield, an Atlantic County town just inland from the shore. It’s an easy stop for mainland neighbors heading home.
Timing can make the trip smoother. Friday evening and Saturday afternoon into the evening are the busiest stretches.
Quieter windows show up on Sunday morning, much of Monday, and Tuesday or Wednesday mornings. Saturday morning is also a calmer bet before the weekend rush builds.
The doors close at 7 PM daily, so don’t cut it too close after work. There’s no restroom and no delivery, so plan for a quick pickup.
Honestly, a platter on a random Tuesday might be the best kind of treat. Nobody needs a special occasion for shrimp.
Address: 1121 Tilton Rd, Northfield, NJ 08225
3. Lusty Lobster

With a name like Lusty Lobster, subtlety was never the plan. This long-standing market on Bay Avenue in Highlands puts shellfish front and center.
Fresh lobsters lead the lineup. Clams and oysters round out the case, giving raw bar fans plenty to consider.
Hosting a crowd is where this stop really shines. A shrimp, lobster, and snow crab platter makes a showstopper spread for a few friends at home.
Think about it for a second. You get the wow factor of a seafood tower without boiling a single pot in your kitchen.
Highlands has deep ties to the water, sitting along the bay near the Shrewsbury River. A shellfish market in this spot feels perfectly at home.
Now for the part that trips people up. The hours are short, running Tuesday through Saturday from 9 AM to 3 PM.
The shop is closed on Sundays and Mondays. If your party is Saturday night, a morning pickup is the move.
Calling ahead for a big platter is a smart idea, especially for a gathering. That way the spread is ready when you pull up.
In-store shopping is available, but delivery is not. Bring a cooler if the drive home is long, because those lobsters deserve respect.
Here’s a fun little New Jersey twist: Highlands sits just below one of the highest coastal points on the Atlantic seaboard. Your platter gets a scenic send-off.
Address: 88 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
4. Metropolitan Seafood & Gourmet

Hummus, craft bread, and local cheese next to a fish counter? That combo makes Metropolitan Seafood & Gourmet feel more like a food lover’s playground than a fish shop.
The heart of the place is still seafood. Fresh fish sits at the counter, and oysters on the half shell are part of the appeal.
Takeout is where things get tempting. The fried fisherman’s platter is a standout, and the clam chowder makes a strong sidekick.
Prepared foods round out the lineup. You can build a whole dinner here, from main dish to bread to a cheese course.
You’ll find it along Route 22 in Lebanon, out in Hunterdon County. It’s a handy stop for western New Jersey households far from the coast.
Hours are generous during the week. The shop runs Tuesday through Saturday from 9 AM to 7 PM, and Sunday from 9 AM to 4 PM.
Mondays are closed, so plan your fish fix accordingly. Friday and Saturday afternoons into evening are the busiest times to visit.
Want an easier trip? Weekday mornings and Sunday mornings tend to be calmer, which leaves more time to browse.
Practical perks stack up here. There’s a free lot, free street parking, and a restroom, which is a nice bonus on a longer drive.
Delivery is offered too. That means your platter might come to you on a night when leaving the couch feels unrealistic.
Address: 1320 US-22, Lebanon, NJ 08833
5. Capt’n Chucky’s Crab Cake Co Cinnaminson,NJ

Crab cakes get top billing right in the name, and honestly, that’s a confident move. Capt’n Chucky’s Crab Cake Co in Cinnaminson builds its whole identity around them.
Of course, the menu doesn’t stop there. Lobster rolls and other specialty seafood items share the spotlight.
Platters are a big part of the fun. They let you skip the decision stress and bring home a mix of seafood in one go.
South Jersey readers know Route 130 as a busy stretch. Finding a specialty crab cake shop in Suite 5A feels like a treat along the commute.
The Burlington County location makes it easy for nearby towns. It’s a practical pickup on the way home from work or errands.
Now, about the clock. The shop opens Tuesday through Friday from 11 AM to 6 PM.
Weekends run shorter. Saturday hours are 10 AM to 4 PM, and Sunday wraps up at 2 PM.
Mondays are closed, so don’t plan a Monday crab cake craving here. Sunday lunch, though, could become a lovely new habit.
In-store shopping is available, so you can see what’s on hand before choosing. That’s handy when you can’t decide between crab and lobster.
Here’s a friendly tip for platter nights. Order with your guest count in mind, because crab cakes tend to vanish faster than anyone admits.
Address: 202 US-130 Ste 5A, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077
Share this story

