Some of the best food finds in South Carolina hide right along the highway, easy to zoom past without a second look. Imagine catching the scent of warm bread and cookies before you even reach the front door.
There’s a little store near the coast where the baked goods come out of the oven still warm, and once you stop, you’ll understand why folks keep coming back. Get ready to leave with your arms full and your car smelling amazing.
A Roadside Stop Worth Pulling Over For
Cruising down Highway 17 South in North Myrtle Beach, you might spot a colorful storefront that practically waves you down. Country Living Amish Store sits at 4403 Hwy 17 S, and plenty of travelers admit they drove past it for years before finally stopping.
The front is packed with handmade wooden lawn decor, bright and inviting, making it nearly impossible to miss. It’s technically a grocery store, but that label barely scratches the surface of what waits inside.
Regulars who finally pull in describe it as an instant “must-stop” for every future trip. The delicious smells hit you before you even reach the door, a friendly hint of the fresh bakery goodness ahead.
If you’ve been meaning to check it out, consider this your reason to finally hit the brakes.
Warm Bread Straight From The Oven
Few things beat bread so fresh it’s still warm when you carry it to the register. That’s the everyday reality here, where loaves are baked daily and the aroma greets you at the entrance.
Visitors rave about the banana bread and banana nut bread, and one shopper walked out clutching a bread pudding like a treasure. The variety runs deep, with breads, bagels, cakes, and more lined up fresh.
A handy bonus regulars mention: the staff will even slice the bread for you right there. That means it’s ready for sandwiches, toast, or just tearing into during the drive home.
Grabbing a warm loaf feels less like grocery shopping and more like visiting a friend’s kitchen. Just be warned, one loaf rarely makes it home untouched.
Cookies So Big You’ll Share Them
Picture a cookie so enormous a family of three can split just one. That’s the delightful problem shoppers face here, where the cookies come XXL and still warm from the baking sheet.
Choosing a flavor is the real challenge. Fans swear by the chocolate chip, the ginger molasses, and the peanut butter, and one visitor was told all three were the “best,” leaving them happily stuck.
Whoopie pies also make the list of treats worth grabbing. Even better, staff have shared that the cookies freeze well, so you can stock up for a road trip.
One family remembers an employee handing their five-year-old a giant warm cookie straight off the tray. Moments like that turn a quick stop into a lasting memory.
Pies, Cakes, And Sweet Surprises
Beyond bread and cookies, the bakery case hides even more temptations. Pies and cakes round out the daily lineup, joining candies and other sweet goodies that make browsing dangerous for your willpower.
Shoppers describe the baked goods as delicious across the board, with fresh items made fresh throughout the day. Cinnamon rolls earn their own fan club, showing up in reviews as a favorite worth seeking out.
What makes it extra fun is that free samples are often set out, letting you taste before you commit. That’s a smart move, because it usually means you’ll grab more than you planned.
Whether you’re after a full pie for dessert or a single sweet treat for the ride, the selection keeps things interesting. Sweet tooths, consider yourselves warned.
Jams, Jellies, And Pantry Treasures
Nostalgia hits hard in the pantry section, where rows of jams and jellies wait to be discovered. One visitor spotted a jar of Damson Plum Jam and nearly teared up, since they hadn’t tasted it since their grandmother’s kitchen over sixty years ago.
The variety is impressive, including sugar-free options for those watching their sugar. Canned goods like beets fill the shelves too, adding to that classic Amish-country feel.
Shoppers from Ohio, familiar with real Amish country, praised the authentic grocery selection. You’ll also find cheese and Trail Bologna, a specialty tied to Trail, Ohio.
Prepared soups are on the menu as well, with one visitor eager to try them on a return trip. It’s the kind of pantry that rewards slow, curious browsing.
Handcrafted Decor And Gifts Galore
Not everything worth taking home comes from the bakery. The store overflows with handmade wooden lawn decor, unique gifts, and crafts that catch the eye at every turn.
Seasonal shoppers love the handcrafted fall and Halloween outdoor decorations, praising the fabulous craftsmanship and quality. Beach-themed items, large outdoor lighthouses, and wind chimes give the coastal crowd plenty to admire.
Custom-built indoor and outdoor furniture is a big draw too, and while the pieces lean pricier, visitors note the high quality backs it up. There’s even a nice section for cat and dog items.
One shopper joked you can easily spend three hundred dollars without realizing it, so keep an eye on your basket. Browsers say they never get bored, always finding something new to admire.
Ice Cream And Quick Bites
Who can say no to ice cream? Not the many shoppers who light up when they mention the ice cream counter tucked inside the store.
Beyond the sweet scoops, there’s a genuine snack lineup to keep hungry visitors happy. Chips, drinks, and quick food items like nachos and hot dogs round out the offerings.
Plenty of snacks and drinks make it an easy pit stop during a long beach day. Families appreciate having grab-and-go options alongside the fresh baked treasures.
It’s the kind of spot where you can nibble something on the spot while deciding which loaves and cookies to take home. Between the bakery and the counter, nobody leaves hungry.
Consider it a delicious two-for-one: shop the shelves and snack while you browse.
Friendly Faces And A Welcoming Feel
Warmth here isn’t just coming from the ovens. Time and again, visitors highlight how friendly and welcoming the owner, his daughter, and the whole staff are.
Little kindnesses stand out, like an employee checking for allergies before handing a child a warm cookie. Another shopper recalled the woman at the register being especially sweet during their visit.
The store has also shown a community spirit, at one point collecting donations for hurricane relief and helping items reach people who truly needed them. That kind of heart leaves an impression.
Regulars describe staff as attentive, happy, and genuinely glad to see you. Between the homemade goods and the down-to-earth hospitality, it’s easy to see why families make it a repeat stop.
You come for the bread and stay for the good company.
Planning Your Visit
Ready to go? You’ll find Country Living Amish Store at 4403 Hwy 17 S in North Myrtle Beach, an easy stop right along the highway.
Give them a ring at +1 843-427-4004 with any questions before you head out.
Parking is plentiful, and shoppers note there are no barriers to getting inside, making it accessible and easy to navigate. The interior feels roomy considering how much stock it holds.
Prices earn frequent praise, with many calling them reasonable and even lower than expected. A gentle tip from regulars: if you order custom furniture, ask plenty of questions about timing up front.
Whether you’re browsing crafts or filling a bag with warm cookies, plan a little extra time. There’s more to explore here than one quick pass allows.
Share this story
