Some lunch spots open and close before anyone learns their name. This one in Phoenix has been handing over subs since 1975, back when the Valley looked very different.
Families now bring their kids to the same counter their parents visited decades ago. The sandwiches are so big that splitting one is a smart move, and the pastry case tempts people who came in only for lunch.
There is also a grocery section packed with imported Italian items that can turn a quick stop into a long browse. Out-of-state transplants say it reminds them of the neighborhood delis they left behind in Detroit, St. Louis, and South Philly.
Keep reading to learn the story behind the counter, what to order, when to go, and one money-saving tip worth knowing before you get in line.
A West Dunlap Address Worth Remembering
Plenty of Phoenix strip-mall storefronts blend together, but one on the west side has earned a loyal following for nearly five decades.
Romanelli’s Italian Deli sits at 3437 W Dunlap Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85051, in the heart of the Valley. It works as three businesses rolled into one: a delicatessen, a market, and a bakery.
The menu covers subs, pizza, pasta, and pastries. On the shelves, shoppers find imported Italian ingredients that are hard to track down elsewhere in town.
That mix explains why the place draws such a wide crowd. Office workers grab lunch, families pick up dinner, and home cooks stock their pantries in one trip.
The deli holds a 4.8-star average across more than 3,800 Google ratings, which is a remarkable number for a neighborhood shop. Clearly, the word has gotten out, and it keeps traveling well beyond the zip code.
Five Decades of Family Recipes
Back in 1975, the Romanelli family opened their doors and started serving the Valley. They have not stopped since.
Homemade recipes, imported specialty groceries, and personal service remain the backbone of the business. Many longtime customers describe it as a Phoenix institution rather than just a place to eat.
Family members still play an active role. Regulars mention a son named Robert and the patriarch, often called Papa, by name when talking about the welcome they receive.
The grandfather has been known to stop by tables to check on meals himself. He likes to chat about how long the family has run the business together.
That kind of continuity is rare. Some local families now count trips here as part of their own traditions, passed from one generation to the next like a favorite recipe card that never gets lost.
Subs Built for Serious Appetites
Subs are the stars here, and they come with a warning label of sorts: bring a friend or a big appetite.
Sandwiches are packed with lunch meats, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion. The bread gets as much praise as the fillings, which is no small feat for a deli.
Favorites include the Italian Stallion, George’s Special, The George, and The New Yorker with pastrami. The meatball sub stands out too, loaded generously and toasted so the bread holds up to the sauce.
Half-subs are not offered, so splitting one is a popular strategy. Many guests say the size makes the price feel more than fair.
Not every order lands perfectly. Some find the chicken parm sandwich less impressive than the classic cold subs, so first-timers may want to start with a house specialty and work outward from there.
The Pastry Case Problem
Here is the trouble with ordering a sandwich first: the pastry case is waiting right there at checkout.
Cannolis lead the lineup, including chocolate-covered versions. Eclairs, napoleons, and lobster tail pastries also earn steady attention.
Cheesecake is a frequent pick, with chocolate cheesecake among the options. Tiramisu, limoncello mascarpone cake, chocolate cake, brownies, and even baklava round out the selection.
Many people admit they came for the subs but would return for the desserts alone. Boxes of pastries often leave the building for birthdays and gatherings.
Even guests who had a so-so main course tend to praise the sweets. That says a lot about how consistently the bakery side performs.
A smart move is grabbing an extra box on the way out. Tomorrow’s version of you will be grateful for the planning.
Aisles of Imported Italian Groceries
Lunch might be the reason people walk in, but the grocery section is why many linger.
Shelves are stocked with imported Italian items, from fresh imported pasta to cheeses. Fresh deli meats and bread are available too, making it easy to assemble a meal at home.
Some first-timers get so focused on sandwiches and desserts that they never explore the aisles. They usually promise themselves a return trip just for shopping.
Others face the opposite problem. They browse the grocer area and struggle to decide what to take home because the selection is so broad.
Home cooks who chase authentic ingredients will find this corner especially useful. It saves a long search across multiple stores.
Budget a few extra minutes for wandering. A grocery list here tends to grow longer than planned.
Hot Plates Beyond the Bread
Sandwiches grab headlines, yet the kitchen turns out plenty of hot dishes worth a look.
Spaghetti and meatballs is a standout, served with no shortage of meatballs. Lasagna with meat sauce also earns devoted fans, especially as a takeout dinner.
Pizza and garlic cheese bread appear on many tables during lunch. Cold options such as a bow tie, feta, and pepper salad add variety for lighter eaters.
Travelers who eat out across the country have called the meals some of the best Italian food they have found in years. That is high praise from people with plenty of comparison points.
Dining in is an option, and so is carrying out. Families often mix and match, pairing a pasta dish with a sub and splitting both.
Variety keeps repeat trips interesting, since there is always another dish to try.
Old-School Charm and Friendly Faces
Old-fashioned is the best word for the vibe, and it is meant as a compliment.
The shop is described as clean and welcoming, with a family-run feel that reminds many of delis in Italy. Staff greet customers with smiles and help with menu choices.
Speed impresses too. On a busy Saturday at noon, some orders are ready before payment is finished.
Most experiences are warm, though not universal. A few people have reported toasting requests getting missed or a curt moment at the counter, so double-checking an order never hurts.
Still, the overall tone is friendly and personal. Names are called out when food is ready, and regulars often know the folks behind the counter.
It is the kind of place where a quick lunch can turn into a friendly chat.
A Taste of Home for Transplants
Phoenix is full of people who moved from somewhere else, and many of them miss their old neighborhood delis.
Those transplants find a familiar comfort here. Former Metro Detroit residents, folks from St. Louis’s Hill neighborhood, and East Coasters who grew up near South Philly all draw comparisons.
Some liken it to classic New York or Chicago delis. Others simply say it feels like home.
Visiting relatives often make it a mandatory stop during Arizona trips. Cousins, friends, and out-of-towners get dragged along and usually leave converted.
Locals benefit as well. Construction crews on lunch breaks, nearby office workers, and families looking for a casual meal all fit right in.
People even drive across the Valley from places like Gilbert, braving traffic for a sandwich. That kind of commitment speaks louder than any advertisement.
Hours, Crowds, and a Cash Tip
Timing matters at a place this popular, so a little planning pays off.
Doors open at 9 AM and close at 6 PM, Monday through Saturday. Sunday is a day off, so weekend cravings need to strike on Saturday.
Lunch is peak time. Arriving early helps beat the rush, and parking can get tricky when the shop is packed.
Here is the money-saving tip: bring cash. Card payments carry a 4% processing fee, which adds up on a big pastry order.
Prices for specialty sandwiches can reach around $15, though portions are generous. Sharing one sub stretches the budget nicely.
Calling ahead or checking the website before heading over is a good habit. That way, the trip goes smoothly from parking spot to pastry box.
Why the Line Keeps Coming Back
Nearly fifty years is a long run for any small business, and it rarely happens by accident.
The formula here is simple. Generous subs, a pastry case that tempts everyone, and shelves of imported groceries all live under one roof.
Add a family that still shows up and greets customers, and the loyalty makes sense. Generations of Phoenix families have built memories around food from this counter.
No place is flawless, and a few orders miss the mark. Yet the vast majority of guests leave planning their next trip before they reach the car.
For a first visit, start with a signature sub, grab a few pastries, and save time to browse the aisles. Bring cash and a friend to split with.
Chances are, one trip turns into a habit, and the family behind the counter will happily welcome you back.
Share this story
